School board members defend decision to deny Clinton, allow Obama

by Dustin Grove (grove@wsbt.com)

Tools

Democratic presidential hopefuls Sen. Barack Obama, D-Ill. and Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton, D-N.Y.

Democratic presidential hopefuls Sen. Barack Obama, D-Ill. and Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton, D-N.Y. (AP Photos)

By Beth Boehne

SOUTH BEND — Sen. Barack Obama will speak at Washington High School Wednesday night. That location is a big point of contention with a lot of people.

Just two weeks ago, South Bend Schools denied Sen. Hillary Clinton's request to use the school's gym for her campaign stop.

Tuesday, school board members responded to the outcry, calling Obama's visit a different situation.

Less than two weeks after telling the Clinton campaign "no," the South Bend Community School Corporation is preparing to welcome her opponent to Washington High School.

All day, we've been hearing from hundreds of people by phone and by e-mail wanting to know why.

But School Board President Sheila Bergeron says the superintendent had good reason to veto a visit by Clinton and sign off on a stop by Obama.

"We've never held political things during school hours in the school building,” she explained.

The Clinton campaign wanted its rally at the school mid-morning on a school day.

That, Bergeron says, would've violated the district's long-standing policy against campaigning of any kind during the school day.

But because the Obama camp wants an evening visit and while students are away on spring break, Bergeron says “the situation is different.”

Different, she says, but for others it’s not different enough.

“I don't think it's fair even though they're saying, 'Well it's because he's not during the school day and this is spring break,' it's going to upset a lot of people,” Michelle Richards told WSBT News.

Some of them are still upset over turning down Clinton.

“I went to a high school where they always allowed candidates come in to speak to us about things,” Jennifer Veirs said. “I always thought it enriched our education. It helped broaden our views and I think that's why I've always felt a need to participate.”

One board member says his hands were tied.

"I guess there was no right answer to this,” school board member Bill Sniadecki told WSBT News. “So if we didn't allow him to come in, it's wrong; if we allowed him to come in, it's wrong.”

Sniadecki said he hopes, to be fair, the superintendent will extend an invitation to Clinton — asking her to come back and visit here after hours — and to Republican presidential hopeful John McCain as well.

Saturday, Apr 12 at 10:58 AM Logic and Reasoning wrote ...

I am assuming we are dealing with intelligent mature indivisuals. It seems clear from reading the full report ( I don't know if people are doing this or just jumping on the band wagon be it a racistr one or sexist one)the school has rules and if we are telling our children the rules are there to be followed, the same rule goes for Politicians I don't care who they are. Mr. Obama obviously followed those rules and I am sure all Mrs. Clinton has to do is adjust her schedule and be allowed also.

Saturday, Apr 12 at 10:27 AM Anonymous wrote ...

WAIT... Why not blame the ILLEGALS for this too, it seems like we need to be blaimed for everything else!!!!!

Friday, Apr 11 at 11:14 PM Undecided Hoosier wrote ...

I attended an appearance by former President Clinton today in downstate Indiana. It was held at a high school DURING school hours and all students were allowed to attend. There were no disruptions and the students were quite excited to be able to attend. Taking part in this forum will give them memories they couldn't have made in a normal classroom. South Bend schools missed a great learning experience for their kids.

Friday, Apr 11 at 10:44 AM Anonymous wrote ...

I was shocked SB School Corp said no to Clinton, and then yes to Obama! It's a sad day when decisions like this are made! I really don't think it had anything to do with school being in session. What are we really teaching our kids? And then for SB Mayor to endorse Obama, wow what a surprise! Even the News seemed to air more coverage for Obama. Are you trying to help people decide who to vote for? I have a mind of my own!

Thursday, Apr 10 at 6:40 PM identity crisis wrote ...

Obama broke down and resorted to drugs from identity issues he has, I have to say GO HILLARY. this is a no brainer how to vote for me.

Thursday, Apr 10 at 10:44 AM R. wrote ...

If everyone keeps acting like idiots, and making the democrats look bad, the party is going to split, and fight like WW III then the Republicans will win so stop whining!!!! I am ashamed to even say I am a democrat with all this petty maddness. Is this really important? Is it the end of the World? NO! So get over it.

Thursday, Apr 10 at 9:01 AM Mary wrote ...

Who decided that this should be at Washington? Was it the school board that proposed it or Obama? Either way, it was obvious this was an intentional "up yours" directed at Hillary and all her supporters. How should we take that? That was completely classless.

Thursday, Apr 10 at 8:57 AM Anonymous wrote ...

Sorry to disappoint you, "Cowards". I was spending time with my kids and putting them to bed.

Thursday, Apr 10 at 7:48 AM From Singapore wrote ...

Yes, on the other side of the world we have now heard of South Bend. Any school here would be delighted to have a local politician make a speech. Whether Queen of England, President of China, or dictator, we extend the same courtesy, whatever we think of their politics. It is the OFFICE we respect, not the person. And we are supposed to see this situation emanating from the foremost democracy in the world?

Thursday, Apr 10 at 7:28 AM Glad I dont live in South Bend wrote ...

Why did they have to use the same school when there are plenty other schools in South Bend to use.

Thursday, Apr 10 at 6:16 AM Patty wrote ...

Well School Board, I disagree with you all. Guess what, this is easy for me, I will not vote for any of you again, plain and simple. You all can not even face the fact that it was a bad decision! No to One, No to all!!!! Thats all Zimmerman and board!

Thursday, Apr 10 at 6:02 AM COWARDS wrote ...

HEY WHERE WERE ALL YOU PEOPLE THAT WERE SO AGAINST WHS HAVING THIS RALLY, WHERE WERE THE PROTESTORS? WHATS THE MATTER WHY WEREN'T YOU THERE STANDING UP FOR THER CHILDREN, AND FOR EQUALITY, AND THE SCHOOL BOARD? LET ME GUESS ITS BECAUSE MOST OF THOSE COMMENTS CAME FROM PEOPLE WHO DON'T EVEN LIVE IN SOUTH BEND OR HAVE CHILDREN THAT GO TO SB SCHOOLS, YOU JUST LIKE TO RUN YOUR MOUTHS AS IF YOU REALLY CARE ABOUT SB STUDENTS!WHAT MESSAGE ARE YOU SENDING YOUR KIDS AND COMMUNITIES? WERE YOU SCARED???

Thursday, Apr 10 at 12:39 AM kmccliment wrote ...

The only class I see in Obama is NO CLASS!

Thursday, Apr 10 at 12:38 AM kmccliment wrote ...

Obama was given a choice. Hillary was not.

Thursday, Apr 10 at 12:19 AM Vote Hillary wrote ...

I hope one of the other schools there invite Hillary.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 11:03 PM LINDA MURPHY wrote ...

SO TELL ME WHO IS PLAYING THE RACE CARD EVEN KNOW HE IS HALF WHITE OBAMA MAKES ME SICK HE GETS AWAY WITH ALL THEM LIES AND THE MEDIA LETS HIM GET AWAY AFTER THIS IS ALL OVER I WILL NOT WATCH SOME NEWS STATION THATS BEEN COVERING UP FOR HIM AND BY THE WAY C-B-S IS ONE OF THEM THANK YOU LINDA PA

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 10:46 PM karela wrote ...

Peace brothers and sisters. Mrs. Clinton got to speak her piece. Mr. Obama will get to speak his piece. We will all listen and vote. All is well.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 10:05 PM sherry wrote ...

Like I said when they refused Clinton, If it were Obama or McCain, they would not have denied them. Even if Obama did pay the $800.00 to use the school, and if someone else did set up Clinton's time schedule. It doesn't matter. Everyone knows why this happened. When they denied Clinton, they said it would not be fair to the other candidates to allow her to speak and not the others as well. If I were Clinton, I would not speak there if they begged or paid me.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 9:20 PM tawaun wrote ...

Mr. Obama followed the rules and Mrs. Clinton wanted to make them as she goes. During sring break not interupting school activies ie sports etc. Why is everyone so upset she spoke at Mishawaka High. The school board did what they where supposed to do follow the rules.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 7:12 PM Todd wrote ...

Many of you are wrong. There is a school policy and it is on the internet for all to see. Please read it and come back here to say you are sorry for being rude and wrong. Hillary could of come if it was not during school hours and if she did not block where students could go. The policy says they can come when school is not in session. Her staff made that choice, it is nobody else's fault. The board was only upholding what is in print and not what they felt.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 5:46 PM what rules wrote ...

Why was Hillary not allowed to speak during the school day? Seems like MHS handled it very well. Why didn't Obama choose a different site after all the controversy with Hillary's visit? For all you saying Hillary didn't obey the rules and Obama did it seems like they make up the rules as they go along.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 5:36 PM Michiana Dad wrote ...

Coverage by the media, and access to public buildings should be equal! Allowing one candiate to use the school, and rejecting the other doesn't seem equal. Doesn't set a good example now does it. Perhaps there is more to this, perhaps the power at be at just playing dirty politics.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 5:16 PM Jackie wrote ...

All I can say is I know who I wouldn't be voting for come time for school board elections. In additions to basics, the primary courses that all students have to take to graduate are government and civics. That this school board didn't jump at the opportunity to provide its students with an opportunity to see any and all candidates, regardless of the time of day, shows its members to be ignorant and unworthy of the task for which they were elected.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 5:05 PM Knappyknee wrote ...

There is no denying the fact that there seems to be a racial factor involved in this decision.Having said that, I wouldn't walk across the street to see either one of them!

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 4:43 PM BJ wrote ...

This response if for walker1209. Why are you lying saying that you are a blacl woman, what doe's you skin color have to do with this discussion anyways. Hillary's campaign can have the buliding after hours just like the Obama campaign....what makes her so special???? kis don't need to be exposed to sexual predaters and liars anyways

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 4:37 PM melvin wrote ...

In regards to the one post: The poster forgot to add Zimmerman and a board member who was running for re- election appeared together at a High School Parent/Teacher conference shortly before the election; Clearly illegal. I guess being consistant is a moving target, especially downtown.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 4:05 PM Educator wrote ...

Dan Quale came to Clay High School during my first or second year of teaching - school year 86/87 or school year 87/88. The visit was during the school day, and the entire student body attended an assembly. Perhaps there has been a policy change since then. But the statement that SBCSC has never allowed "political things" during school hours is not true. I am sure Quale's visit is easily verifiable. Even though he was in office, I still considered his visit a political event.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 3:48 PM Ingrid wrote ...

Was it a free venue or did the candidates have to pay for its use? If it was fee paying maybe the school did not want to be stiffed with a bill from the Clinton campaign.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 3:38 PM cameltoe wrote ...

it's their school they can do what they want with it. let the guy talk, chill out and vote your conscience

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 3:27 PM Carolyn wrote ...

Zimmerman is Racist as they come. To deny Hillary but yet allow Obama is a disgrace the SBCSC he took a vote then deciede on NO. There is no school policy on this if there was there would not have been a vote. Just a Racist man. They teach Government to Seniors to graduate and to deny them this privledge is a slap in the face. Government is Government now what do the teacher teach. We should invite McCain as well. But then Zimmerman would say NO to him as well, he's not black. Bring back Joan.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 3:00 PM Your conscience wrote ...

Here are the facts, the United States has had 43 Preidents so far, all of them have one thing in common- they have all been WHITE MEN ....I don't care if the next President is a woman , or man of a different color, I just want this knucklehead in office now gone. Grow up South Bend, and this is coming from a whiteman speaking on this .

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 2:55 PM GA wrote ...

That is the rifht thing to do. Clinton wants to do it during school time and that is not right. OBAMA did the right thing. Hillary should not worry about it anyway. she need to drop out of the race because their is noway she will win. She will come there and lie again and that is not good for student.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 2:36 PM Janet wrote ...

To Blackspirit 3: Regardless of what happened when Clinton was in office (not that your ranting proves any of the allegations you've made) we need someone in office that is going to create jobs and foster a better ecomonic stimulus plan. Look around you, you live in the armpit of America. Change has to occur! If nothing happens educated individuals will continue to seek a better quality of life outside this armpit leaving it completely hopeless.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 2:13 PM Vic wrote ...

Add mis-step to the other mis-talk to mis-manage to the list.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 2:08 PM TB wrote ...

Great civic opportunity to have a candidate appear at a school. Unfortunately students were not going to be allowed at Clinton's visit. No students = no use of facility.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 1:52 PM Marilyn wrote ...

Clinton can fix this easily. Just do what Obama did...have a night-time event during spring break. What is that woman's problem?????

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 1:28 PM Anonymous wrote ...

Are you threatening us, Jake? What are you going to do if this continues? We're not hurting your feelings, are we? Does it bother you that we don't all agree with you? You poor baby.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 12:24 PM Anonymous wrote ...

No, it's not Dick Chaney. Guess again.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 12:21 PM jake wrote ...

all of you people sound like a bunch of cry babies. all of you cry babies should grow up

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 12:03 PM blackspirit3 wrote ...

IN 1992 THE CLINTONS WENT TO THE WHITE HOUSE TO FIX THINGS - The only president ever impeached on grounds of personal malfeasance - Most number of convictions and guilty pleas by friends and associates* - Most number of cabinet officials to come under criminal investigation - Most number of witnesses to flee country or refuse to testify - Most number of witnesses to die suddenly - First president sued for sexual harassment. - First president accused of rape. - First first lady t

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 12:00 PM looking new wrote ...

WSBT,let's have a new topic to talk about. This one is old. It's time to talk about something else.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 11:54 AM walker1209 wrote ...

I am so sick of the double standard between the two Democrats; the Clinton haters are alive and well and supporters of Boy Wonder or BARACK THE MAGNIFICANT want it all their way. I don't really care that Senator Clinton was denied access to the school - but the reasoning sucks!!! I am a Black female who is 59 years old and wouldn't vote for him for dog catcher. I has gotten so that every time I hear his name of see his face I want to hurl!!!

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 11:44 AM J wrote ...

If you have never held anything political during school hours in school then what would you consider allowing people to vote in the school during school hours?

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 11:43 AM Dave wrote ...

This is all about sexism and racism - no matter who is denied and who is allow to speak - sounds as if Dick Cheney runs this school district! Democrats remember Bush, Cheney and their clone McCain are our foes - not each other.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 11:42 AM vromero wrote ...

Maybe the school board also realized that Mrs. Clinton does not pay her bills. UC Davis is taking Mrs. Clinton to court to recover some $25,000 for an event in March. If Mrs. Clinton wants to come to Washington she should be forced to pay in advance.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 11:19 AM John wrote ...

This is all about following the rules, and not about sexism and racism as some people try to make it out to be.As a white university professor, I, along with my children, am honored to be part of this great history in the making and vote for Sen. Obama. Now, will America rise to the occasion and truly unite,showing the world that ONLY in America this can happen,it really is the land of the free? Or,will those whose judgement is clouded by prejudices continue divisive tradition of‘Us’and ‘them?

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 11:13 AM Andrea wrote ...

I don't understand why some people think that it is "shocking" or they are "ashamed" of the state/school. This is just another example of her not following the rules... (1) campaigning in Florida/Michigan...asking to campaign during school hours...not being truthful... not paying her bills on time...it goes on and on...

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 11:11 AM phillyPete wrote ...

I can't believe Clinton supporters can't see the difference between using a School during a school day - or using it at night during break. Are you that loyal that you can't see clearly? Political rallies are very disruptive. You cannot do that to students who need to learn. Hillary can use the gym at night, after hours.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 11:11 AM rachel f wrote ...

As usual Sen. Clinton wants to change the rules. And, when they're not changed, she cries discrimination. Is there no end to her manipulations?

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 11:08 AM Tom wrote ...

According to ABC.com on July 18,2007, Obama believes that Sex Ed. for Kindergarteners is "the right thing to do". Does this reflect the School Board's feelings on this?

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 11:05 AM Nickolas K. wrote ...

Clinton always looking at ways to not follow the rule of law. I wonder how she would do as a president!

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 10:51 AM Johnnie wrote ...

If the rules were as stated, no politics during school hours, why is it so hard for people to understand that Obama played by the rules. It seems to me that it will never be okay for a qualified Black man to be president in this country.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 10:51 AM leonard wrote ...

hilary was probley whanting to stop in to see the kids in the school i dont thank it is right for one to be told know and the other one to be told yes i thank thank any way we vote we will be ran down in the ground becouse thanks to bush look were we are to day if it was not for him our familys would be togeather for the holidays. and what about the gas prices people cant aford that for the little bit of money i make i cant hardly make it to work for the week and take care of my family

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 10:49 AM Sallie Ellis wrote ...

Hillary is just like GW Bush, always looking to break the rules for an unfair advantage, and her own personal wealth. I really think we have had enough of the Bush/Clinton era, and as a NY citizen, I am going to vote for anyone except Clinton!!

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 10:48 AM Tia wrote ...

Has the Clintons Paid UC Davis yet? The Clinton campaign still owe UC Davis couple g last time I checked!

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 10:45 AM Anonymous wrote ...

If it is against the law to for schools to allow politiking during school hours---then Mishawaka (SPELL IT RIGHT C-SAKE!) High clearly broke the rules by allowing Clinton to "rally" (and it was a rally, it was a push for money and join our campaign). It's a shame that some of you can't quite grasp that this is a race and sex issue---Obama has his pastor cloud looming over his head that's about to burst---Clinton is a woman... be realistic. understand politics. ignorant people shouldn't vote.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 10:45 AM bugmom wrote ...

Yada yada yada - It boils down to she's a girl; he's a guy

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 10:45 AM Kathy wrote ...

Would you want to rent out space and have to wait months before you got paid? I don' t think so. Hillary has a hard to e paying her bills . The school board was only looking out for their best interests. Which brings up another question. If Hillary can't pay her bills now, how would she hand the nation's economy that Bush has destroyed?

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 10:43 AM aim high wrote ...

ENOUGH is ENOUGH ALREADY! We have other things happening in this world that we need to be concerned about.Instead of bickering back and fourth on who's to blame. The decision has been made he is coming and that's IT. What about those women and kids that were locked up...What about there's not enough medical supplies in africa to help those babies, What about your child and your family needs. And you all are complaining about a visit. Let's get mature people.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 10:33 AM Anonymous wrote ...

I bet the SBCSC board is proud, knowing this is national news, and everyone can see how pathetic they are. For everyone outside South Bend, we budget over $10K per student per year, but our graduation rate is barely over 50%. We do have a top-of-the-line homeless shelter, though.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 10:33 AM Anonymous wrote ...

I am from south bend and my brother graduated from washinghton high school -- and I am outraged that the clinton campaign was not allowed acess like obama -- what is the difference ? was the school trying to make a name for itself -- I am ashamed and embarrassed -- by my Indiana roots -- we were taught respect for one another and all was equal -- where is the equal ? is this what we want to teach our young people -- let us revist this and five clinton a chance

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 10:26 AM greeneyes wrote ...

Hypocritical. I'm ashamed this could happen in Indiana.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 10:22 AM Anonymous wrote ...

Larry M, the reason Obama can pay his bills is that he is being funded by the Chinese and Arabs.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 10:21 AM Daniel wrote ...

Am I the only one reading the whole story??The only porblem here is a scheduling problem.There is non race issue, sexist issue, or endorsement of a candidate.Clinton wants to use the Gym during a time when the rules do not permit.Obama wants to use it during a time when the rules does permit.Thats right they must be racist, sexist or endorsing Obama for suggesting that the rules be followed.Grow up people.Everyone must follow rules...not just when its convenient!!!

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 10:20 AM Lori wrote ...

Look at the security issues, an appearance at night during spring break has no impact on the students of Washington HS, which would have been a nightmare during the school day.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 10:15 AM michael wrote ...

If there was any doubt about the media''s mysogynistic bias against Senator Hillary Clinton, the following youtube video should dispel all doubt (except for those who are so blinded by their own prejudices or brainwashed by the media): http://www.youtube.com/result s?search_query=Hillary Mad as Hell&search_type= (You can also type in "Hillary mad as hell" in the youtube search field to retrieve this video.)

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 10:06 AM adw wrote ...

the kids come first. why should ANYONE be allowed to interrupt their day. with their speech bla bla bla. half of the kids wouldn't even be able to go. i think they did the right thing by the students, that is what schools are supposed to do.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 10:05 AM Larry M wrote ...

There is actually only one reason why it was denied, but they are being polite in not stating it. School Boards open these facilities to outside groups as a way of making income off of unused facilities. Typical charges range from $250.00 to over a thousand, depending on addition support. Real facts time: Obama's campaign pays it's bills on time. Hillary's campaign has been in the press no facing accusations of non-payment of bills, (especially school property rentals).

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 10:00 AM Linda, Fl wrote ...

People just do NOT want her Everywhere.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 9:56 AM PA Voter wrote ...

Rules are rules. One campaign follows the rules, the other does not. Thus, the acceptance of one candidate, the refusal of another. Nothing new here - remember Florida & Michigan?

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 9:55 AM pat wrote ...

It is too bad that there is not enough real news to report. It is just sad that CBS, NBC, CNN, FOX and all the rest have nothing more important to write or talk about. This is just plain silly.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 9:40 AM Ang wrote ...

There is a rule in place and Obama follows it but Clinton does not. Why does that not surprise me...

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 9:40 AM Anonymous wrote ...

Whether turning down Clinton and saying it is ok for Obama was racism/sexist, or due to school policies it is wrong. I think they both should have been giving equal opportunity. NOw look what the SBSC has caused. They should be embarrassed and ashamed of themselves. They have angered a lot of people in the community and to the politicians it can't look good. If your going to say no to one say no to the other. Regardless of the reason. I hope they read these comments.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 9:25 AM joe wrote ...

has anyone asked the clitnon camp what they thought? your all eager to whine for them but im guessing they were happy to have there fourm. now barack gets his. it all works. wheres mckain?!?

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 9:23 AM Hank wrote ...

Looks like a whole lot of bias here ... once again, people are so afraid of offending NObama that they stretch the rules for him.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 9:19 AM Dave MIner wrote ...

Clintons are corrupt.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 9:12 AM Jack wrote ...

Democrats need to grow up. The war needs to be dealt with electing someone who is qualified to do so, a Democrat is not. A Democrat is nothing more than a losing viewpoint with empty and proposterous promises. It might be the case that Republicans are not well liked, but this isn't high school and another Republican more qualified to lead is better than any Democrat with nothing more than bags of tricks and lies.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 9:09 AM ms wrote ...

Check out CBS News on the internet - we've made national (heck world wide)news - how embarrassing is that.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 9:07 AM Lydia wrote ...

Is it so unreasonable for the Clinton campaign to reschedule their visit to meet the school district's criteria of not being there during the school day?!?! However, I agree that students should have the opportunity to hear both candidates during the school day. This is an opportunity for both campaigns to reach out to future voters. There is no reason to accuse the school district of playing favorites, they are just following their own rules, as we would expect. Much ado about nothing.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 9:07 AM Elga wrote ...

Clearly a double standard and unfair.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 9:02 AM mona wrote ...

"District's long-standing policy against campaigning of any kind during the school day". They should have asked Clinton to come in the evening. Or change the policy. If the rules had been violated what would have been the consequences? Also I wonder was the full statement of the Superintendent on TV, or was sound bite of what he/she said on TV?

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 8:54 AM Cintnut didn't care wrote ...

Hillary Clintnut didn't care she could not go to Washington. We have laws and that is it. I just wonder why "the man" didn't want to go to a large place.ND the Morris, the Cov, Century Center? And why do we say he is "black" when his mom is white? Does Black trump white or is it people can get beyond the actually skin colo?

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 8:54 AM Roya wrote ...

Why does Clinton always want to break the rules. first she wants delegates seated in states that broke the rules - Now she gets mad because she wanted to have an event during hours which would've been against the school's policy. Just do it during evening hours and you'll get your event! she shows her true character over and over and while you supporters are siding with her she's gonna broke the rules when it comes to your rights people if she becomes president. You won't matter to her.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 8:51 AM Mo Mo wrote ...

You know after reading these comments that people have posted,I realize just how racist our city of South Bend is! It is stupid, silly, arguments like this that makes inspired young people like myself to get uninterested in politics. I am 21 years old and i have been following this years democratic road to nomination even more compared to the 2004 elections. It is really sad that grown (ADULTS??) like you all will make it hard for young people like me to follow this. PLEASE people, grow UP!

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 8:50 AM Look Who's the follower wrote ...

They way it looks that Obama dose all the crying and is trying to be the follow in clitons foot steps think about it people obama complains if clinton says any thing even if in his favor. The SBSB should have been honered that Clinton wanted to speek at there school. your sure not hering any complaing from Mishwalka. The SBSB knows that they really screwed up. I would be doing some electing of new board members ASAP.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 8:48 AM Anonymous wrote ...

10:00 at night? Who's going to be up late enough for that on the west side? Wait, is this a crime prevention plan? Get all the hoods occupied so there isn't any crime in South Bend one night. What a great idea!

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 8:35 AM coco0331 wrote ...

Just an other example of Obama backers, easily influenced and short on wit. A good example of the current American intellect. What a disgrace.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 8:30 AM Tracy wrote ...

A woman president or a black president seems to be the issue with everyone. NOT who will be the best for our country. Fair is Fair they shouldnt even consider letting one speak under any condition without contacting and arranging with the other. Bias..... yes. What are the schools telling our children?! But do you want a president who wont hold his hand over his heart when the pledge is said or the anthem is played? I do not.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 8:20 AM Mariann Pepitone wrote ...

If they only allow Obama then they are endorsing a candidate. I think it is an injustice. If I were the students I would not vote Obama I would vote Hillary and go against the board members. Its the right thing to do. School board members should not play favorites. But in the end Obama will not win the nomination.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 8:19 AM battleroaron wrote ...

beaurocrats doing what beaurocrats do.....crap......, that's crap...... vote for RON PAUL

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 8:03 AM Anonymous wrote ...

I wonder if the police will enforce the curfew in South Bend. The timing of ten at night seems rather wierd, like, I don't care if you show up. That is too late for any kids, and also adults who have to go to work the next morning. They only ones there will be the losers who are out work, or on welfare.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 8:01 AM bbassett wrote ...

This could be called sexiest! If it was reversed it would be called raciest. You are not being fair and show a very one sided view to your kids there. Obama must have paid you a lot of money since he is buying his candidacy!

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 7:38 AM Ken wrote ...

No points for 2nd place. : )

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 7:36 AM DJ wrote ...

The reason for allowing one to speak and one not, simple, they were not on spring break and it would take place during a school day. They are on spring break now and school is not in session. We have 2 Presidential Canidates speaking at local High Schools this is a once in a lifetime event. This is the first time in history where we have a black man, a woman and a POW running for President,why make it a racial issue.I remember days of rasicim I would hope the school allowed a black man to speak.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 7:24 AM Pam wrote ...

They did give Clinton a variety of different time slots she could use.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 7:14 AM Vinchenz wrote ...

Sounds like a valid reason to me. Maybe the Clinton camp should plan a little better. You can't always get what you want even if you are a Clinton.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 7:13 AM Anonymous wrote ...

Priscilla..."it only makes you look foolish". I am sorry but this board and Super. continues to embarrass themselves and our city. They continue to do their laundry in public and quite honestly they should all be replaced-resign. As for Zimmerman's policy maybe he should have read further as he and a board member showed up in tow at a high school parent teacher conference a while back-clearly against the rules.(political gain) have they no shame?

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 7:03 AM Ryan wrote ...

They can attempt to defend the decision all they want. It's WRONG! They all need to be replaced.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 7:02 AM tomulcak wrote ...

this is typical of clinton's staff. this isn't the first time that their lack of attention to detail has caused problems. if this is the type of people clinton has working on her campaign, it makes you wonder how effective she would be as president. she is obviously not a leader and cannot inspire people effectively enough or choose the right people

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 7:01 AM Tom wrote ...

No more fed funding fo you

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 6:50 AM JonathanR wrote ...

Just another example of Clinton claiming "unfair" when in fact it is due to her own failure to respect the rules!!!!

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 6:24 AM Anonymous wrote ...

"...but some men are more equal than others."

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 5:23 AM Mary Santos wrote ...

School Board President Sheila Bergeron needs to go to DETENTION! A true educator would WELCOME members of the SENATE to visit any time of the day! OUTRAGEOUS! It's DISAPPOINTING that this is the sort of judgment that oversees our students. No wonder our nation is suffering academically. Please check the resume/credentials of this School Board President ASAP!

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 5:15 AM skip wrote ...

It will be a different situation next time too when all school board members are voted out!

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 5:00 AM CTU wrote ...

Hilary would've scared the kids and made them cry.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 4:53 AM Earthbound wrote ...

It's against federal law to campaign in schools during school hours, period. You can vote during school hours, but you can't campaign for 150 feet from polling sites. Hillary's event planners failed to take that simple fact into account, or miscalculated spring break. Paranoia is ugly. It's also a waste of time. Better to overcome No Child Left Behind, invest in the schools, and not pass on prejudices. Someone in town should volunteer to help Hillary's event planners!

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 4:53 AM Just Wondering? wrote ...

As one who has followed these stories from day one, I'm confused by the lack of attention to detail by so many individuals. Instead of seeing the simple truths of the whole picture to these intertwining stories, people infused their own ideas agendas, and prejudicies making a mountain out of a mole hill. No prejudice, no deceptions, no endorsement of a certain candidate. Just abiding by their policy. Why can't the truth be as simple as that without jumping to anxious, unfounded conclusions?

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 4:26 AM duane wrote ...

Another "pity me" care played by Hillary...Pathetic

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 4:07 AM Political Center wrote ...

The references to David Duke and many other off color comments are a sign of the outright bias of Obama voters. That this is not fair is obvious. The choice was done in a way that makes the school board's decision biased. And that bias is just some of the issues the electorate should address when it makes its own decision on who should get their votes. A man whose approach is best exemplified by the image of him turning his back on Hillary Clinton during the State of the Union speech.

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 2:21 AM Jkan wrote ...

What a lame excuse? How much money Obama gave you? This is DIRTY. I am an independent, but it seems Obama is manipulating people who are morally not very strong. What a shame!

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 1:32 AM Bk wrote ...

So if David Duke, politico and former KKK member, wanted to come and speak, it's okay? Schools have no obligation to have to allow any politician or speaker to use their grounds as a forum, much less during a school day. It's a firm policy on a solid foundation...they even offered Clinton to come back at night. Give me a break, Clintonites. Just another example of the "double standard" and bending of the rules that the Clinton folks always find in their favor. Follow the rules already!

Wednesday, Apr 9 at 12:00 AM E Eastman wrote ...

Reverse discrimination?? This is just wrong. Any way you look at it it is Just Wrong!! You call this equality??? I think NOT!!!!!For Shame!!

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 11:40 PM Elaine wrote ...

I am not sure that I understand why tehre is a controversy over this. If the rules are that there can't be appearances during the day, and the Obama campaign scheduled an appearance at night, how is it a double standard??? I think the Clinton people should just accommodate the school and make their appearance at night. It's really not that hard.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 11:16 PM Live in the area , not by choice wrote ...

Here are the facts, the United States has had 43 Preidents so far, all of them have one thing in common- they have all been WHITE MEN ....I don't care if the next President is a woman , or man of a different color, I just want this knucklehead in office now gone. Grow up South Bend or Michiana as we have now been called for too long.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 10:21 PM Andrea wrote ...

To Priscilla: Zimmerman should have clearly stated this policy to all & he did NOT!!!!!!!!!!!

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 10:20 PM Tim wrote ...

What a bunch of racist no-brain hicks in charge of that school. Hmmm did they get Sunday schooling from Reverend Wright?

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 9:51 PM annette wrote ...

It is shocking that they would deny one and then allow another..but it is a wonderful experience for the students and something they will always remember..it is too bad that they weren't allowed to be honored with both candidates but the upshot is that more children were exposed to our nations politics..I applaud both candidates for choosing high schools to speak at..more of this type of public speaking should happen..many parents would love to hear political input from their kids..great dinner

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 9:45 PM dave wrote ...

Sounds like the rules were applied as written. If Clinton had asked to use the school when school was out of session, she would have gotten a different answer. Her timing was probably dictated by her schedule. Get over it.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 9:33 PM Concern Educator wrote ...

Again let get beyond what happen recognize who we are and be about change. There is no question this community as a whole harbor racist tendencies. The school board is a real reflection of thisl. Look at your high school, do an analysis of the racial make-up and then look at the helm of the ships. WHS is not suppose to recieve any positive PR because the community is such an uproar the Dr. Z and the board are trying to massage feelings. But look at how the board appointed the leader .

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 9:12 PM Chad wrote ...

I think it's a shame letting one in and not the other. Both are running for the same thing and I think both should have the opportunity be heard.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 9:07 PM Priscilla wrote ...

I read through Zimmerman's detailed policy re political rallys which was available to read before Clinton ever came to town.He clearly stated that it was against their policy to hold such rallys during school hours.He also explained that the Clinton group requested curtailed movement in the school, etc.The entire policy was made available on the web, please read it before making comments about it - it only makes you look foolish.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 8:57 PM Pat wrote ...

I'm a Hillary supporter....... waaahhhhhh wahhhhhh waaahhhhh

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 8:30 PM topflight46 wrote ...

Great timing and planning by Obama. Very bad timing and planning by Clinton. AND YOU WANT WHO... IN THE WHITE HOUSE?????

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 8:29 PM Roger wrote ...

1) It's plain foolish to think that the Obama campaign "conspired" this. 2) This is in no way "racial". This is the SB school system at work. 3) This is one big bad P.R. move by SB schools. I'm an Obama supporter, but I saw no reason to deny Clinton. 4) It's done now, SB gets a candidate, extend the invite to Clinton and McCain. 5) Enjoy this time here in Michiana. There have been too few of these experiences to be players in U.S. Government. 6) See 5)

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 8:23 PM Greg wrote ...

This is not a race issue! It is just a lack of skills from Dr. Z and the school board. They are trying to make a right out of a wrong and it is just another wrong. Let's hope and pray for better leadership in the future.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 8:23 PM I judged too soon... wrote ...

WHOA WHOA WHOA! I think alot of us have made a HUGE mistake! I didn't realize that the Obama team was paying $800 to use the school for their appearance. That does kind of change everything. Now it's more like 'a show' you know, a performance where you have people get up on stage and do what it is they do. I wander who Obama's warm up act is going to be. I'll bet it's a toss up between 'Stupid super tricks' and the TONY ZIRKLE show. HEY WSBT, why don't you ask your viewers to vote on that

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 8:13 PM Tired of stupid comments wrote ...

Everyone Needs to Grow Up and Get Over IT. Stop all the hating for all parties. Each one of them have a good chance at winning. Stop posting negative comments and write something positive if you know how for once. There is already to much hate & dissolution in this world, and some of your comments are just a waste of space on this blog. I say to Obama, Hilary, and John, Good Luck and may the best candidate win.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 7:56 PM culligan man wrote ...

why did obama pick whs?there are other schools in town,or is he sticking it to mrs.clinton.please tell me who is paying the overtime to open the school.i thought money was tight

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 7:54 PM YOUR NEWS COVERAGE STINKS! wrote ...

In all the hoopla, all the reports, not once did I see where Clinton was offered the facilty under the conditions of the city or school system but they declined. Was never an option and as crack as our local news hounds are certainly that would have been brought to light. Look at all the Clinton bashig going on over this that is getting printed and I've had FIVE blogs blocked because I have come out and said straight forward that this cockeyed news source participates in reverse discrimination!

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 7:29 PM craig wrote ...

who cares

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 7:13 PM kb wrote ...

the school board has shown that it is not alright in this country to compete for the nomination. They are not educators when they display this kind of attitude. I served in the Air Force to defend this action, I say not. This process is for all citizens and This is more than Campaigns This is a history and government class that they denied our kids. Censorship should not be tolerated even by our supposedly most educated.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 7:03 PM Michelle wrote ...

Is the super black or white? Kind of fushy to me, or is the board almost all black? Or are they all bigots?

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 7:01 PM Educator wrote ...

There seems to be an impression that the Clinton campaign is whining about this. That's not what I hear. I hear a lot of people who claim to know everything, though. Here's the simple story: Clinton's itinerary put her here during a school day. The board's policy, which cannot be changed by whim, prohibited her visit. Obama is coming outside the school day. If Clinton's campaign brings her through again outside the school day, I assume she'll be welcome. No bad planning - no inconsistency.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 6:54 PM sad wrote ...

After reading the numerous blogs,it is really sad at just how racial our community is. It is more sad and disturbing that now allowing something after denying it with someone else, and knowing, of the issues it would cause because of this decision now. These issues should never happen within the schools and where our children are involved. School should be pushing education and not continual resistance over adult issues that will affect them later in life. It is too bad that this is going on...

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 6:43 PM Bad Move wrote ...

SBCSC totally blew this. If they do not "endorse" political candidates, why host Obama (I support Obama by the way). The only thing this accomplished is an increased racial divide and bias towards people on the west side. The board should have known this would have been the outcome. Shame on them and Zimmerman. Obama could have spoke at another location and this whole mess could have been prevented.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 6:43 PM Kathy wrote ...

Ok, it was my understanding that the SBCSC had a standing policy that is against any form of political promoting at their schools! Is this correct or not?? Or has the policy now been changed that they will not accept any form of political promoting during school hours? The reasons they stated for Hillary not to be allowed were somewhat understandable, but now they have changed for Borok?? They need to set one set of guidelines to be followed by ALL!!!

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 6:38 PM JJ wrote ...

I wish people would quit falling for that line "school policy prohibits politicking during school hours." Put up or shut up, Dr. Zimmerman: Appear on TV with that policy book, not newly changed, and show us this policy!

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 6:32 PM Given Up! wrote ...

Like we didn't see this coming!

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 6:31 PM wake up and listen wrote ...

Read 6:00 CD's blog.He hit it right. The Pres. of the school system stated on TV that they do not endorse politics, then all of the criticism came and now instead of admitting the truth,another story is put out, now it is political.Why is Obama not going downtown, in our great city? What is the purpose of using a school where it has also been stated there is no room for such large crowds, on the news last night, by a school board member?

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 5:48 PM ev wrote ...

clinton-10:am school day. obama-8pm evening school not in session. clinton was told she could come in the evening. why is this so hard to get?

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 5:46 PM Sad wrote ...

SBCSC is teaching everyone to go against their words, since you declined one person you have decline everyone, because everyone isnt getting their fair share of time. SBCSC and the school board are showing favoritism by allowing Obama to speak. I dont blame anyone who decides to ralley against Obama comming to WHS. SHAME ON YOU SBCSC!!

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 5:37 PM Kasi wrote ...

Barack should be allowed to attend Washington High school. Many blogs had purported racially bias comments, as if one candidate was more suitable to come because of the racial make-up of the school. This was a board decision much about bias against Washington and the principal. The school board and the Superintendent are trying to clean up where they messed up by allowing Obama to come. The board members and Superintendent will have to explain to the community why they made this decision.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 5:33 PM CD wrote ...

Well, my comment from earlier is not included. I suppose you only want the ones that are inflamatory. Shame on you.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 5:27 PM Alan wrote ...

Where is the problem? Can't do it during school hours. This is no controversy here.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 5:24 PM Bob wrote ...

Shame Shame. I am sure glad that SouthBend has an elected school board.I think come election time for the Southbend School board you will see ALL NEW FACES. We should

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 5:21 PM M wrote ...

Clinton supporters are always consistent in one thing: their candidate should get special privileges. Clinton needs to follow the rules, like everyone else. She seems to have a hard time doing so, and expects the rules should be changed for her, just because she is Hillary Clinton. Sorry, that is not how America works.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 5:18 PM Tony wrote ...

I think what some people fail to understand is that SB schools are obviously supporting Senator Obama. It does not matter whether school is in session or not. The fact that SBCS are involved because it is their building is what disturbs me. Zimmerman should have been fired when the school board had the chance to do so.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 5:17 PM Julescator wrote ...

I think the school spelled out the differences. If you don't get it - YOU don't want to! Why doesn't Clinton jsut come at night - geesh - she is such a pain - everyone has to roll out a red carpet for this lady. Give us a break from her - PLEASE!

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 5:15 PM Barbara Ackerson wrote ...

That was our school board president!? No wonder our schools are in trouble...and i beg to differ, there is a right and wrong on this...what is good for the goose etc..NO EXCUSES...they have really opened up a cans of worms on this one. Peace

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 5:14 PM Anonymous wrote ...

whatever the decision is ... the school is sending a message..it should be a fair decision..u have one candidate..u should have all.... why didnt they offer clinton a different time and explain the policy? why show favoritism...? school is about learning and teaching... not POLITICS !

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 5:13 PM Anonymous wrote ...

seems to me there's a big difference between a candidate appearing in the evening during spring break, and a candidate appearing during school hours, during term time. a very big, very clear difference. Maybe, instead of the usual weeping/whining, the Clinton campaign should re-book, more appropriately.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 5:13 PM Anonymous wrote ...

So then WHY can schools be polling places during school hours?

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 5:11 PM jane wrote ...

my oh my and to think these board members had our trust~i believe there is only one whom is telling the truth! if wahington school board would not allow clinton then the y sure as heck should not allow obama~ this only make racism shine`please remember all of this when there election time is here~

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 5:11 PM sharon Denney wrote ...

not only did the school go prejudice toward Barrack Hussein Obama, but the news keeps saying his name over and over and then you are going to broadcast it live. how is that for prejudice

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 5:07 PM keith wrote ...

It did not matter to the mishawaka school district. This sounds like gender bias and racial bias. WAKE UP Michiana. Mr Zimmerman already had his mind made up.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 5:07 PM Marg. wrote ...

I would of let Clinton come instead of Obama.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 5:00 PM CD wrote ...

Come on people, the reason Obama is speaking is because the superintendent realized he made a big mistake by denying Clinton and realized this was an opportunity to do the right thing. There is no alternative motive. That is as stupid to think as his first decision was. Both of them should have spoken at the school--the most Democratic part of the area in the most diverse school. I am only sorry the students and teachers won't be there to receive the benefit of his coming.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 4:57 PM scott Ryan wrote ...

South Bend schools made a huge mistake by denying ANY presidential candidate. Though we’re not ignorant enough to accept the excuse they’ve conjured up for denying Hillary. On the positive side I think the excuse itself is a form of admission to their mistake and it would be wrong to repeat the same mistake over again.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 4:57 PM Sally wrote ...

White woman.........black man. Questions answered?!?

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 4:39 PM Kasi B. wrote ...

The Superintendent and the school board made the decision to deny Clinton to have a rally. Now they are trying to appease the community by allowing Obama to hold a rally. Its and effort to make a right a wrong.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 4:26 PM Debra wrote ...

The school board was completely correct not to let Mrs. Clinton speak. It was during the school day where the children should be learning. Mr. Obama is speaking when the children are not at school. I can't believe the people of this community don't understand this difference.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 4:25 PM donna taber wrote ...

Same rules should apply to all, no exceptions!

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 4:23 PM Ed wrote ...

It's simple, Hillery wanted to come in while school was in session (very disruptive) and Obama when it isn't. If you can't understand that reasoning maybe you shouldn't vote either; Hello!

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 4:17 PM Anonymous wrote ...

if its a gov ran office if you allow one you must allow all for political campiening i think thats the law?

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 4:16 PM Betty wrote ...

It is very unfair for S.B.School Corp. to allow Obama & not Clinton. It appears the School is Endorsing Obama. I tried to understand the School's position with Sen. Clinton, that it was in the best interest of the School Corp. to NOT get involved with Politics, but, this sends a wrong Message to all. It's a little to late to extend a Welcome to the other Candidates now. I'm very dissapointed with this School Corp.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 4:14 PM Anonymous wrote ...

Obama should be able to hold a rally at the school. This is just one example of how his planning is exemplary to Clinton. If Clinton wanted to come back during hours that are safe for the school kids, she could do so. One question I have; is Hilary running for Presidency or her husband and daughter? They have been campaining and answering questions that I would rather hear Hilary specifically answer, not her family. FYI~ I am not voting for either Obama or Clinton, just see class in Obama.

Tuesday, Apr 8 at 4:10 PM Jeff wrote ...

The reason for not allowing Clinton to speak was that they didn't want to seem as if they were endorsing a canidate. Thats what I saw the school superintendent say on TV. So whats the difference now? Typical school board decision making.

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

Comments are moderated and will not appear on this story until after they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

WSBT and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

WSBT Weather

icon
Current Temp 35
°
More Weather
More On Demand

Stock Quotes

YouNews

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.
This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.