BMV says Indiana man must change names if he wants license

Tools

BMV License Branch

(WSBT file photo)

By Beth Boehne

LAKE STATION (AP) — A retired steelworker and longtime Indiana resident must change his name if he wants a driver's license, the state Bureau of Motor Vehicles says.

The BMV informed Francisco Mendez, 65, that he had to change his name to Francisco Mendez Vale to match his birth certificate even though he follows the custom of his native Puerto Rico and does not use his mother's family name. In many Spanish speaking parts of the world, children are given both the father's and mother's family names, but generally use only the paternal name.

"I've been Francisco Mendez for 65 years," said Mendez, who was born in Puerto Rico and raised in Gary. "I served in the military with that name. And I retired from U.S. Steel after 35 years with that name."

The BMV refused to issue Mendez a license because the name on his birth certificate did not match U.S. Social Security Administration records, which do not include the name Vale. He was required to present his birth certificate when he applied for an Indiana driver's license in December because he had an out-of-state license.

"The birth certificate is your name," said BMV spokesman Dennis Rosebrough. "It's the ultimate identifier. But you can go to court and change your name."

However, BMV officials were meeting to research the law, Rosebrough said. "We want to make sure if there is a policy change, it's one that can be practically applied and not one that's going to put our customer service representatives in a difficult situation."

Rosebrough said in 2006 the BMV notified 206,000 Hoosiers that information on their driver's licenses didn't match the federal database and some 60,000 of those discrepancies were corrected.

Mendez said records for property and cars that he owns are issued under the name Mendez. He has lived in Lake County for most of his life except a five-year stint in Las Vegas after his retirement. He moved back to Indiana in 2006, he said.

Francisco Mendez said the BMV branch office in Hobart gave him a handwritten note that said his application for a license was pending, but said the document might not be accepted if he was stopped by a police officer.

"I served this country under my father's name," he said. "It's not fair now that they're making me change my name for some bureaucratic reason."

Monday, Jul 21 at 3:20 PM Bloomington wrote ...

I work at the BMV and as much as everyone thinks that this is a Bunch of BS that were pulling outta our rears, its not, its STATE LAW! do you think that we LIKE to make things up for you to go do just so that you can come back yelling in our faces, were trying to get through the day just as you are.

Thursday, Jan 10 at 7:02 AM Carrie wrote ...

Geez, dude, pick a name already.

Thursday, Jan 10 at 6:55 AM Anonymous wrote ...

Just another example of how the BMV makes up their own rules...I particularly love it when I go there 3 times for the same thing and each time I'm told something different. This guy should've just told the attendant he'd take care of it and went back 2 days later. They'd have had a new story by then. Or go to a different branch...that is even more interesting!

Wednesday, Jan 9 at 6:46 PM Name: BMV won't let me use it wrote ...

Used to be that you could just file a name change affidavit at BMV.The forms and rules were still posted when I tried to change my license name to my maiden name.So there may be quite a few people who are seriously inconvenienced at the least.To say they must all go to court (fees and time) to fix what may have been a government clerical error to begin with is a slap in the face (I paid my court fees and BMV wouldn't accept the documents).Puerto Ricans are U.S. citizens, by the way.

Wednesday, Jan 9 at 3:53 PM Me wrote ...

My birth certificate and social card dont match and I have never had a problem. wonder if I will when I go to renew next yr. ugh I hope not!

Wednesday, Jan 9 at 12:37 PM Elkhart wrote ...

You are in America, follow American customs, what to follow your native customs, go back to your native land.

Wednesday, Jan 9 at 11:21 AM ron paul wrote ...

if you think its bad now trust me its gonna get alot worse. just remember the economy is good and everything is great ha ha big brother think's we are all morons if we believe that then yes they are correct. wake up sheep bah bah. the illegal's dont have to show any document's in order to get a license fact! the illegal's are being used as a battling ram to our economy and our way of life. they get welfare ssi food stamps and free education we the people pay for it of course i wish i was illegal

Wednesday, Jan 9 at 10:01 AM Michigan Resident wrote ...

My husband was told by an agent when re-financing our house that he had to change his signature. Now, if he changes his signature for them, it matches nothing else!!! That's just stupid! He never did and they put it through. If he changed it, it wouldn't be him. Dorks!

Wednesday, Jan 9 at 7:49 AM Anonymous wrote ...

Rules are made for your protection. If you want to change your name, you have to go to a judge. If your birth certificate has a different name than what you want, too bad. Go to a judge and get it fixed. Quit blaming the government. Afterall, 19 morons came into our country using our screwed up immigration system and killed nearly 3,000 people.

Wednesday, Jan 9 at 4:20 AM Anonymous wrote ...

Heck, I use my middle name. Do you think the government will accept my signature? Many times I have had to explain that that is how I am known and unless I am fraudulently signing something, I may use any name I like. When we bought our house, they called me a few days later to come back in and re-sign everything with my first name. I said sure, at $2.00 per page. I never heard back from them.

Tuesday, Jan 8 at 11:50 PM Name: BMV won't let me use it wrote ...

After divorce and checking ahead, I went to BMV for name change.Although I requested(and had court-certified documents as proof)the change to my maiden name-which appears on my birth certificate, all other ID and Social Security), they refused. Told me I "might be a terrorist".Since the judge didn't "correctly" (to them) stipulate that I can use my OWN name, I can't?!Six hours and many fruitless trips later proved to me this is NOT a free country. What a shame (sham)our country has become!

Tuesday, Jan 8 at 10:48 PM B wrote ...

This is newsworthy?

Tuesday, Jan 8 at 10:18 PM professional driver wrote ...

i find it funny that any employee for the agency acts as a spokes person when one of the very people that they work with took it upon themselves to steal identites and sell them

Tuesday, Jan 8 at 9:45 PM anonymous wrote ...

It's just another way for the BMV to harass the public. I took my son to get his permit you wouldn't beleive the hoops we had to jump through. But three almost four years ago someone from our trusted BMV had no problem selling my husbands social securtiy number to a ring and we are still paying for it. Life has been hell but guess what we can not go back and sue them because it's a government agency. Tell me where they are truely trying to protect us from identy theft?

Tuesday, Jan 8 at 9:23 PM Diana wrote ...

What's the big deal? When ANYONE goes to get a drivers license the first time its supposed to match your birth name. Hell, if not I am going to go and get a different ID since I no longer wish to use my last name just my first and middle. It's about time some of the rules start to get enforced! It's bad enough that illegals can get drivers license in many states the least we can do is make sure the name is who the person really is whether they are a legal resident or not!

Tuesday, Jan 8 at 6:40 PM kc9ixv wrote ...

this is messed up. it sounds like he is a legal citizen. whats really messed up is the illegal's can get a driver's license but an american citizen get's jerked around.if you think im joking just open your eyes.in indiana im not sure if illegal's can get a license but in other states they can and they need no identification either.this is the kind of government everyone voted for lol.

Tuesday, Jan 8 at 5:34 PM anonymous wrote ...

try another branch. They are all suppose to have the same rules but it seems like they make their own. I HATE going to the license branch, especially the one in Plymouth. I totally avoid going there at all costs! When my daughter got her permit her name was spelled wrong on her birth certificate and they just told me that it had to be the same on her permit as her birth certificate.

Tuesday, Jan 8 at 12:53 PM Romany wrote ...

I don't understand why he can't just have his name LEGALLY changed to the name he has always used. Wouldn't that solve it?

Tuesday, Jan 8 at 10:16 AM Anonymous wrote ...

We live in a world where people will sell and steal identities for a profit. Some of you who think this is wrong need a reality check. We no longer live in a world where we can assume there are not bad people.

Tuesday, Jan 8 at 7:53 AM laughing wrote ...

Anonymous you are an idiot. If you don't like police and government move to a country that doesn't have them. And good luck trying to find one of those. Bet you don't complain when the government has services or money to give you, do you?

Tuesday, Jan 8 at 3:39 AM BMV Employee wrote ...

This is for his own protection, times are changing and identity theft is on the rise. The minute you think it won't happen to you is when it does. Many are angered about these precautions being taken, but would you rather us do nothing? Trust me it would cause you more harm than good in the long run.

Monday, Jan 7 at 11:08 PM Cromwell wrote ...

Does this mean I have to change my name back to Eagleclaw? THAT was the name given my grandparents when we were on the reservation...

Monday, Jan 7 at 9:54 PM Elkhart wrote ...

If the rest of us have to go by whats on our birth certificate then why does Mr. Mendez think he is any better then we are.

Monday, Jan 7 at 9:53 PM rather not say wrote ...

I know someone that this happened to last year,,, it was pretty sad that they just wanted one letter changed,, the person has been known as the other spelling all his life,, then,, they want him to change it???

Monday, Jan 7 at 8:54 PM South Bend wrote ...

What is the WORLD coming to why do we all wait intill the last minute to make changes its 2008 I wonder what the Future will look like if we all dont staighten up

Monday, Jan 7 at 7:00 PM anonymous wrote ...

once again proof that government and police interference need to be removes from our lives!!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

WSBT and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, or remove user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum. Items that may be considered inappropriate to post are those containing profanity, hatred, or insensitive, vulgar, unlawful or threatening comments.

WSBT Weather

icon
Current Temp 12
°
More Weather
More On Demand

Stock Quotes

YouNews

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.
This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

Tonight On WSBTFull Schedule

7.00
Wheel of Fortune
7.30
Jeopardy!
8.00
Ghost Whisperer
9.00
Flashpoint
10.00
Numb3rs
11.00
WSBT News
11.35
Late Show with David Letterman

Question of The Day

How often do you check your smoke detectors?

E-mail your comments. We'll pick some to read during WSBT News at 5.