Foreclosure crisis hitting hard in Indiana and Michigan

by Jim Pinkerton (jmpinkerton@wsbt.com)

Tools

Indiana and Michigan in top 10 for number of foreclosures

Indiana and Michigan are in the top 10 in the country for the number of foreclosures. (WSBT photo)

By Jim Pinkerton

ST. JOSEPH COUNTY — Rising gas prices, rising taxes, rising mortgage payments. They're all contributing to tough times for local homeowners. Indiana and Michigan are in the top 10 for the number of foreclosures in the country. The numbers are growing quickly.

"We never thought we'd be where we were at," said Marlene Schindewolf of Granger.

When her husband Tom lost his job, things got tough.

"Because we'd never been in that position, you don't know what to do. You don't know who to call, you don't know where to start," she said.

When creditors started calling around the clock, she knew they had to make some tough choices to keep their house. Schindewolf says creditors were unwilling to work with them.

"The way you're treated is absolutely degrading. We've had good credit. We've paid our bills on time. We're working through this. My husband's looking for work. Just bear with us, but no one bears with you at that point," she said.

And it's not just people who've lost a job. Experts say more middle income families are being affected. Judy Fox is with the Legal Aid Clinic at Notre Dame. She's says many have become victims of predatory lenders — companies that loan money to people who shouldn't qualify at high or adjustable interest rates.

"It's a very big problem in this area," Fox said.

So big, in fact, that her clinic has started researching the numbers. Preliminary figures show that between 2001 and 2002, the number of foreclosure cases in St. Joseph County rose 151 percent. Similar increases have been reported each year since then.

"There seems to be a correlation between low income, minority neighborhoods and this kind of activity," Fox said. "I think it's a crisis and we've only seen the tip of the iceberg."

Predatory lenders target people who have equity in their home. They get them to borrow as much as they can against that equity. The lender gets a huge fee and doesn't care that the homeowner can't afford the payments. Sometimes, Fox says the lender will even alter documents and that confuses people.

"The person was told they have a payment of $400 per month. They get to the closing and the papers are all different. They think they don't have a choice. They think they have to sign it," Fox said.

But they don't and Fox says knowing your rights makes a big difference. So does getting advice. That's what helped Schindewolf get out of her problems. A credit counselor showed her there was light at the end of the financial tunnel.

"We found a mortgage company to work with us. Not only were we able to roll some things together, pay off some more bills and get out of this home equity mess. We were able to drop our interest rate down a whole percent, too," she said.

The Schindewolfs are a success story, but not every story ends the same.

Amanda Walker is with Green Path Debt Solutions. She says many people assume if the bank approves them for a loan amount, they can swing the payments.

"A lot of people don't sit down and go through their budget to figure out what can we realistically afford month to month as a payment," said Walker.

When they see trouble coming, they don't know that it's better to contact the bank. Many times, they're intimidated, but Walker says they don't need to be.

"A lot of banks and lenders will do repayment programs. If you're only a month or two behind, you pay little bit more for the next couple of months or an extra payment with the income tax returns. There are different options to get the mortgage caught up," Walker said.

Bankruptcy trustee Debra Miller says most banks don't want to foreclose. She recommends calling the bank's collection department at the first sign of trouble. If that doesn't work contact the bank's loss mitigation department.

"If someone is trying and trying to make the payments, they're going to work with people as much as they can," Miller said.

The key is to document who you talk with and what is said. And if you do seek help from a credit counselor, make sure they're reputable.

"Unfortunately, there are people who are more than willing to take advantage of people and scam them," Miller said.

She says that includes many you'll find through the internet.

Even though Congress has taken some action to stem the tide of foreclosures, Fox says the numbers will probably increase because the worst lending practices she's seen happened between 2004 and 2006.

Fox said because the credit market has dried up, some of the predatory lenders have moved on. She says, however, the danger isn't gone because there are no new rules to prevent the practice.

Fox and others started making the call for reform several years ago, but she said they were basically ignored.

"Basically we were all told we were Chicken Little, that the roof wasn't falling, that the market's fine, the market's taking care of itself. The market isn't fine and we haven't seen the end of this yet. Because some of the worst practices we are seeing were happening in 2004-05-06. Those mortgages haven't even started foreclosing yet," Fox said.

Miller said while many people would like to blame the lenders, there's plenty of blame to go around.

"You have mortgage originators who weren't doing the job and people who were getting the money out of their houses. And when everything came crashing down, there really wasn't one person that is to blame for this," Miller said.

Miller is planning an event next month to help people. They want to get various lenders and advisors together in one place so people can get advice and work on issues before they become a crisis. No date or location is set at this time.

The website www.hud.gov has lists of government approved housing credit counselors.

www.877gethope.org is a website set up to help people who are in danger of losing their homes. Telephone advice is also available: 1-877-GET-HOPE.

The South Bend Heritage Foundation is in partnership the Indiana Foreclosure Prevention Network and the national organization hotline is 1-888-995-HOPE.

The city of South Bend Community and Economic Development also has a certified counselor with HUD and the state.

Saturday, Feb 2 at 10:00 AM SS wrote ...

There are several who comment on every story that appears and their comments ALWAYS say the same things. "I have ALWAYS done the right thing and the rest of you are just crap". So, I would advise you to take all of your "wisdom" and your hard earned money and invest it in new computer equipment, self publish your "wisdom", and spend as much time reading your crap as you do writing it. I can't believe that people who spend SO much time looking for things to criticize in others, claim to be happy.

Friday, Feb 1 at 10:04 PM anonymous wrote ...

We don't need another new school building! Education does not come from the building. It's just a further extension of building what you can't afford and wanting someone else to pay for it later. The buildings in all school districts at this point are great and should last another 40 yrs. That doesn't mean you can't upgrade some computers, etc. but we don't have to be building new buildings every yr. Concord and Northridge.

Friday, Feb 1 at 9:57 PM Anonymous wrote ...

I have just realized that all or most of the Indiana properties are having the assessed values raised now, so that when the property taxes come down we will be paying at least what we're paying now anyways PLUS the extra 1% in sales tax, we just got horn swaggled-----we lose again.

Friday, Feb 1 at 2:36 PM John Wesley wrote ...

Mitch is not the problem, the problem was there long before he came along, he has gone a long way towards fixing the problem, If you want to fix the problems in Indiana, get rid of the TAX and Spend demycraps like our own B Patrick. We in this state cannot afford to support all of the dead wood that we are currently supporting. we must see to the operating needs of state and local government and schools, and eliminate the so called entitlement programs.

Friday, Feb 1 at 11:33 AM Han wrote ...

Linda: If you don't have the money to pay for something, you can't afford it. My greatgranddad came here from Sicily, got a job at the water dept., bought a house in a mixed/upscale 'hood. He lived a good life as a worker because he didn't buy things if he didn't have the money to pay for it. He didn't belong to anyone, in life or in retirement. He wasn't anyone's slave and noone was his slave. He couldn't do that today. Today his arse would belong to lenders. That's a shame and it's very stupid

Friday, Feb 1 at 11:01 AM Han wrote ...

Lar: Now now, didn't your mom tell you it's not nice to call names? You're right, it's a good thing to buy a home. Homes are nice. Boys and girls who go to church are good boys and girls. Be good, now, and run along. I need to talk to some grown ups.

Friday, Feb 1 at 10:57 AM Han wrote ...

Jay: didn't your mom tell you it's not nice to call names? Now, when there's trouble, we ask for help, that is right. But there is this thing going on with grown up banks that you'll find out about someday. Remember to behave yourself and stay warm.

Friday, Feb 1 at 7:21 AM Linda wrote ...

I think it's a combination of factors. Greed on the part of the lenders and unwise decisions on the part of the borrower. An adjustable rate mortgage is never a good idea. We have bought two homes and would never agree to that. If you can't afford it at a fixed rate, you just plain can't afford it.

Friday, Feb 1 at 6:08 AM Economic AL in Lakeville wrote ...

Surely this must be wrong??? With the economic opportunities, provided by Mitch Daniels and Jackie Walorski, this article simply cant be correct. Everyone knows that the ability to pay your mortgage has nothing to do with Gas/property tax or cost of living rates.....its just core economic indicators that say it isnt so....Let's all go to the casino and play some texas holdem, this problem will undoubtedly go away very very soon...........

Friday, Feb 1 at 4:31 AM Lar wrote ...

Han, YOUR stupid! Would you like to be put out into the cold without a home? People did a good thing getting a home, they made a mistake by not reading the fine print. When was the last time you went to church?

Friday, Feb 1 at 2:39 AM Suzanne Granger wrote ...

I am a Realtor in Granger/Mish/SB area.Every single person I have had a transaction with in the past several years - I have been in VERY close contact with their lender, making sure that they were getting into a fixed rate, 30 year mortgage as opposed to a shady loan that would make their payments skyrocket within a couple of years. I took the extra time to do this...some people, especially first time home buyers are not experienced enough to realize.. Thank heavens all of my buyers are fine!!

Friday, Feb 1 at 12:43 AM W wrote ...

It is amazing that no one has sympathy for anyone nowdays. If someone has a problem people want to gang up and be critical.No one cares and everyone thinks they are being taken advantage of.What is happening? If the economy gets worse,I hope there will be some kind people left out there to lend a helping hand. Whatever happened to loving your neighbor?

Thursday, Jan 31 at 10:27 PM Jay wrote ...

Of course Han you'd probably be the first one looking for help if this, or something like it, happened to you. Moron.

Thursday, Jan 31 at 9:49 PM James wrote ...

No, the real reason taxes are up is our government officials think they have an unlimited budget. We're paying $10,000 per child for public schools. That's absurd. Lower that to what is reasonable, and they could lower taxes. Get rid of the big spenders in government.

Thursday, Jan 31 at 8:57 PM In God We Trust wrote ...

Family should just come together and live in one big happy home and just try to save money I just think GODS trying to tell us all something

Thursday, Jan 31 at 6:11 PM Han wrote ...

Buying things you don't have the money to pay for is deeply, painfully stupid, but it's fashionable and not enough people are getting screwed over by it for anyone to care about those who are. So, buck up. You had no problem with this dumb game while you were winning it. Don't look for sympathy, now.

Thursday, Jan 31 at 6:06 PM Anonymous wrote ...

I hope that the vooters in this state wake up. Danials is the core reason that property taxes have gone up. DITCH MITCH!!!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

Comments are moderated and will not appear on this story until after they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

WSBT and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

WSBT Weather

icon
74
°
More Weather
More On Demand

Stock Quotes

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

Tonight On WSBTFull Schedule

7.00
Wheel of Fortune
7.30
Jeopardy!
8.00
Ghost Whisperer
9.00
Numb3rs
10.00
Swingtown
11.00
WSBT News
11.35
Late Show with David Letterman

Question of The Day

What do you think of John McCain's VP choice?

E-mail your comments. We'll pick some to read during WSBT News at 5:30.