Rough roads ahead: Potholes popping up costs city

by Nora Gathings (hsgathings@wsbt.com)

Tools

South Bend street crews work to patch potholes

In January, South Bend street crews worked 2,500 hours of overtime trying to patch potholes. (WSBT photo)

By WSBT News1

SOUTH BEND — Expect rough roads ahead. Potholes are popping up, and road crews can't patch them fast enough. And it's getting pricey for the city.

The fluctuating temperatures and melting snow are creating big potholes.

Some of the worst areas in the city are on State Road 23 from Edison to Five Points, on Cleveland from Ironwood to Crestview, and on Western Avenue from the Bypass to Chapin.

Crews say more wet weather will force them to buy more materials.

"I have noticed a lot more potholes in the streets," said driver Mike Berta.

"Every spring we have the same problem," said Dick Detino, another driver. "There are always potholes, I know the city tries to fill them as quickly as they can."

It only takes minutes, but with this many potholes, it becomes an endless task.

"As soon as we drive over it a few times, it will come right up and the hole is just going to get bigger and bigger," said driver Audrey Dillon.

"A lot of people say, 'You patched it yesterday, and it's Tuesday and they are open [again] today.' That's the reason — because it's freezing at night," said Sam Hensley, South Bend Street Department commissioner.

That's forcing drivers to find ways to navigate the bumpy roads.

"I dodge them," said Dillon.

"I notice I'm going back and forth trying to avoid them a lot more," said Berta.

In January, South Bend street crews worked 2,500 hours of overtime trying to patch potholes.

"We have used approximately 125 tons of cold patch compared with last year when we used only about 125 tons period," said Hensley.

But they keep popping up.

"We pay them to maintain our roads; and if that is maintaining, I am looking at the wrong picture," said Dillon.

The biggest expense has been overtime — cold patch only costs $55 a ton.

South Bend still has 125 tons, but they expect to have to buy more before the end of the year.

For information on reporting a pothole or filing a claim of damage resulting from a pothole, click on the "Report a pothole" link in the Related Content box.

Do you know where the worst potholes are? Let us know by adding a comment to this story!

Wednesday, Mar 12 at 2:50 PM maria majerek wrote ...

According to the city, no they are not liable. In Jan. I hit that huge crater on Ireland. It took out BOTH passenger tires but thank goodness the rims are ok.I filed with the city and today got a letter from the city attorney saying the "city did everything to provide a reasonably safe roadway and the City of South Bend is not legally liable for the damages" My car is a 2008 with 5,000 miles on it. Did I need new tires? uh-no. Is the city doing anything to provide reasonably safe roads? uh-no.

Monday, Feb 18 at 11:10 AM Koriey L wrote ...

I hit a Crater on Lincolnway that made my tire go flat the instant I hit it my tires are only 6 months old and now I have to replace the rim as well!! $ 240.00 for replacement rim $58.00 for ANOTHER new tire, Alignment $60.00 City actually doing their job and fixing potholes with our wheel tax money would be Priceless!

Thursday, Feb 7 at 7:12 AM Mee wrote ...

The persons in charge of our roads in SB. and Mish. should be in a elected position. If we keep the same people in charge nothing will change. We need someone that actually cares and wants to make it more efficient for our cities. It's no secret that most city workers are lazy and most of them don't care, they just show up and collect a weekly paycheck. We need people who actually care for their city.

Thursday, Feb 7 at 7:05 AM Dave wrote ...

excuses, excuses, excuses! 2500 hours of overtime!!! Well someone better be looking into that. Because it sure wasn't spent patching potholes. And at $55 a ton for patch thats about 1 ton of patch I'm owed from my WHEEL TAX money. I'd like my 1 ton put on LWE in Mish. so I can make it to work in one piece.

Wednesday, Feb 6 at 4:07 PM L wrote ...

I'm no scientist, but it seems to me that if the road crews put the cold patch in the pothole, after not removing any of the water in it, it isn't any great surprise that it pops back out. Let's see water, cold patch, water freezes, expands, & pops back out of the hole. Isn't there some kind of equipment that can dry out the potholes, so there may be a slightly better chance it won't pop back out immediately? This is so incredibly stupid.

Wednesday, Feb 6 at 7:19 AM Dave wrote ...

You people in charge of our roads are complete idiots. Do not blame anything but ignorance on this problem. The surrounding counties have endured the same weather we have but yet the road conditions are nothing near the decayed condition that St. Joe. Co. roads are in. Why can't you notice this and follow the way that other counties that have good to excellent road conditions manage there roads. Or would that make you have to WORK to hard. FIX OUR ROADS. DON'T PATCH OUR ROADS.

Tuesday, Feb 5 at 3:41 PM Me wrote ...

Earl, some of these potholes you cannot miss. The one on Ireland Road that Carrie mentioned, well lets just say she is not exaggerating on that one. Don't blame it on the cell phones when the pothole is in the whole lane.

Tuesday, Feb 5 at 12:37 PM Kristin wrote ...

I wont be surprised when i get pulled over on suspicion of DUI i swerve all over the road no matter where i go...its horrible!

Tuesday, Feb 5 at 12:28 PM Carrie wrote ...

Sorry Earl, but you're wrong on this one. We hit the biggest pothole I've ever seen (it literally covered a lane and a 1/2) in front of the Speedway on Ireland just west of Ironwood and our tire INSTANTLY went flat. It just so happens you can't see this hole in the dark until you are IN it!

Tuesday, Feb 5 at 9:48 AM ms wrote ...

Guess the wheel tax is here to stay now - they'll probably even try to raise it - come on SB. We have winter here every year - fix the roads right the first time and cost will dwindle. Oops - forgot about job security.

Tuesday, Feb 5 at 9:01 AM j wrote ...

Some of the worst areas are on bendix drive, the pot holes are every where. Down by the rail road crossings are some huge holes that are almost impossible to avoid, something must be done withthat area.

Tuesday, Feb 5 at 8:39 AM Donald Sheets wrote ...

Hit a pothole between the 2 Blair Hills entrances on Dragoon Trail this morning. Bent my front rim, broke my hubcap and damaged my door. My car literally hit the frame. Took pictures of everything and will contact the city of Mishawaka.

Tuesday, Feb 5 at 7:01 AM Me wrote ...

I think the worst spot that was not mentioned is Ireland Road, between Ironwood and Miami. They look like big craters in some spots and I have not seen anybody out there filling them in.

Tuesday, Feb 5 at 7:00 AM Anonymous wrote ...

HEATED ROADS ARE NOT IMPRACTICAL! They cost more at the onset but less in maintenance. Lives are saved as well as road construction lessesns and no jobs are lost, just recalibrated! Wake up!

Tuesday, Feb 5 at 6:44 AM BOB wrote ...

Build our streets with concrete instead of this asfault crap and will save in the long run

Tuesday, Feb 5 at 4:44 AM stewie wrote ...

My thoughts and prayers and heart are with the vehicles damaged by potholes.

Tuesday, Feb 5 at 12:25 AM Earl wrote ...

There is no such thing as a pot hole you cannot avoid. I have yet to hit one this year. Pay attention to where you are driving...hang up the cell phone and concentrate.

Tuesday, Feb 5 at 12:23 AM Todd wrote ...

You can buy the most expensive pot hole filler in the world and it will not work right now. The roads are very wet and we barely half way through winter. They all are just going to come back up anyways. Put cheap stuff in and fix them better in the spring when it will finally stick.

Monday, Feb 4 at 9:39 PM randy wrote ...

Did we always use this cheap patch stuff? lets see, 2,500 hours of overtime . $15 an hour plus overtime of 7.50 an hour is $22.50 an hour times 2,500 hours = around $55,000 !! 125 more tons of patch cost $ 6,875 . well , is'nt it easy to see !!!!! buy better pothole filler that stays in the hole and south bend savethousands of dollars on labor !! i`m just an average joe , but i can see how to save our city money in about 5 minutes of thinking and writing about it . pretty sad south bend ,SAD !

Monday, Feb 4 at 9:18 PM randy wrote ...

I just love the title to this story ( Costly to the city ) . no kidding !! winter potholes have always been costly , nothing new to south bend. what i hate is we pay more and more taxes and we have the same old pothole problem every year. why pay more taxes? pay less taxes and it would be no different. we pay more taxes for schools but we still lose programs and art and field trips. how did we do it in the past so cheaply ?! i'll tell you how . less greed ! greed is so sick . stop the greed !

Monday, Feb 4 at 9:13 PM RS wrote ...

I praise the plow drivers for keeping our roads cleared the best they can, BUT, I've seen them run the blades on DRY pavement, with just a bit of ice getting scraped along the edges of the road, while the rest of the "dry" section of road is getting torn up, can't they use better judgement when the roads dont need 100%scraped? HEY JT, I remember that hole too, cost me to have the right side A frame replaced.

Monday, Feb 4 at 8:10 PM JT wrote ...

Good luck on getting the city to take the blame for damage to your car. Damaged a rin last year on a man hole in front of McDondals on Lincoln way East (1800)the man holeis 6-9 inches below grade and still isn't fixed. Buy a car and there is a 1.25 wheel tax and we pay $25.00 per car and still can't get roads fixed correctly. So much for owning a nice car or a set of custom wheels.

Monday, Feb 4 at 7:33 PM Jeremy wrote ...

I am with Steve on the wheel tax! The streets are terrible and they are/were supposed to get better from the tax. Even in the summer they still leave alot to be desired.

Monday, Feb 4 at 6:52 PM SD driver wrote ...

I wish the city would be liable... I bent a tierod due to their pot hole that was unavoidable. Thanks to them $600.00 to replace the tierod, new rim, and alignment.

Monday, Feb 4 at 6:49 PM Squirrel wrote ...

Yea if they would use the better stuff and make the guys work a little faster the cost would go down because they wouldn't have overtime and wouldn't be repairing it twice!!!

Monday, Feb 4 at 4:56 PM Steve-O wrote ...

Quit using cheap materials and use the good stuff to fix it. What happen to the the wheel tax money we pay.

Monday, Feb 4 at 4:48 PM Terri M. - South Bend wrote ...

If your car is damaged due to a pothole that you couldn't avoid, is the city liable?

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

Comments are moderated and will not appear on this story until after they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

WSBT and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

WSBT Weather

icon
70
°
More Weather
More On Demand

Stock Quotes

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

Tonight On WSBTFull Schedule

7.00
60 Minutes
8.00
Big Brother 10
9.00
Cold Case
10.00
Flashpoint
11.00
WSBT News
11.35
Irish Sports Report

Question of The Day

What are your thoughts on the state of the RV industry?

E-mail your comments to us. We'll pick some to read during WSBT News at 5:30.