Catholic bishops seminar won’t meet at Notre Dame because of 'Vagina Monologues'

By MARGARET FOSMOE and CLAUDIA BAYLISS, Tribune Staff Writers

Tools

University of Notre Dame

(WSBT file photo)

By Beth Boehne

SOUTH BEND — A theological seminar for Roman Catholic bishops that had been scheduled for the University of Notre Dame will be moved off campus because of a planned performance of the play "The Vagina Monologues."

The Catholic bishops made the decision because they disagree with the university administration’s decision to allow a student performance of the controversial play.

"Because of the likelihood of the presentation of the play ‘The Vagina Monologues’ at Notre Dame this year, the bishops made a collective decision to move the seminar off campus," the Most Rev. John M. D’Arcy, bishop of the Catholic Diocese of Fort Wayne-South Bend, said Thursday in a written statement. The bishop declined a request for an interview.

The seminar, which includes Notre Dame faculty speakers and is co-sponsored by the university’s Institute for Church Life, had been scheduled for Monday through Wednesday on campus. Instead, it will be at the convent of the Sisters of St. Francis in Mishawaka.

Notre Dame spokesman Dennis Brown confirmed that the bishops moved the gathering off campus and that the decision was related to "The Vagina Monologues."

The university issued the following written statement:

"We understand that not all are in full agreement about the propriety of allowing performances of this play on a Catholic campus. Because of concerns about the play and its potential performance, we have worked collaboratively with the bishops to move the conference out of respect for everyone involved.

"Notre Dame and the U.S. bishops have worked together constructively in the past, they are working together on this current meeting, and we are sure that our partnerships will continue in the future."

Brown said the Rev. John I. Jenkins, Notre Dame’s president, is not available for an interview on this issue.

Notre Dame students are planning a March 26-28 production of "The Vagina Monologues" in a campus classroom. All such student events require an academic sponsor. The departments of sociology and anthropology have tentatively agreed to co-sponsor the production.

The departments are awaiting a formal proposal from the student planners about academic panel discussions to coincide with the performances, said Mark Schurr, chair of the anthropology department. Once the proposal is presented and approved by the sponsoring departments, it also must be approved by the College of Arts & Letters.

The student planners could not be reached for comment.

"The Vagina Monologues," by playwright Eve Ensler, is a theater production that deals frankly with women’s views on their bodies and sexuality. It is performed annually on hundreds of college campuses with the goal of raising awareness about sexual assault and domestic violence.

Notre Dame student productions of the play were performed annually on campus from 2002 to 2006, and an off-campus version was presented last year.

Jenkins two years ago considered banning "The Vagina Monologues" because he was troubled that the play’s portrayal of sexuality opposes Catholic teachings. That prompted an extensive debate about Notre Dame’s Catholic identity.

After listening to widespread campus discussion, Jenkins announced that a Catholic university has nothing to fear from engaging in topics of the wider culture.

He did not ban the play. However, performances must be in a classroom setting (not a theater), the production cannot be used to raise money for community groups and each show much include an academic panel discussion.

The Notre Dame board of trustees passed a resolution in 2006 expressing confidence in Jenkins and agreeing in principle with the policies he developed for evaluating campus events that touch on the university’s Catholic identity.

D’Arcy has publicly criticized Notre Dame and Jenkins for allowing the play. In 2006, the bishop issued a nine-page pastoral response critiquing Jenkins’ decision and his reasons for not banning the play.

The Committee on Doctrine has seven members: the Most Rev. William E. Lori, bishop of Bridgeport, chairman; the Most Rev. Leonard P. Blair, bishop of Toledo; the Most Rev. José H. Gomez, archbishop of San Antonio; the Most Rev. Robert J. McManus, bishop of Worcester; the Most Rev. Arthur J. Serratelli, bishop of Paterson, N.J.; the Most Rev. Allen H. Vigneron, bishop of Oakland, Calif.; and the Most Rev. David A. Zubik, bishop of Pittsburgh.

The committee has several consultants, including John C. Cavadini, professor and chair of Notre Dame’s theology department; and Cardinal Francis George, archbishop of Chicago. Cavadini could not be reached today for comment.

Monday, Feb 25 at 3:54 PM Nancy Danielson wrote ...

The University of Notre Dame has had a long History of Fidelity to Catholic Truth. To continue in this Mission, it must not be afraid to speak the Truth.

Monday, Feb 25 at 3:05 PM egrady1111@sbcglobal.net wrote ...

Maybe we should save our tuition $$$ and send our grandchildren to a truely CATHOLIC univ.No money no fame --just the same old deceptive catholics at N.D.

Friday, Feb 22 at 11:53 AM Nancy Danielson wrote ...

P.S. The objectification of any person is also known as Slavery.

Wednesday, Feb 20 at 2:59 PM Nancy Danielson wrote ...

The monologues are a lie from the start. They are oppressive because they do not respect the Sacredness and Dignity of women. Notre Dame is a Catholic University. As Catholics, we hold that there is a Truth, ( Jesus Christ, The Word Made Flesh ) and for everything that we do , we must ask, is it of God? One does not debate a Truth. The Truth is where you hope to arrive at the end of the debate. To debate a Truth is nothing but a lack of Faith. Pray, Defend our Faith, BE NOT AFRAID.

Tuesday, Feb 19 at 11:14 AM Pat Conard wrote ...

It appears that the bishops have forgotten the long, rich tradition of Catholic scholarship. Fr. Jenkins has it right: a Catholic university has nothing to fear from engaging engaging in topics of the wider world. We insult the tradition when we stop this engagement! This non-engagement pretends that problems don't exist. It sends the message that the problems of the world are irrelevent to the Catholic Church. This is not what Jesus was about.

Sunday, Feb 17 at 8:40 PM Net wrote ...

Dana Jacobson starring in “The Vagina Monologues”? MAYBE at Notre Dame, but definitely on Fighting Irish Thomas. The Vagina Monologues’ St. Valentine’s Day Massacre at Notre Dame: An open letter to Fr. Jenkins http://www.fightingirishthomas.net/2008/02/vagina-monologues-st-valentines-day.html

Tuesday, Feb 12 at 10:13 AM Tomor wrote ...

Perhaps Mary will continue to turn a deaf ear to the plight of the ND Football Team until ND decides to act Catholic rather than secularist.

Saturday, Feb 9 at 9:16 PM John wrote ...

I believe this was first reported on by Notre Dame's Catholic student paper, The Irish Rover, and was only later picked up on by the South Bend Tribune, Catholic News Agency, and other outlets. It's all at their blog, irishwatchdog.blogspot.com .

Saturday, Feb 9 at 11:32 AM joan sheridan wrote ...

South Bend is lucky to have a Bishop who is not afraid to be Catholic. Also to answer the first comment..the Catholic Bishops have cleaned up their house and if she was interested she could find out all they have done...I admit it was late but they have done it.

Saturday, Feb 9 at 9:22 AM mary phillips, new york wrote ...

Thank God for the spine shown by the bishops. Shame on Notre Dame University's "catholic" leader for his cowardice.

Saturday, Feb 9 at 12:41 AM John wrote ...

Hurrah for the Catholic Bishop's decision to remove themselves from the campus of Notre Dame because of this play. It is refreshing to see the Bishops stand up to be counted and quite consistent with their responsibilities and current efforts to refresh the image of church leaders in the wake of the 'scandal'. They made the right choice. The school president failed to be the guide his vocation calls him to be....or perhaps he isn't Catholic, I can't be sure in any case.

Friday, Feb 8 at 11:51 PM Anonymous wrote ...

What is it with Catholics, especially the heirarchy? They act like they are so holy & so above everyone else. Why don't they clean up their own house w/their child molesting clergy, teachers, etc. & all the other dirty little secrets they have before going around telling everyone else how to behave. I would expect nothing less from such a patriarchal system. Women don't count, they can't hold positions of authority in the church (my how well that's turned out) so this is a huge shock.

Friday, Feb 8 at 4:39 PM candy wrote ...

Just another way of saying that women's experiences don't count

Friday, Feb 8 at 1:40 PM Confused? wrote ...

Is THAT what they're calling their football team these days?

Friday, Feb 8 at 11:55 AM Pam wrote ...

This is exactly what the Catholic bishops should do. They should model the teachings of the faith. Father Jenkins also has a responsibility to adhere to the teachings of the Catholic Church.

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

Comments are moderated and will not appear on this story until after they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

WSBT and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

Most Popular

WSBT Weather

icon
60
°
More Weather
More On Demand

Stock Quotes

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

Tonight On WSBTFull Schedule

7.00
60 Minutes
8.00
Big Brother 10
9.00
Cold Case
10.00
CSI: NY
11.00
WSBT News
11.35
Irish Sports Report

Question of The Day

Who is going to win the Super Bowl 2007 rematch?

  • Bears
  • Colts

Most Popular