Negotiators reach property tax relief deal

By MIKE SMITH, AP Political Writer

Tools

Property tax reform

Indiana House and Senate negotiators have reportedly reached a compromise on property tax reform. (WSBT file photo)

By Beth Boehne

INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — Legislative leaders reached a compromise on a sweeping property tax relief and reform plan that they said was headed for a vote either late Thursday night or on Friday — the deadline for adjourning the session.

The deal struck between negotiators for majority House Democrats and ruling Senate Republicans would provide additional property tax cuts for homeowners this year, cap future bills for most property owners, and subject major local building projects to referendums.

The state sales tax would be raised from 6 percent to 7 percent to help pay for the property tax relief, which also would include the state absorbing some major local levies. Those include remaining school operating costs and some child welfare expenses.

The plan would result in homeowners' tax bills this year being cut by 31 percent on average statewide from what they were last year, according to Senate Republicans.

Senate Tax Chairman Luke Kenley, R-Noblesville, said when the plan was fully implemented in 2010, homeowner bills that year would be nearly 38 percent lower on average statewide than they otherwise are projected to be.

"I think the homeowners and the taxpayers are the winners in this exercise," Kenley said.

House Speaker Patrick Bauer, D-South Bend, said it was "a compromise all the way through." It included some provisions sought by Democrats, including an increase in the earned income tax credit for lower-income working Hoosiers, an increase in the renters deduction, and added tax breaks for lower-income seniors.

Republican Gov. Mitch Daniels did not have any immediate comment on the compromise, but he was heavily involved in negotiations that led to the agreement.

He had warned lawmakers that if they failed to pass a plan acceptable to him by the midnight Friday deadline for adjournment, he would call them back in a special session. He said any package must provide immediate, significant and lasting property tax relief and reform.

The compromise legislation included some key components of a comprehensive plan he presented last October. They included statutory tax bill caps, and legislation that would begin the process of amending them into the state constitution so they would be harder to undo.

The homeowner relief this year would be provided by adding $620 million from the increased sales tax revenue to $250 million already allocated for additional homestead credits in 2008.

The tax bill caps would be phased in over the next two years. When fully implemented in 2010, most homeowners' tax bills would be limited to 1 percent of their homes' assessed value, with 2 percent caps on rental property and 3 percent limits on business property. The caps could be exceeded if voters approved major bonding projects through referendums.

The caps are projected to save property taxpayers about $600 million when fully implemented in 2010. But that that is money that schools and local municipalities would not get.

House Democrat leaders in recent weeks have said they shared concerns cited by many educators and local government officials that the caps would result in severe budget cuts and reduced services such as police and fire protection. The plan would set aside $120 million for schools over the next two years to soften the caps' impact on them.

Lake and St. Joseph counties were among a handful of counties that would be especially hit hard, so as part of the compromise, their existing debt would not count against the caps. The resolution that would amend the caps into the constitution would continue to exempt their existing debt from the caps through Dec. 31, 2019.

Beginning next year, the state would absorb all school operating costs, four child welfare levies, local juvenile detention costs, money local governments owe for pre-1977 pension plans for police and firefighters, and property taxes used to subsidize costs hospitals incur treating the indigent.

Taking over the levies could cost the state $2.5 billion or more. They would be funded through revenue from the sales tax increase and using about $2.1 billion the state now pays local governments to keep property tax bills lower.

Democrats from both chambers have expressed concerns that the state might be unable to afford absorbing those costs, especially with the sluggish economy and the hit it has been taking on state tax collections.

"With the numbers that we're seeing in terms of actual collections and the commitment that we're making to assume the responsibilities for those levies, it's going to make budget-making next year extremely difficult," said House Ways and Means Chairman William Crawford, D-Indianapolis.

House Minority Leader Brian Bosma, R-Indianapolis, said the plan retained much of the framework his caucus endorsed at the start of the session. That included tax bill caps, referendum requirements for major bonding projects, and starting the process of amending the caps into the constitution for a vast majority of the state.

"I'm encouraged that there is an agreement," he said. "Am I thrilled with the content of the agreement? No, I'm not, but it does meet many of the standards for success that the House Republicans endorsed at the start of the session."

Friday, Mar 14 at 9:20 AM Tim Hughes wrote ...

Bauer stood with local politicians to not have property taxes capped instead of representing the citizens. He is a traitor

Friday, Mar 14 at 9:10 AM Anonymous wrote ...

Bauer, you're a crook! Resign your office. You've screwed us over for the last time. If there was against what you did, you should be arrested! VOTE BERNIE PATRICK BAUER OUT OF OFFICE!

Friday, Mar 14 at 8:39 AM tax poor wrote ...

Mayor and I use the term loosely.Rea....I hope your next position does not involve a budget....hope your wife has the check book....McDonalds is hiring at Twin Branch ....just an FYI

Friday, Mar 14 at 8:32 AM Anonymous wrote ...

Meanwhile Patrick Bower and John Broden are high-fiving each other, because they managed to get in a tax increase, to cover their spending. They think they got away with it.

Friday, Mar 14 at 12:57 AM Jim wrote ...

I find it odd that B. Patrick Bauer used his position of speaker of the house to get the St. Joseph clause in.

Friday, Mar 14 at 12:43 AM Chaz wrote ...

Jim, someone posted all the email adresses and phone numbers of these officials at WNDU replies to the story but "someone" there deleted them. WSBT will let them be here as they are a REAL news organization! Post them please!!

Thursday, Mar 13 at 11:23 PM C'huck wrote ...

Not only are there exemptions to the caps, but the exemptions start from the first dollar, instead of just allowing for the amount above average to be exempted. After the mayors get done playing games to shift costs into either "School Construction" or "debt service" accounts over the next two years, I expect our "capped" rate to be closer to 3% than the 1% neighboring counties will see. Now the mayors can watch our abandoned housing, employment, and crime problems really explode.

Thursday, Mar 13 at 10:08 PM Anonymous wrote ...

Jim, post their addresses if you can find them.

Thursday, Mar 13 at 9:13 PM Nick wrote ...

So basically we were hoping for property tax releif, instead, we gave our elected leaders the ability to continue to raise our property tax in the years to come while the rest of the state has caps. They wont collect anything on a vacant home and will collect even less on homes that will drop in value. This will accelerate area foreclosures.

Thursday, Mar 13 at 8:57 PM Nick wrote ...

Lets not wait to vote them out. I think impeachment or a recall election would be better

Thursday, Mar 13 at 8:44 PM D C wrote ...

We have no choice but to file a lawsuit to get fair treatment we must have the most dumb leaders in the world. BY THE WAY, KEEP PUTTING THE SAME STUPID JERKS IN OFFICE FOLKS.

Thursday, Mar 13 at 8:08 PM mc wrote ...

Steve Luecke, Jeff Rea and Patrick Bauer, I hope you enjoy your last term in office.

Thursday, Mar 13 at 7:59 PM Jim wrote ...

Lets protest in front of Bauer, Luecke and Dvorak's House Who's in?

Thursday, Mar 13 at 7:00 PM What? wrote ...

This is absurd. St. Joe residents pay the highest taxes in the state and we are getting screwed. I CANNOT wait to to vote this year.

Thursday, Mar 13 at 6:40 PM Concern Citizen wrote ...

The political leadership in St Joe Cty is out of touch with reality. There lackluster performance continues to destroy our "COUNTY'S" business infrastructure while maintaining a government infrastructure populate with "DO NOTHING" bureaucrats. The Lake and St Joe Cty tax relief proposal is absolutely absurd. . .One more time, we are the exception rather than the rule!

Thursday, Mar 13 at 6:31 PM Will Ditzler wrote ...

I can not even believe what our own representitives are doing to us. Thanks Pat, we get the higher sales tax but no property tax relief, thereby subsidizing the rest of Indiana's tax relief. This is rediculous and the citiizens should go balistic over this until we get included. E-mail and call the Governor and our representatives Now! I will be long gone from this County before we get any relief. I am speechless.

Thursday, Mar 13 at 6:23 PM Anonymous wrote ...

DON'T EVER FORGET THIS!! EVER!!! Vote them all out!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! IMPEACH LUECKE!!!!!!

Thursday, Mar 13 at 5:52 PM Tired of bending over wrote ...

St. Joe County politicians are addicted to spending YOUR money. We need to vote the lot of they out of office. They need to learn what it is like to be a private citizen. I am tired of paying for this waste. I pity the fixed income retirees, choosing between food and paying the taxes so they can keep their homes.

Thursday, Mar 13 at 4:50 PM rebecca wrote ...

so what does this mean for us kos county people i dont understand this is so confusing to me can some one help me on this matter

Thursday, Mar 13 at 4:49 PM Anonymous wrote ...

st joe county could get the same caps, but would have to raise the local county income tax to 2%, it is at .08% now,,,so pay me now or pay me later..tax shift,not a tax break.

Thursday, Mar 13 at 4:47 PM Pam wrote ...

Well I think our leaders may end up being the only people left living in St. Joe County, I am already thinking about moving out of this county and to one of our connecting counties if this is what they are projecting. St. Joe county may become a ghost town. I think we need to make sure an vote out all our representitives in the next up coming elections. Listen to your people.

Thursday, Mar 13 at 4:31 PM Indiana Resident wrote ...

Mitch Daniels: By Phone: 317-232-4567 By Mail: Office of the Governor Via the web:http://www.in.gov/gov/2310.htm Statehouse Indianapolis, Indiana 46204-2797

Thursday, Mar 13 at 4:30 PM J.C. wrote ...

I'M MOVIN TO MICHIGAN, INDIANA MAKES NO SENSE TO ME...UGHHHHHH!!

Thursday, Mar 13 at 4:27 PM Amy wrote ...

Bauer can be e-mailed at h5@in.gov and Craig Fry at h6@in.gov Others can be researched on www.in.gov site.

Thursday, Mar 13 at 3:59 PM Anonymous wrote ...

Everyone remember who did this...Steve Luecke, Jeff Rea and Patrick Bauer.

Thursday, Mar 13 at 3:33 PM Anonymous wrote ...

Hey, WSBT, how about a subtitle for this article. Make it something like "St. Joseph County gets screwed".

Thursday, Mar 13 at 3:30 PM Bob wrote ...

I can't emagine why people in st. joe county even bother to vote. How dumb does it get

Thursday, Mar 13 at 3:29 PM Dennis Ralston wrote ...

House of Representitves phone #1-800-382-9842 Bauer's email: h6@in.gov Ryan Dvorak's email: h8@in.gov www.in.gov will get you a lot of contact info

Thursday, Mar 13 at 3:24 PM Anonymous wrote ...

You can protest with an email to Mitch Daniels here. Tell him to veto the bill if St. Joseph county is not included in the cap. http://www.in.gov/gov/2310.htm

Thursday, Mar 13 at 3:09 PM Outraged in St Joe County wrote ...

So the rest of the state gets relief and we don't?! It's time for the voters of St Joe County to get rid of the same "old" tired elected officials and vote in some new blood.

Thursday, Mar 13 at 2:17 PM Fred wrote ...

Dennis, could you post email addresses to contact? I bet we can innundate the representatives and the governor with protests.

Thursday, Mar 13 at 2:16 PM ms wrote ...

There must be one or two more drops of blood left in this county that they are squeezing out - what a bunch of bull.

Thursday, Mar 13 at 1:38 PM Concerned Citizen wrote ...

Reading another "article" about this situation has me fuming. They are saying that Lake and St. Joe counties will be exempt from caps. How in the world do they expect that to fly. I agree with Dennis...why aren't we entitled to the same caps. If St. Joe county was run by people who had a clue we wouldn't be a situation that would screw the schools out of money. ERRRR...I'm mad...sorry.

Thursday, Mar 13 at 1:16 PM Dennis Ralston wrote ...

How in the world are we not entitled to same caps as everyone else? I am so upset I can't even type anymore. Contact your representives now.

Thursday, Mar 13 at 1:16 PM Concerned about Property Taxes wrote ...

It is my understanding that Rep Bauer is attempting to get St. Joseph and Lake Counties exemptede from the property tax caps. Therefore the rest of the state may get property tax relief, while we will continue to pay an exorbitant amount. Is this what the constituents of St. Joseph county want?

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

WSBT and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, or remove user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum. Items that may be considered inappropriate to post are those containing profanity, hatred, or insensitive, vulgar, unlawful or threatening comments.

WSBT Weather

icon
Current Temp 13
°
More Weather
More On Demand

Stock Quotes

YouNews

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.
This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

Tonight On WSBTFull Schedule

7.00
Jeopardy!
7.30
Wheel of Fortune
8.00
CSI: NY
9.00
CSI
10.00
Eleventh Hour
11.00
WSBT News
11.35
Late Show with David Letterman
12.35
Late Late Show with Craig Ferguson

Question of The Day

How often do you check your smoke detectors?

E-mail your comments. We'll pick some to read during WSBT News at 5.