Washington students and staff sound off on Clinton decision

by Troy Kehoe (tkehoe@wsbt.com)

Tools

Clinton at Washington High School

Students at Washington High School are circulating a petition that expresses their disappointment with the decision not to allow Sen. Hillary Clinton to speak at the school. (WSBT photo)

By WSBT News1

SOUTH BEND — Students and staff spoke out at Washington High School Thursday, after learning that administrators said "no thanks" to a proposed campaign stop by Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton.

It was the talk of the town Thursday, and not just in South Bend. Washington High School was plastered on the front pages of newspapers and websites from Michigan to Chicago and Indianapolis.

And in the hallways of the high school, the subject was the same.

WSBT talked to a group of about a dozen students Thursday afternoon, and asked them if they felt cheated by the South Bend Community School Corporation's decision.

"Absolutely," they all agreed.

"We never got a voice," said sophomore Victoria Mallard. "We never got a say so in our school not being chosen."

"It's not fair how they just pushed us aside," agreed junior Raven Mallard.

"It could have been an amazing experience for people, because it could have opened many people's eyes that aren't used to politics and government," said Jareen Austin, one of a handful of students in the room who will be eligible to vote in the general election later this year. "It would have given us a chance to voice our opinions on something historic."

Even teachers noticed it.

"I think some of them took it personally," said social studies and government teacher Lisa Jarrett. "They have a lot of pride here on the west side. And to have that opportunity rested from them was ... unsettling."

"My government students, 90 percent of them are registered to vote," agreed social studies department head Mary Schmanski. "They were so excited to have the opportunity to meet Senator Clinton. It was just devastating for them."

"They didn't really understand the reasons why," she continued. "And they took it very personally. And it was hard to clarify the reasons why. Then we found out she was coming to Mishawaka [High School], and it was was even more disappointing for them."

It's one reason why Jarrett and Schmanski helped students who wanted to start a petition demanding to know why the decision was made.

Click here to read the petition.

"We want somebody to tell us the truth," said another student. "We just want a real explanation, not a lie."

By 3 p.m., the petition already had nearly 300 signatures. But the students said they still had no answers.

Superintendent Robert Zimmerman refused to speak with WSBT on camera about the decision, but acknowledged in a statement that he was the one who made it after consulting with school board members and administrators.

Click on the link in the Related Content box to read that press release.

Among the reasons listed on the release:

1) This rally was a public event, not a student event.

2) The size and scope of this event could have increased risk to student safety.

3) It has been a long standing practice of the SBCSC not to allow political campaigning during the school day by students, faculty or staff.

But many students and staff don't buy those reasons.

"This school would have been so heavily guarded that nobody would have been able to even get in a fingernail file," said Victoria Mallard.

"This was a learning event," said another student. "For both people in public and students."

But there's something else that had the teens even more upset.

"The worst thing is what people are saying on the Internet about us," said junior Trisha Salinas. "That the reason she can't come is she's not black. Or she doesn't play sports. Or she doesn't play basketball. Or she doesn't carry a gun."

Comments posted anonymously on the Internet have alluded that some think Washington is too run down or dangerous to host a presidential candidate.

"That's the worst," Salinas continued. "Because that's not what our school is about at all."

But some students say they're not going to let any of it get them down, or stop them from learning. That's why they plan to attend Clinton's rally in Mishawaka.

And they'll all be wearing "Panther" green, and carrying the petition to help send a message.

Washington principal George McCullough says students will be excused to attend the speech in Mishawaka, as long as they have a signed note from a parent.

"I don't think [the petition] is going to change anything at all," said Victoria Mallard. "But look at how many people signed this. It's basically saying, we care!"

"We won't let this stop our young minds from expanding," agreed Austin. "We'll create, and learn more about it. Maybe it will even inspire one of us to run for president someday," he said with a smile.

Several students said their teachers have offered them extra credit if they write to administrators, school board members, or candidates to talk about how they feel about the campaign stop decision.

Dr. Zimmerman's statement does say the corporation would have been willing to host a Clinton event after school, but doesn't elaborate beyond that.

South Bend Mayor Steve Luecke also refused to comment on the corporation's decision.

Tuesday, Apr 22 at 12:41 PM R. wrote ...

Heres a thought GET OVER IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Flag for moderation

Thursday, Apr 17 at 8:51 PM Ben wrote ...

Boot out Zimmerman, he's a joke and a horrible superintendent. He shouldn't have another job in this state

Flag for moderation

Monday, Apr 7 at 6:17 PM kb wrote ...

from what I am hearing, the democratic process is being denied to our students. to hear from Obama and not from Clinton. Watch it big brother is watching. If Obama is allowed to speak there, it truly is a racist issue.

Flag for moderation

Sunday, Mar 30 at 1:22 PM Debbie wrote ...

I support the T-Shirt business, LET'S FIRE THEM ALL!!!! They don't care about our kids education, so it looks like we will have to do it ourselves!! WHS is no worse or better than any of the High School, If they would have left our system alone and leave it the way it was 15 years ago, our kids would have a better education and appreicate school alot more than the crap they have to deal with these days!! Glad I'm not a kid in school these days!! Lets help our kids, fire them all!!!!!

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 11:16 PM disappointed wrote ...

I think it is a disgrace that a chosen leader such as Dr.Zimmerman would take matters into his own hands and let down much of the South Bend Community... you should try to keep your personal oppinions @ home. Think about what you're indirectly teaching your students SB Washington before making important decisions !!

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 8:43 PM Anonymous wrote ...

Sorry to WHS students and staff. Wish I could do something else besides offer sympathy to those who need it, as well as gripe to those who need it. Though I have no say when it comes to SB schools, I do have a voice, so I think I shall make a few phone calls on your behalf. I suppose I should wait a few days, week, or month... however long it takes until their heads are out of the sand. I feel they need to make an apology to students, parents and staff instead of the "blah blah" blame game.

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 6:33 PM Sharon Weesner wrote ...

I also am a graduate of WHS. I think it is a travesty that Washington was denied the opportunity of a lifetime. It is clearly a negative attitude about the west side that has been perpetrated throughout my lifetime here. I didn't know my school was "bad" until someone from another school told me. Prejudice and, as others have said, "stupidity" played a part. Oh, by the way, I was Valedictorian of the class of 1979, have enjoyed a nice career as a published writer, and I CAN spell MORON.

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 6:22 PM Anonymous wrote ...

All of our high schools have issues, and it shouldn't reflect on the whole student body. I'm a student at Marian. There are bad seeds there. As there are at Riley, Clay, Mishawaka- ANY high school you go to. Kudos to Washington students for standing up and speaking out against the pathetic excuse of the SBCSC. You were truly cheated out of a great opportunity.

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 6:01 PM David wrote ...

I don't think this was a black/white issue, but a political one. I bet if she were a Republican a different decision would have been reached. These children, and the community, whether they like this candidate or not, lost out on a great opportunity to hear a wonderful speaker and potential future leader of our country.

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 5:15 PM Margaret Lepay wrote ...

Dr. Zimmerman, you screwed up again!!!! Everybody fought to keep you in South Bend, now I wonder why they did it.

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 4:02 PM Anonymous wrote ...

Everyone needs to attend the next board meeting for the members to remember who put them in office and we are ready for some new faces! South Bend Schools lost a chance of a lifetime and managed to get more negative news spread about them but this time it went nation wide. Shame on the school board!! Thanks Mishawaka it was a great event!!!

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 3:57 PM Watching & Waiting wrote ...

You know what would be funny? If Obama's people contacted SBCSC about doing a town meeting at one of their high schools and they had to say 'NO' again! OOPS!

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 3:30 PM Billy wrote ...

Argh. Harumph. Argghhh! Me Hulk. Me smash school.

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 3:07 PM ED wrote ...

NOT TALKING TO NEWS REPORTERS,TEACHERS,STUDENTSAND PARENT ABOUT DECESIONS THAT AFFECT THEM,SEEM TO BE THE NEW POLICY OF THIS SCHOOL SYSTEM LEADERS. THIS IS THE SAME POLICY USED JUST A FEW MONTHS BACK WHEN THIS BOARD TRIED TO FIRE YOU ,MR ZIMMERMAN.

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 2:50 PM ED wrote ...

SHAME ON YOU MR. ZIMMERMAN YOU LOST THE RESPECT OF THOSE WHO FOUGHT SO HARD FOR YOU JUST A FEW SHORT MONTHS AGO. YOU LESTENED TO THOSE SAME BOARD MEMBERS WHO TRIED TO FIRE YOU A COUPLE MONTHS AGO AND LET THOSE DOWN THAT STOOD BY YOU. WE THOUGHT YOU HAD THE COURAGE TO STAND UP TO THIS SELF-MOTIVATED BOARD AND DO WHAT WAS BEST FOR OUR CHILDREN. WE WERE WRONG. WHEN THESE SAME BOARD MEMBERS TRY AGAIN TO FIRE YOU IN THE COMING MONTHS,MANY OF US WILL NOT BE THERE TO SUPPORT YOU THIS TIME.

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 1:50 PM annette wrote ...

It doesn't matter what your political views are. These kids missed an opportunity to be close to something that would have been historic. We aren't talking about elementary. These are young adults. I would have felt the same no matter who the candidate was. Maybe it would have garnered enough interest from some that they would have gone to the Obama office and helped campaign. It is about exposing them to something important in their future. And what about "Social Studies?"

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 1:14 PM The Printer wrote ...

Would somebody please tell me where to send the 9 certificates of achievement that are being awarded to the SCCSC Board and it's Super-duper-super? They are from the David and Dorothy Snyder School of Brilliant Governing Decisions. By the way; they're coming C.O.D! NO CHECKS!

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 1:06 PM panther parent wrote ...

This is a slap to all students. WHS is the school who gets all the other kids no one wants & we try to turn them around. The School Board has once again told them that the West Side isn't worth investing in. Thank God that there are Great Kids who go there, who stay out of trouble and give of themselves to make the west side the best side. It doesn't matter who asked to come, Obama, Clinton, McCain, a chance was denied to kids who DESERVE a chance. We're alot more than basketball & guns.

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 12:44 PM Anonymous wrote ...

Schedule for the next few Board Meetings: April 14, 22. May 5, 12, 19. I plan on attending with my new t-shirt SAVE OUR SCHOOLS: FIRE THEM ALL!

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 12:41 PM JACKIE wrote ...

Thanks South Bend for not letting her in your schools its a shame Mishawaka did not do the same.

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 12:32 PM PK wrote ...

Do you realize that we are even being talked about in the Dallas metroplex area? We all know there were underlying reasons that nobody wants to talk about. Even this site will not publish all comments. Wake up....remove these officals-board, Zim and Leuke. They all dropped the ball and really were happy to do it. Wake up you sleepy heads!

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 11:04 AM I am sad wrote ...

Wahington High School hat of to they to our colors true we shall ever be firm and stong united are we rah rah rah rah hats of to Washington High!

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 11:04 AM Patti wrote ...

Once again, Mishawaka trumps South Bend (as they do in most things.) I am not a Hillary fan but the lost opportunity...What a pathetic example of an elected school board!!!

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 10:58 AM Michele wrote ...

My husband and I are former panthers who have two sons who are panthers now. Not only have they let down the present students but past and future. I do not believe Zimmerman has the best interests of are students,schools and community. He passed on this opportunity, which leads me to wonder what else we will miss with him as superintendent. We will take our panther pride with us as we go to Mishawaka High to share the glory that should have been our place in history. GO PANTHERS!

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 10:45 AM MARY ANN wrote ...

SOUNDS LIKE ZIMMERMAN IS AS IGNORANT AS JOHN GLENNS SUPER DICK REESE AND NOT TO MENTION SUE ELLEN REED FROM INDY " THE BIG KAHOONA" OF ALL OF THEM. ALL THEY THINK OF IS THEMSELVES AND HOW THEY MAY LOOK BAD NOT WHAT IS RIGHT FOR OUR KIDS. THEY ARE ALL OVERPAID FOR WHAT LITTLE THEY DO, OTHER THAN SIT BEHIND A DESK SHUFFLING PAPERS AND TAKING THAT WAY TOO BIG OF A PAYCHECK. SORRY WASHINGTON HIGH AND SHAME ON YOU ZIMMERMAN. YOU MUST BE RELATED TO REESE AND REED????!!!!

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 10:08 AM Anonymous wrote ...

There are a lot of kids that are going to be able to vote that are in school and a lot of people think that it would be chaos. It would only be chaos if people make it that way. I think that it's great that they are trying to reach out to the young people. I think that the students should of had an opinion in the matter cause it sounds to me that they would have loved the opportunity to have this experience in there own school. It is a once in a lifetime experience.

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 9:23 AM BILL wrote ...

THE REASON THEY GAVE THESE KIDS WAS CRAP! THERE WAS NO SAFETY ISSUES, MR ZIMMERMAN MADE THIS CHOICE ON HIS OWN. THEN HE SHOULD BE FIRED! THE SO CALLED LEADERS OF OUR FINE CITY SHOULD DO SOMETHING ABOUT THIS. YOU KNOW THE MAYOR WON'T DO ANYTHING,AND THE REST OF THEM ARE AS DUMB AS A BOX OF ROCKS. ITS TIME FOR REAL CHANGE, LET'S CLEAN HOUSE!

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 9:22 AM gary wrote ...

look at all the good pr Mishawaka is getting from this. and south bend gets a black eye. i guess south bend does not not people in power to come to are town. this would have been a event the city and the kids would never for get. a former 1st lady and the 1st woman to ran for the high job in the land we tell he go way. don't we teach government is school what a leaning chance for the kid 1st hand. sad sad sad and mishawaka looks good and we look like a city ashamed of it schools.firer him

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 9:18 AM ev wrote ...

clinton should not have even asked to use a high school as a backdrop for her campaign. what a mess she created, and poor zimmerman,who made the right decision, according to his facts.if he would have said yes, everyone would have criticized just as much.

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 9:12 AM Bill wrote ...

IT WOULD NOT HAVE CAUSED ANY PROBLEMS FOR THE STUDENTS OR NEIGHBORHOOD!POINT BLANK, THESE PEOPLE MADE THE WRONG CHOICE. I GREW UP ON THE WEST SIDE AND I THINK IT WOULD HAVE MADE A HUGE IMPACT ON THE ENTIRE COMMUNITY! THE FACT THAT PEOPLE THINK IT WAS A BAD CHOICE TO LET HER COME THERE IS PLAIN DUMB!! AND YES WE ENDED UP ON THE FRONT PAGE NEWS IN CHICAGO, INDY. WAY TO GO ZIMMERMAN YOU REALLY MADE US ALL LOOK LIKE IDIOTS!!!!!

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 9:10 AM CS wrote ...

Get a life "Louise" - these kids care about their education, that's why they are standing up to the superintendent. Who does he think he is? This was a perfect place for this campaign stop - these kids are our future, they need to know what it's all about and this was an opportunity of a life time. I will definately remember this, as will many others when it comes time to re-elect the school board and their leader. This is absolute nonsense on their parts.

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 9:04 AM South Bend Continued wrote ...

Last time I checked, Mishwaka had a high dropout rate. All schools have issues. For those at WHS that WANT to learn and excel, keep your heads up and continue to fight for your education! I am a proud graduate who is sucessful. I credit good teachers and good parenting to that. It is the administration of the schools (i.e. the board, Superintendent) that are lacking leadership. Again, shame on them for denying students of voting age this opportunity.

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 9:00 AM South Bend wrote ...

Kudos to these kids for standing up against the board! As a former Panther, this would have been a great opportunity for the students who could have went. Yes, it is disruptive, but so are the seminars they force students to go to. But they go becasue they are EDUCATIONAL. And for those bashing the kids, a few bad seeds to not reflect an entire student body. There are many students at this school who are excellant. There are many talented athletes at this school (state champions anyone)

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 8:43 AM Horrified wrote ...

What happened to societies fairness and separation of politics and state tax funded SUPPOSED politic NEUTRAL institutions? If a tax paid for school can promote one candidate without fairly representing the other in the name of ‘education’ then I would call that one party socialism and NOT a democracy. What’s next? Catholic masses in public schools in the name of education? I would support all the candidates coming to the school but not just one. That’s NOT education, it is partisanship!

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 8:25 AM Louise wrote ...

The right decision was made by Robert Zimmerman. We have places for public appearances and they don't belong in the schools! What chaos that would have created for the students, teachers and the adjoining neighborhood.

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 7:22 AM c wrote ...

These kids are amazing. they are taking this horrible violation of there rights and turnning it into a learning expeiriance all on there own. Way to go guys. Keep it up.

Flag for moderation

Friday, Mar 28 at 6:57 AM Carrie wrote ...

All I heard the SBCSC say is blah blah blah. Another drop of the hat to them!!

Flag for moderation

Thursday, Mar 27 at 11:44 PM Des wrote ...

Please dont take to heart what these mean hearted people say. What they say does NOT matter,hold your heads high.The fault lies with the School Board and their bad decision.

Flag for moderation

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

Comments are moderated and will not appear on this story until after they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

WSBT and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

More On Demand

Stock Quotes

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

Tonight On WSBTFull Schedule

7.00
Wheel of Fortune
7.30
Jeopardy!
8.00
Ghost Whisperer
9.00
Moonlight
10.00
Numb3rs
11.00
WSBT News
11.35
Late Show with David Letterman

Question of The Day

What are you doing for Mother's Day?

E-mail your comments to us. We'll pick some to read during WSBT News.