Neighbor describes accused Penn student as strange

By TOM COYNE, Associated Press Writer

Tools

Penn High School

(Tribune File Photo/Margarita Bilbrey)

By Beth Boehne

SOUTH BEND (AP) — A neighbor of a 16-year-old boy accused of planning a Columbine-style attack on his high school described him as "kind of strange."

"He was an average kid, but kind of strange," said Allen McBride, who lives seven houses away. "He came down here one day with a snake wrapped around his arm and said, 'Do you want to buy a snake?' I said, 'Man get back there.'"

McBride said he's lived in the house for 22 years and had watched the boy grow up from the time he used to visit his deceased grandfather until he moved into the house with his uncle. He said the boy didn't spend time with other children in the neighborhood, though he used to play with another boy who has since moved away.

The boy was taken into custody after a school officer investigating an unrelated threat at Penn High School, 10 miles east of South Bend, discovered Internet postings in which the teen discussed his support for the Columbine shooters, a reference to the 1999 massacre at a suburban Denver high school in which two students killed 12 classmates and a teacher before committing suicide. Authorities also say he exchanged e-mails with an Ohio man about planning simultaneous attacks on Sept. 11.

Authorities said they found more than 100 knives and several illegal snakes at the home, which is in a rundown neighborhood scattered with vacant houses just blocks from downtown South Bend.

St. Joseph Probate Court Judge Peter Nemeth on Friday ordered the teen, whose name was not released because of his age, to remain in juvenile detention "for his own protection and protection of society." He also ordered him to undergo a psychological evaluation.

The teen's attorney, James Nafe, had asked the court to release him to the custody of his uncle, with whom he lives, saying he could keep an "eye on him."

Nemeth rejected the proposal, saying: "It doesn't sound from past history that anyone was keeping an eye on him."

The boy's mother told the judge that her son did not live with her in Mishawaka, just east of South Bend, because of an altercation. Nemeth stopped her when she tried to explain.

In a MySpace page believed to belong to the boy, although it could not be confirmed, the author describes himself as being 16 years old and lists himself as being "optimistic."

The page also has "TCMI" in brackets. An online search shows that TCM is often an abbreviation for Trench Coat Mafia, which the Columbine killers Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold called themselves.

The MySpace page has a link to a YouTube page with videos of a character named Hillbilly Benjamin. The character has a bearded mask on, plays the guitar upside down and sings a song laced with profanity. Another profanity-laden video with the same character said he would commit suicide by electrocution and shows him sitting in a chair simulating an execution. The video ends by stating that the suicide attempt was unsuccessful.

The last log-in to the MySpace page was on Tuesday, the day the youth was taken into custody.

Prosecutors have not decided whether to seek to have the case moved to adult court, said deputy prosecutor Eric Tamashasky. The results of the psychological tests will be part of that decision.

"It's another piece so we can make an informed decision that really is in the best interest of justice for everybody," he said.

Prosecutors have until Thursday to file delinquency charges, he said. There is no deadline for a decision to seek to have the case moved to adult court.

Friday, May 9 at 2:14 PM confused wrote ...

So, for all you who believe that this kid should not be prosecuted, just because he "thought" about commiting this crime. I would like to know when you think he should be prosecuted. Wait until he has already gone through with his plan?! I am so thankful that they were able to intervene and prevent this from happening. Everyone always looks back and states what should have been done. Here is a situation where they are able to stop it before it happens.

Friday, May 9 at 1:18 PM pitski wrote ...

Did you ever think that TCMI meant Trench Coat Mafia Indiana, yeah i'm sure this kid was going into ministry. HA!

Friday, May 9 at 1:08 PM Nick wrote ...

(The page also has "TCMI" in brackets. An online search shows that TCM is often an abbreviation for Trench Coat Mafia, which the Columbine killers Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold called themselves.) WOW. Are you serious? Thats one hell of a stretch to place TCMI as trench coat mafia. whats the I then? I did a internet search too, and I got TCMI.org in Indianapolis. Trains people for ministry. Maybe he was tryin to become a priest? Or a broker for Triple Crown Media International? Bad reporting

Monday, Apr 28 at 12:56 PM ANON wrote ...

Why are certain people out there criticizing the justice system for thinking about taking this case to the adult courts? Do you people not realize that this was a potential act of violence stopped BEFORE it took place? Or, are we supposed to sit by and WAIT for this to take place? According to you, we are!! How ignorant is your thinking? Have you not learned anything from the recent past? A lot of lives have just been spared due to the steps already taken! Think about it!!

Monday, Apr 28 at 9:06 AM Anonymous wrote ...

i know the the neighbor of the accused neighbor and he is strange too.

Monday, Apr 28 at 8:46 AM Anon wrote ...

PHM does let people in who are not in the district..u just have to have enough money...i know alot of people who do it

Monday, Apr 28 at 6:59 AM Dennis wrote ...

Thank You, Jason... Frightened and Ignorant is the best way to describe these people. if everyone had All of their personal freedoms taken away for simply the things they thought or said... well i'd hate to live in this country anymore. maybe all this kid needs is for someone to listen to him and Try to understand. i would Listen to him above all else... but that's just me. Reach out to help... not throw away in a dark dungeon. what's wrong with you so-called God-loving people? huh?

Sunday, Apr 27 at 9:49 PM Jason wrote ...

The kid didn't hurt anyone. Regardless of what he may have been planning, it doesn't prove he intended to go through with it. Yet your already talking about trying him as an adult and taking away his freedom. It disturbs me that I live in a community with so many frightened ignorant people.

Sunday, Apr 27 at 9:02 PM Penn grad wrote ...

Lock him up and throw away the key? It's that type of cynical thinking and bad parenting that has destroyed the youth in this country. Get him help and a constructive environment. It's the terrible parenting "adults" that should be ashamed of themselves.

Sunday, Apr 27 at 6:39 PM Psychologist wrote ...

I REALLY hope they prosecute him as an adult!This is not kids play here, this is a huge, ugly, violent crime he was planning to commit! He wanted to murder our babies and teachers! Lock him up and throw away the key! This type of person is not fit to be in society, it is way too risky!

Sunday, Apr 27 at 4:27 PM Amy wrote ...

Easy question to answer as to why this kid goes to Penn. If anyone really read the article or articles published the last few days, you would know that the boy WAS living with his mother but he moved in with his uncle. His mother must live in the Penn district so they are probably still going by his old address. It sounds like neither uncle nor mother can provide a good home for this kid. Hopefully he gets the help he needs.

Sunday, Apr 27 at 4:12 PM A Parent who cares wrote ...

He OBVIOUSLY was using a false address to got to Penn. PHM doesn't just let people in from other districts, it doesn't work that way! Good thing he was at Penn though, South Bend schools probably wouldn't have caught him in time. Good job Penn security! He will never lead a normal life now, that is for sure. Very sick young man.

Sunday, Apr 27 at 4:08 PM worried... wrote ...

that many of you should already know this CHILD needs and needed help all along. Why not try and look at what turned him so hateful of people... wouldnt be the anyone of the people who made those awful hateful comments now would it! My daughter goes to Penn funny how all of our schools have troubles not just SB. Maybe some of these bad talkers of SB schools should stand up to the plate and mentor some of these kids that might need someone to care about them and guid them...

Sunday, Apr 27 at 1:04 PM ANON wrote ...

How is it he goes to Penn if he lives in So. Bend? Seems to me someone's mother owes a lot of $ for tuition if he doesn't live in the Penn school district. When will THAT be brought up? Many other families have been charged or dismissed for this. Better he should be sent to a nice hospital where he can get help. Pretty far gone if he has planned this type of kill. How much gas did it take to cart him back and forth?

Sunday, Apr 27 at 8:48 AM anon wrote ...

why do you keep mentioning "just miles from south bend". this is a person who is a PENN student not from sb. what a shame

Sunday, Apr 27 at 8:43 AM Dennis wrote ...

Lock away and throw away the key? sounds like we're living in some Pretty compassionate times! you're no better than what this kid talked about doing. and so the neighbor called him Strange... how many of you out there are so straight-laced and "normal" that people don't call you a little strange? whenever someone is into something that others Do Not Understand; like art or music.. it's easy to pigeon-hole them and call them names because we do not understand. Fear causes this.

Saturday, Apr 26 at 9:31 PM Who do my taxes support, anyway!? wrote ...

I guess the real question is "Why is the media talking to this 'neighbor'? Who contacted whom, not that it matters, this wasn't news, just someones take on a kid he only really 'knew of'. Now I have a question for the fine folk on the PHM School Board. Just how large are your corporation boundaries anyway? What is this a freebe, South Bend can't handle all of them so step in a give them a hand? A few blocks from DT S.B IS NOT PHM district! Please tell me we aren't busing him to boot! Disgusting

Saturday, Apr 26 at 9:29 PM Parent in Osceola wrote ...

OK South Bend people saying this is a Penn thing...This kid should have been at Washington, not Penn. That said, what a sick boy this must be! I hope they try him as an adult and keep him locked away for a very long time! His parents should be ashamed of themselves!!!

Saturday, Apr 26 at 8:05 PM Disturbed wrote ...

"which is in a rundown neighborhood scattered with vacant houses just blocks from downtown South Bend." That pretty much narrows it down to that entire area :)

Saturday, Apr 26 at 1:33 PM Indina wrote ...

"kind of strange." Go figure.

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

Comments are moderated and will not appear on this story until after they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

WSBT and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

More On Demand

Stock Quotes

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

Tonight On WSBTFull Schedule

7.30
Jeopardy!
8.00
Cold Case
9.00
CSI: NY
10.00
48 Hours Mystery
11.00
WSBT News
11.35
CSI: Miami

Question of The Day

Should schools offer incentives for attendance?

E-mail your comments to us. We'll pick some to read during WSBT News.

  • Yes
  • No