Fighting Fakes: Knock-offs cost local businesses

by Dustin Grove (grove@wsbt.com)

Tools

Counterfeit hardware parts costing Johnson Products in Elkhart

Johnson Products in Elkhart says the hardware parts they've worked 50 years to perfect are being knocked off by counterfeiters overseas, and it's costing them business. (WSBT photo)

By Tiffany Griffin

SOUTH BEND — On a Monday afternoon in the South Bend Police Department parking lot, fraud detective Dominic Zultanski was tired. He'd been wheeling box after box, containing 10,000 DVDs out to a commercial-sized shredding machine.

Every single copy would be destroyed. They may be popular music and movies, but these particular DVDs won't be played anymore. They're fakes: pirated copies of the real thing to be sold on the street. The Motion Picture Association of America considers it a $250,000 loss to their sales.

"We've gotten these out of gas stations, we've gotten these out of homes," said Zultanski. And fake DVDs aren't the only kinds of counterfeit goods he's seen here.

"There are handbags and we've also had activity with watches."

Fake merchandise, often made overseas and shipped to the states, is no longer confined to the back alleys of big cities anymore. Just this spring, St.Joseph County Police, working with the Nike Corporation, raided a South Bend convenience store and confiscated close to 3,000 Nike knock-offs.

Each year, federal estimates show counterfeit products in general cost the United States $250 billion in lost sales.

In some cases, it's not just the loss of money that concerns authorities. It's where the money made on counterfeit goods may be going.

"This is just another way for criminal organizations to gain money for their craft," said Zultanski.

In two recent local cases, police said the people selling fake movies and music were also dealing stolen guns and drugs.

In 2002, international law enforcement officials testified before a Congressional committee, claiming the international trading of phony consumer goods had, in some cases, been linked to organized crime and even terrorism.

"Everyone talks about the six degrees of separation," said Zultanski. "When you're involved in this type of organized crime, you just made your degrees a lot shorter. If you buy one or two (counterfeit goods) you've taken your six degrees of being involved with a terrorist down to two or three."

Police say that doesn't necessarily mean the people selling fake goods locally are terrorists or organized crime bosses, but whether the sellers know it or not, authorities say they're part of the supply chain.

To stop the free flow of counterfeit goods, authorities and businesses are turning to Congress for help. Rep. Joe Donnelly, who represents Indiana's Second Congressional District has co-sponsored legislation that would treat intellectual property theft just like money laundering and other black market crimes.

"We are working hard to get other cosponsors in the House to get this to the floor for a vote and we are hopeful to move this forward," said Donnelly "We are going to go after them criminally and we're going to work to make sure their products cannot enter this country."

Monday, Jun 23 at 12:16 AM Gina wrote ...

What would be great - but impossible - would be for us to tarrif stuff they export to US, so much that the same product - made in the states - is cheaper than that made overse. I no more like to buy chinese stuff than you, but on a fixed income, if I just want toiletries, dishsoap, etc., I HAVE to patronize dollar stores. Unfortunately, they'd turn around an tarriff stuff WE export to them and...it'd be a moot point

Saturday, May 10 at 4:37 AM RAY wrote ...

The Mishawaka Police or ST. Joe County Sheriff will probably raid that purse party at Country Inn & Suites real soon...they will fill their squad cars with lots of fake handbags to give to their wives...

Friday, May 9 at 7:03 PM Anonymous wrote ...

wow isnt nike shoes made in china already? i wear durango boots,the tag inside says made in china.see they can make them cheaper there and ship them half way around the world and still be cheaper than if made in usa raise the import tax before china takes over the usa.the next major world war will be with china and we will lose because everything we need for defence is made in china! i think its their secret plan and our government and rich businessmens greed is falling into their plan!think!!

Friday, May 9 at 6:52 PM Anonymous wrote ...

how is it possable to get movies before they come out in theaters? i think that they a5e released in other countries first

Friday, May 9 at 6:50 PM Anonymous wrote ...

have you been asleep for the last few decades?the feds are already in charge thats why china is getting away with putting us. companies out of business!china pays less import tax that we pay to ship to china,think about it,thats why every thing says made in china at wal mart,who claimed that they only buy usa??????????????

Friday, May 9 at 6:45 PM Anonymous wrote ...

well if our government would raise the import tax to the same as we have to pay to import into other countries we would not have this problem! pattent laws dont go over seas,look at kamatsu now they want to put a kamatsu plant in peoria ill.the same place caterpillar equiptment is made! look out cat employees you jobs are now at risk for layoffs

Friday, May 9 at 5:44 PM Tierra wrote ...

U kno the stuff is fake so y bother with the raids! With the rise of food and gas, it'll get worse thant this! Lets get cheaper gas and then worry about the pety stuff!

Friday, May 9 at 2:57 PM Sue wrote ...

OK, somebody explain to me why a fake Chanel purse (that is priced at a fraction of the original) is wrong. You KNOW it's a fake by the price. Somebody is just copying it at a cheaper price for people who can't afford the real thing. Chanel is still making a bundle from the rich people who are buying the real thing and KNOW it's the real thing. ???

Friday, May 9 at 1:51 PM Anonymous wrote ...

while were at it, lets just put the feds in charge of all the commerce enterprises. they seem to think they got a grasp of the whole situation.

Friday, May 9 at 1:49 PM Anonymous wrote ...

we just notice this after decades. wow we are strecthing here. and by the way those outlet malls that are so popular with the soccer moms, u better shut them down too.

Friday, May 9 at 11:34 AM Edith wrote ...

WSBT, please do a story on the purse parties. Explain to people that these purses are as illegal as the knock-off shoes. People think since they are sold at in-home parties they aren't illegal, it's only illegal if you get them at store. Women need to know this is wrong!

Friday, May 9 at 12:41 AM seen it too! wrote ...

I have seen a lot of this stuff in gas stations and convience stores run by Foreign families. I can imagine where the money is going! I have seen bootleg gas trucks in my town too! NO signs on the tank or truck and they drove off real quick when they saw me and disapeared into the night. never saw a tanker go so fast!

Thursday, May 8 at 10:05 PM Anonymous wrote ...

There is a motel on the corner of Main street in mishawaka by target that frequently advertises on it's sign "purse Party".... this sat or sun....these are all fake purses...check with the hotel staff and see who holds these parties...who reserves the space.

Thursday, May 8 at 9:06 PM D wrote ...

This is why we can not allow prescription drugs to be imported into this country. The Chinese will poison us!

Thursday, May 8 at 7:25 PM Gretchen wrote ...

I wish we would do the same in Michigan. I waked into a local store in my town for the first time and it was filled with fakes - Chanel, Prada, D&G and about every other big-name brand. I made a call to the MI state police and was told they couldn't do a thing. Indiana, you're far ahead of us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

Comments are moderated and will not appear on this story until after they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

WSBT and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

Most Popular

WSBT Weather

icon
57
°
More Weather
More On Demand

Stock Quotes

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

Tonight On WSBTFull Schedule

7.00
Wheel of Fortune
7.30
Jeopardy!
8.00
Big Bang Theory
8.30
How I Met Your Mother
9.00
Two and a Half Men
9.30
The New Adventures of Old Christine
10.00
CSI: Miami
11.00
WSBT News
11.35
Late Show with David Letterman

Question of The Day

Who is going to win the Super Bowl 2007 rematch?

  • Bears
  • Colts

Most Popular