Graffiti cases may signal bigger issue for neighborhoods

by Troy Kehoe (tkehoe@wsbt.com)

Tools

Graffiti cases may signal bigger issue for neighborhoods

By Jim Pinkerton

SOUTH BEND — It's an epidemic that's already grown to record proportions on South Bend's west side. But now, some are worried graffiti may also be a sign of a much larger problem: an increase in gang activity.

The numbers are staggering.

"We have painted over 282 sites already this year," said South Bend Weed and Seed Coordinator Mark Dollinger. Last year it was 290 for the whole year."

And those 282 sites are only in the city's 2nd and 6th districts, where Weed and Seed grant money has funded cleanup efforts. South Bend Police estimate an additional 200 graffiti sites haven't even been touched yet.

But some say paint isn't the only problem.

They're worried that gangs are behind the rapid increase in "tags," and that has some living in high graffiti areas worried.

"There's graffiti everywhere," said Sandra Hernandez, whose home just off Western Avenue has been "tagged" several times this summer.

From houses and garages to stop signs and even trees, it seems nothing has been left untouched by a spray can.

"We don't know what time they do it. You don't know if they're around your house, walking down your yard. But it sure seems like there's more gangs around. Because you see different signs everywhere," said Hernandez.

City clean up crews are working to paint over them, but even with two employees now painting full-time, 5 days a week, Dollinger says they just can't keep up.

"That's a major concern," he said. "Because many of the tags out there are identifying the certain gangs that are out there."

It's one reason why South Bend's Health and Public Safety Committee met Wednesday to search for new solutions.

The problem, some said, is not with the lack of harsh punishment. State laws already impose strict penalties on anyone caught defacing public or private property. Even stricter felony charges await those convicted of causing more than $250 in damage to a religious building or school.

"The tools are there. It's a question of, how are they being implemented?" Common Council Attorney Kathy Cekanski-Ferrand told the committee.

The problem, agreed the panel, is catching those responsible and proving they committed the vandalism.

South Bend Police did arrest a juvenile last month, suspected of tagging dozens of local sites. And since then, instances of graffiti have dropped slightly.

But his prosecution marks the first graffiti charges filed by the city in nearly 3 years. Meanwhile, the tags being left behind by those who haven't been caught have grown more troubling for police.

"We've really seen a big spike in the graffiti. Gangs are here. There is no question, gangs are here," said Common Council Member Derek Dieter, who is also a South Bend Police Officer. "It's just the resources that we have to go out and confront the gangs and the problems they cause. It's a huge concern."

But the bigger concern stems from new gang signs, left by gangs police and city leaders didn't think were in the South Bend area. In many case, their tags are left right next to signs from already established gangs, and some worry that could signal a turf war is already underway.

"We're seeing some gangs that--in the past--had gone away," said Dollinger. "Now they seem to be reappearing. And that's of concern. They want to identify themselves and say, 'this is where I ply my trade. This is what we do. Come join us.' It also says, 'this is my territory, stay away."

Weed and seed volunteers are trying to prevent that from happening.

But there's a problem.

"Our dollars are going to be gone at the end of August for our graffiti program," said Dollinger.

He estimates the city has already spent $5,000 on graffiti cleanup this year, and $20,000 over the last 3 years.

That spending has also dried up funding for other Weed and Seed initiatives, like after school programs. Those programs help keep youths off the streets and away from "at risk" behaviors like tagging.

If a new funding source isn't found, city leaders are worried the problem will only get worse.

"One kid sees it, another kid does it, and it just keeps going on and on and on," said Dieter. "I don't know what'll happen if we get to that point."

But Hernandez says she does.

"[My kids might be caught in the crossfire,] It worries me. It's just dangerous as the days go by. You don't know what to expect anymore."

City leaders identified several potential solutions during Wednesday's meeting.

Among those discussed:

-Partnering with South Bend Schools to form new educational tools on the dangers of graffiti
-Limiting the sale of spray paint to minors
-Adding temporary surveillance cameras in high graffiti areas to catch vandals in the act
-Establishing a "hotline" where graffiti can be reported anonymously

But Dieter says the single most important step is increased enforcement, and prosecution of those responsible for the graffiti already tainting walls across the west side.

"To have plain clothes officers out there every day, morning or night; the kids never know when a policeman's going to come around the corner. Definitely that is a big deterrent."

The question now, is whether the city will have funds to pay for it all. Dollinger has also requested additional funding in next year's budget to keep Weed and Seed programs running.

Common Council members will begin shaping the city's 2009 budget on July 21st.

The Health and Public Safety Committee will also discuss two other "quality of life" ordinances in August and September regarding noise and lawn parking during Notre Dame home football games.

Thursday, Jul 24 at 4:27 PM Tommy wrote ...

Dieter is South Bend's Obama. He has the answer for everything but we have yet to see him do anything other than get the Adams football program in trouble and his wife the RO job there. Why doesn't Dieter adopt a thug and show him how good the po-po lives by taking thugs to his mansion on the lake. Maybe a reality TV show called "Dieter Knows Best" where the thug that turns his/her life around can become part of the Dieter home. An occasional visit to Mayor Steve's home would make for great TV!

Saturday, Jul 19 at 11:05 AM Take it Back wrote ...

It's time to take back our west side neighborhood since the mayor and police are to intimidated to take action. Start vigiling and remember the old saying an eye for an eye... Maybe then we hard working people live in decency.

Friday, Jul 18 at 9:05 PM MJ wrote ...

my mom has had her property sprayed 2 times and she is the one who gets the citation. Since Dieter thinks he is wonder boy with all the answers why doesn't he do something constructive and put an end to all the gangs and grafftti. He's as useless as the graffitti thugs. South bend sucks and shows o signs of improving. Hire some real police officers and a real mayor and clean this town up once and for all.

Friday, Jul 18 at 6:34 AM Anonymous wrote ...

OMG....you actually think people should lose body parts because of graffiti? I think we should all take a close look at how we speak and think about other people. Shame on you.

Friday, Jul 18 at 3:49 AM Crime Sucks wrote ...

Graffiti?? It's a shame that is not the only problem here in South Bend I have a car from a dealership that had temp tags screwed to the car and tonight someone ripped them off literally tore them right off my car. The cops told me they could not do anything about it. That's pretty bad when people have to do such crummy things to hard working citizens.

Thursday, Jul 17 at 6:54 PM Steve-O wrote ...

Hey Weston, are you stupid or are you just a punk?. Either way, shut your whiny mouth!!!

Thursday, Jul 17 at 6:52 PM Hey frog wrote ...

shut your mouth and stay in plymouth where it is safe?????

Thursday, Jul 17 at 4:41 PM weston wrote ...

Its time the whites n blacks unite an put an end to the illegals trying to take over our country

Thursday, Jul 17 at 12:52 PM Barb wrote ...

I am with Steve-O, if they knew that they could lose a hand/finger it may deter them and make them think twice before they spray. And if they would get a harsher punishment than a slap on the hand and turned back over to the parents who don't care...things could change if we demand it. Our leaders are lame and won't step up to the plate and hold these kids responsible so it is a big joke to them and they won't learn until it is harsh punishment!

Thursday, Jul 17 at 12:42 PM Paula wrote ...

My neighbor was at work. The neighbor caught 3-kids all 14 years old breaking in the back porch. The neighbor locked them in the porch , called the police. They took a report, didn't take these kids to JJC, they let them go. Now my neighbor has to go to court and testify against these gangsters. I hope they don't come after him! There is something going to half to happen. By the way all 3 kids were white. So the person that thinks the illigals are part of this problem are wrong.

Thursday, Jul 17 at 11:39 AM Steve wrote ...

Oh dear what can we do, these naughty gangs. Lets just lock ourselves indoors and hide, the police can hide too. Or elected leaders could start cracking down on them. STEVE-O at 10-50am, chopping hands off is a bit harsh, they would have to go on disability. Chop a finger off for every offence up to six, if caught again lock them up for ten years.

Thursday, Jul 17 at 10:49 AM Anon wrote ...

If we shipped out the illegals, over half of the problem would disappear.

Thursday, Jul 17 at 9:50 AM Steve-O wrote ...

I think we need to start cutting thier hands off after each offense either for stealing or graffiti. If they dont learn after to offenses, time for the rope.

Thursday, Jul 17 at 8:49 AM rose wrote ...

I live in the River Park area and we have just as much graffitti as the west side. On McKinley across from Pizza Hut there is graffitti thats Mishawaka. Kids know they get away with things. The curfew law in this county is an example of a big joke. Come into River Park early tomorrow morning and see how many kids are out on the street. Where are the parents

Thursday, Jul 17 at 8:30 AM To Dave wrote ...

Grow a set, man. You see something suspicious, just go up to them nicely, say you saw them drive past several times, ask if they're lost. Just the fact that people are paying attention is enough, and you don't need to act like you're on some crusade. You can be friendly, gracious and effective all at once.

Thursday, Jul 17 at 7:50 AM Anonymous wrote ...

hmmm, I wonder if victims started bleeding on walls after being shot that the city would start to care?

Thursday, Jul 17 at 7:48 AM Ann -SB wrote ...

What happen to the program you had with the JJC and letting kids paint walls. I think that was a good idea. Make them give back to the community. My child did the Police Academy this year. They had them painting walls for a day. Didn't hurt her any. Or hit some of these school. Kids do have Community services hours they have to fulfill also.

Thursday, Jul 17 at 7:38 AM Frog wrote ...

"Graffiti Cases May Signal Bigger Issue for Neighborhoods". Gee, ya think?

Thursday, Jul 17 at 7:24 AM Anonymous wrote ...

Luecke has completely lost control of the city. Why did you morons elect him? I hope you're happy with yourselves.

Thursday, Jul 17 at 7:07 AM Indiana wrote ...

It's probably just punk kids trying to be gang wannabes. Where are the parents?

Thursday, Jul 17 at 6:30 AM Larry wrote ...

I think the chinese had the right response. Canning is a appropiate response

Thursday, Jul 17 at 6:24 AM Anonymous wrote ...

Call the police and report suspicious activity. They'll get the picture that they are not wanted there.

Thursday, Jul 17 at 5:59 AM COREY wrote ...

MY MOTHER-IN LAWS HOME AND GARAGE HAVE BEEN GRAFFITTIED SEVERAL TIMES. SHE REPORTED THE PARTY TO THE POLICE WHO WAS DOING IT AND NOTHING WAS DONE. SHE EVEN WENT DOWNTOWN AND ADDRESSED THE ISSUE AS THE MAYORS OFFICE SAID IT WAS HER PROBLEM TO DEAL WITH IT.tHE LAst she heard she was sent a letter to remove the graffittie or be cited.Our mayor is and city is a joke.Also if there would not be 6 to 7 police cars down at the food cafe on Olive ;maybe they could do their job and patrol

Thursday, Jul 17 at 5:40 AM just wait wrote ...

This gang thing is going to get worse. In 10 years we will all be staying indoors hiding from these thugs with guns in our hands.

Thursday, Jul 17 at 2:30 AM Anonymous wrote ...

There is no solution. The only thing you can do is make sure you can afford to live away from the bad people. The law is not set up to deal with them, not enough to make poor neighborhoods humane places to live. And, since folks who live in those areas aren't the most educated or the deepest oceans, nothing will change. Poor people have low standards and little resourcefulness, and those who don't live in those places could care less.

Thursday, Jul 17 at 12:41 AM Anon wrote ...

Sorry, I don't think the city should be repainting stuff, the property owners should.

Wednesday, Jul 16 at 10:13 PM Dave wrote ...

I don't really know what to think of this...it's in my hood too. I know its a problem;the gangsters I'm worried about aren't armed with spray paint. I saw 3 youths ride up and down my block for 3 hours last weekend before dusk. I'm pretty sure (80%) they did some of this. What can I do? No evidence. No paint at the scene. I can't use force. The cops can't be and aren't everywhere.

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

Comments are moderated and will not appear on this story until after they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

WSBT and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

WSBT Weather

icon
Current Temp 27
°
More Weather
More On Demand

Stock Quotes

YouNews

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.
This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

Tonight On WSBTFull Schedule

7.00
Wheel of Fortune
7.30
Jeopardy!
8.00
NCIS
9.00
The Mentalist
10.00
Without A Trace
11.00
WSBT News
11.35
Late Show with David Letterman

Question of The Day

When was the last time you bought a car?

E-mail your comments. We'll pick some to read during WSBT News at 5.