Knock-offs seized at Blueberry Festival; ID theft may have been prevented

By ANITA MUNSON, Tribune Staff Writer

Tools

Counterfeit merchandise and knock-offs seized at Blueberry Festival

Indiana State Police confiscated hundreds of designer purse knock-offs, high-end designer jeans fakes, and other counterfeit merchandise at the Marshall County Blueberry Festival in Plymouth on Friday, August 29, 2008. (Photo provided)

By Beth Boehne

PLYMOUTH — The Marshall County Blueberry Festival Committee is being credited by police for possibly preventing the theft of personal information of as many as half a million people Friday night.

Indiana State Police Sgt. Lourdes Lemler said the committee’s action taken before the festival opened Friday night resulted in the arrest of seven vendors.

Police confiscated hundreds of designer purse knock-offs, high-end designer jeans fakes, and accessories such as sunglasses, after an unidentified festival vendor tipped off festival officials of what he thought might be illegal sales activity in Centennial Park.

Lemler told The Tribune at the Bremen Post Tuesday morning that Blueberry officials called her around 2:30 p.m. Friday while she was walking the grounds in plain clothes. She was told of the complaint, and proceeded to check out the various booths. Lemler then located four additional booths where fraudulent sales were suspected.

Additional police stepped in, confiscating merchandise and placing the items in a truck and trailer brought onto the scene after police determined the growing quantity of suspected fake goods.

During the course of that action, Lemler said, police found one vendor with a credit card scanner hooked to a cell phone. The fear, Lemler explained, was that the information taken from credit cards could have been forwarded through the cell phone "anywhere," resulting in identity theft of anyone making a purchase from that vendor.

"That was a big deal for the (Blueberry Festival) board," Lemler said. "They said, ‘We don’t want this.’ It was a pro-active stance they took."

Police are now working with federal authorities to track the vendor’s phone records, she said. The ISP Cyber Crimes Unit also is working to gain information from the vendor’s computer. It is a crime to utilize a card scanner for any purpose other than to communicate with a financial institution for the purpose of a legal sale, Lemler added.

"My investigation has just started," Lemler said. "The Blueberry board helped with that because we maintained the chain of custody (with confiscated evidence). And the Sheriff’s Posse did a great job helping, too."

As police fanned out to booths on both the east and west side of the covered bridge in the park, word began to trickle out of the action underway.

"One gentleman left without his goods," Lemler said of the vendor’s speedy departure.

Festival organizers and police believe they know the vendor’s name and address, she said.

Lemler said police used the festival committee’s vendor forms, which require the vendor name, address and a brief summary of what the vendor is selling.

"I have their driver’s licenses, wallets and money," Lemler said, pointing to the hundreds of pieces of merchandise that could have meant big profit for those arrested.

Worse though, Lemler said, is what the purchase of those items really means.

"The public needs to understand that when you buy these kind of (knock-off) purses, you’re contributing to organized crime," the detective explained. "It’s a bad choice you’re making."

"The Blueberry board really did good by catching this when they did," she added.

"It was a problem for a couple of hours for several people," Mark Senter, Blueberry Festival spokesman, said Tuesday morning. "It put out vendors who were doing everything right, with people walking around in their areas. We appreciate their patience."

It was the first such incidence, Senter said, of this type of activity at the festival, and one organizers wanted to stop in its tracks.

Senter said, "The Marshall County Blueberry Festival is known for its quality merchandise and its good reputation. We want it to stay that way."

Staff writer Anita Munson:
amunson@sbtinfo.com
(574) 936-2920

Thursday, Sep 4 at 10:51 PM Anonymous wrote ...

who invited these vendors hmmm ? China no Plymouth Festival folks did. Blame no one else. It has turned into a carnie junk fest.

Thursday, Sep 4 at 9:36 PM Seriously wrote ...

When you are buying a Coach purse at the blueberry festival for $45, do you really think its real?? You can't get a Coach purse for under $300. I like the knock offs, they are cute and most people cannot even tell the difference. Why pay $300 when you can get something that looks like the real thing for $45.

Thursday, Sep 4 at 4:24 PM asia wrote ...

What is wrong with buying knock offs?? People do this everyday, at the grocery stores, malls etc. we buy what we can afford.. as for the telepone credit card scam, they scan the card into the phone and it goes directly to the bank,

Thursday, Sep 4 at 3:24 PM Mike wrote ...

It's NOT O.K. to steal songs, trademarked handbag designs ANYTHING, it's in the 10 commandments, do you believe those? or just the ones you people choose to. And I can tell by the way you look that you have a fake $2000 bag anyway so instead of looking cool you look stupid.

Thursday, Sep 4 at 2:29 PM will cont to buy fakes! wrote ...

Ok, this is bull. I buy fakes. Why? because I am not going to spend 300-1000 on a bag. All you are buying is a name. We get these bags from China? So, it helps everyone everywhere. We buy everything from China anyways! Bottom line everyday hard working american people deserve something nice without killing themselfs on real things. I would buy a fake anything anyday just to save money.

Thursday, Sep 4 at 2:11 PM MY BAG wrote ...

HeHe i can just see the vendor that ran off and left their stuff. I wonder did they run or walk. Any woman that don't know a Knock-Off purse, don't know purses. If they were out there swiping credit cards, then they must pay taxes on the stuff, so what's wrong with them selling it if a person want to buy it. Some people can't afford to buy the real thing. I am sure a person had to know the stuff was fack. I wonder did they get the swift one yet.

Thursday, Sep 4 at 12:59 PM frosty wrote ...

Hey, Warsaw- If you can't spell POLICE, why don't you try using the word COPS? It's only 4 letters, you should be able to manage.

Thursday, Sep 4 at 12:23 PM Anonymous wrote ...

I went for the 1st time this year, never again, too many people, prices are crazy, and the food was less than average tasting.

Thursday, Sep 4 at 10:32 AM dissappointed from Bristol wrote ...

My husband & I attended for the first time in years and were surprised to see all the knock-off vendors (easy to spot). It was time consuming to find the quality vendors since they are spread out throughout the grounds. I applaud the festival for getting rid of the illegal vendors and hope they use better judgement in the choice of vendors in years to come. Otherwise there is no reason for us to return. A waste of our time this year!

Wednesday, Sep 3 at 10:45 PM Tina wrote ...

False advertising should be dealt with also. I purchased a smoothie that was advertised 12oz for $5 24oz for $8. I even questioned the salesman about the size of the 24oz. When I brought the hourglass shaped container home it only held 20oz. GREAT DEAL; for the vendor.

Wednesday, Sep 3 at 8:33 PM Anonymous wrote ...

I used to avoid buying these knock offs until I found out it made the real ones more valuable. In my opinion it is a win win for everyone. I wish the police would spend more time on violent crimes that crimes that don't hurt anyone

Wednesday, Sep 3 at 7:44 PM CJ wrote ...

I bought a pair of sunglasses. It never occurred to me that they WEREN'T knockoffs. Designer specs for ten bucks? C'mon, people.

Wednesday, Sep 3 at 5:16 PM Joey wrote ...

Nicole...You are without a doubt a rocket scientist Thank you for the intelligent comments!

Wednesday, Sep 3 at 4:33 PM Anonymous wrote ...

"It was the first such incidence, Senter said, of this type of activity at the festival". Uh, I beg to differ, they sold them last year in the main aisle by the bridge. The only difference is this year Mayor Senter(former ISP) wanted some publicity so he called his lil' ISP buddies to crack down on this "illegal" activity. Maybe he could get serious about the 100's of illegal Mexicans that live in work in Plymouth? I guess they're OK as long as they don't sell knock off Coach?

Wednesday, Sep 3 at 2:20 PM How stupid can we be??? wrote ...

If we go to a festival and they are selling a coach purse, its obviously a knock-off. Im pretty sure that Coach and Kate Spade, dont have contracts with these people! I happen to go to the Blueberry festival every year...I love it and will go back next year! Btw...talk about fraud...My son bought a $7 "Smoothie" and they can him a Slushy!!! A Slushy! Ice and flavored syrup for $7???? WTF???

Wednesday, Sep 3 at 1:53 PM Loosh wrote ...

What are Gothlic kids????

Wednesday, Sep 3 at 11:49 AM Plymouth wrote ...

I was glad to see more security around. The police did a great job over in the Carnival Section by standing around the Gothlic kids. Thanks

Wednesday, Sep 3 at 10:17 AM Mz V wrote ...

Hey people we don't know that these vendors were going to misuse people's identity. I have purchased knock offs and my credit card has been used this is the new way that most vendors use credit cards now through their cell phones. They do it in malls I have never had a problem. So please stop commenting on the officers stoped a indentity theft selling knock offs doesn't mean that they vendors were going to use the credit card info for anything else other than payment. Get a life

Wednesday, Sep 3 at 10:13 AM Mz V wrote ...

What is the problem you spend time and money closing down one just for 10 more to open. I shop them and love them. I will continue to shop them. Those same officers that closed them down for illegal selling knockoffs, can I arrest you all the next time you are in a bar drunk as a skunk. I am not a police officer but can I make a citizens arrest when you walk out of the bar and drive home after drinking for about three hours. Oh no I guess I can't but guess what that's a knock off police (drunk)

Wednesday, Sep 3 at 9:12 AM Anonymous wrote ...

Cripes who cares. Name brand vs not name brand. Don't make the crap so high priced. You wanna arrest someone bust the idiots selling the shirts for seventy dollars, talk about robbery. I am so sick of the clicks, teaching kids that they can only wear crap that they can't afford. Then they grow up and realize that none of the name brands mean anything.

Wednesday, Sep 3 at 8:57 AM ts wrote ...

have a noon hanging, ruin their lives, come on you weak people think about this for a second before you make your idiotic statements. real things cost more, fake things do not. end of story!!!!

Wednesday, Sep 3 at 8:17 AM spell check wrote ...

To R U Serious: Learn to spell before you post anything else. How can anyone take your comments seriously when it looks like it was written by a third grader?

Wednesday, Sep 3 at 7:01 AM SB dave wrote ...

would like to know witch vendor had the scanner. friends and family both shopped there.

Wednesday, Sep 3 at 2:05 AM to I'd at 11:41 wrote ...

This was State Police, they were called by the festival officials, if you live in Plymouth you would know that the PPD made many arrests, mostly for DUI, PI and fights, and you would also know that (thankfully) we haven't had a murder in a long time. There were several drug arrests also...so take your cop bashing to another site.

Wednesday, Sep 3 at 1:28 AM warsaw wrote ...

Ok people, are you serious, it does not matter what the crime is wether it is murder or stealing or selling knock off goods it is still a crime and it needs to be taken care of.Plolice are not here just to solve murders they have a very large list of things that go with their job,so get a life and dont worry what the polcie are investigating ! Or is it you are worried because you are involved in someway

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 11:41 PM I'd but them all day long... wrote ...

Ok, So where did our priorities go? I think the cops should spend more time looking for ALL the Murders, and drug dealers and child molesters that are EVERYWHERE!!! instead of looking for all the easy work. OH- That'd mean they'd actually have to do some real work with real criminals... OOps!!!

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 11:37 PM R U serious??? wrote ...

OMG! You people are so nieve! Yeah, It's definatley a bad thing to steal someones identity! But Isn't it us greedy americans that raise our children to be soo materialistic and cruel to others who cant afford the real 300-2,000 purses? Isn't it the same conceptit to sell replica perfumes, or generic products? And if China is using seat shops to make this stuff, what about nike who uses them to make their shoes and sell them for full price... Isn't that just as bad?

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 11:18 PM Anonymous wrote ...

To "READ before you REACT" Ahh, I understand. The festival was expecting a half a million people.

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 11:10 PM ron wrote ...

I only go for the car show/swap meet.You can see most of the name brand stuff is knock offs just by the prices

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 8:31 PM steve wrote ...

how many cops and blueberry officals bought this stuff for there wives,girlfrends or familys.the good stuff is made in china

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 8:17 PM SDP wrote ...

Glad to hear they caught some of those vendors. I was just at the Shipshewana flea market today. Far too many Asians there with junk stuff. I also did see a couple of Disney copyright violations there also. Maybe the State Police needs to check that place out also. Bet they would find a few illegal vendors.

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 7:48 PM Not A Brain Surgeon wrote ...

Check out the gas station on North Michigan too, do you really think those are Nikes their selling for $5. You know the one where you can hardly breathe when you walk in from all the incense!

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 7:38 PM SB Resident wrote ...

I applaude the elimination of these frauds from the festival, but don't let the festival staff fool you. By looking at the names of the individuals involved with the fraud, many of these have been selling at the festival for years and this problem has been overlooked in the past by the committee. It is always easier to sell booth space than to have actual "crafters" and honest businesses participate. I can only hope that the public pressure will eliminate even more frauds in the future.

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 7:10 PM MI Resident wrote ...

I wish Michigan would be so vigilant. Just over the state line in my small town we have a storefront that openly sells fakes. MI state police won't investigate or do anything about it. Their response to the complaint was "We don't know about purses and stuff"! No wonder we're losing jobs faster than any other state. Indiana rocks for shutting stuff like this down.

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 6:17 PM Sean Ivory wrote ...

Confiscate all merchandize all them are fake and brought out from china and it is illegal to sell them goods. My personal information was stolen and then this thugs used my Discover card and Visa on their shopping spree. My credit was ruined because the spend too much and did not pay any money at all. How could this idiots get into someone elses account and empty them out leaving the rightful owner in the limb? Do they have any conscience to do this to others¿ Lock them all up and throw away key

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 6:05 PM Local Crafter wrote ...

Blueberry should offer discounts so local craftsman can afford to set up at the festival. There high fees attrack scam artist like the ones they caught

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 5:29 PM Curious wrote ...

Good job to the police and festival for catching this and pulling the items. Looking at the picture, the boxes show measurements in the metric system. I wonder how many of these items are from China? You really hurt our own economy and honest merchants by buying knock offs.

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 5:11 PM Anonymous wrote ...

Seven individuals were arrested and preliminarily charged with forgery. Bassirou Mbacke, 40, Massene Diaw, 48, Roges Louissaint Jr., 32, and Jope Esmala, 50, are all from the Chicago area. Zhi Long Gao, 39, of Joliet, Illinois, Jian Feng Zhang, 35, of Darien, Illinois and Myla Sattar, 30, of South Bend were all taken to the Marshall County Jail. for more go to wwww.am1050.com

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 4:54 PM Plymouth resident wrote ...

And you wonder why Plymouth residents don't want to attend???

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 4:51 PM READ before you REACT! wrote ...

to 3:20 anonomous...the half million people who were at the festival were all POTENTIAL customers of these vendors. Reread the article, it says "possibly prevented..."up to half a million people...".The story reports what could have happened,not what did happen. It's like finding the snake before it bites & kills someone.

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 4:34 PM Lakeville wrote ...

The festival has been going down for years. It use to be nothing but USA hand crafter items. Now it is nothing but China imports. My daughter makes her own soap her at home and would like to take it there but we only go to sanctioned shows with no "junk". Please put the festival back to sanctioned items and remove the commercial imported junk. You are losing your quality crowd!

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 4:16 PM Wonder wrote ...

How many other festivals these crooks have worked that innocent people didn't know about. Too bad people have to be crooks (which seems to becoming the norm) instead of getting real jobs. Glad they were shut down.

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 3:33 PM Old School wrote ...

I ate some blueberries that I am sure were knock-offs. I hate those fakes, they are too chewy!!!

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 3:31 PM plymoth resident wrote ...

They have sold knock offs at this festival for years. Example sunglasses!!! Now they are finally doing something. Ha!!!

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 3:20 PM Anonymous wrote ...

If only seven vendors were arrested, where did they come up with the "half a million people" estimate (paragraph one)?

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 3:18 PM Anonymous wrote ...

Festival? More like Junkival. Been once and will never go back.

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 3:00 PM GB in the Bend wrote ...

Good for them for taking a stand. Now they should arrest some of the "food" vendors. Some of it tasted more like knock-offs than food. The prices should be illegal too!

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 2:48 PM Jason wrote ...

It's great to see that the Blueberry officals and police were able to put these people out of business before any damage was done. PBS recently did a great feature on the real impact of buying knock-offs. By buying these items you are helping fund a whole host of illegal activites, don't do it. If you buy this stuff you are helping terrorists and druglords and putting good people out of work.

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 2:47 PM N wrote ...

A big bravo to the person who noticed this and acted appropriately!

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 2:28 PM dg wrote ...

They have been doing this for years right? Good for them for putting a stop to it. Perhaps it would be okay if it were sold as fake, or didn't violate any laws and looked nice.

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 2:23 PM B.C. Kunze wrote ...

With it becoming such a large draw with people from all over the U.S. it was bound to happen sooner or later. Good job and hope you find the run away vendor.

Tuesday, Sep 2 at 2:21 PM nicole wrote ...

i lik ebuying those fakes but im glad they stepped in only pay cash that is what i do

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

Comments are moderated and will not appear on this story until after they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

WSBT and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

WSBT Weather

icon
Current Temp 26
°
More Weather
More On Demand

Stock Quotes

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

Tonight On WSBTFull Schedule

7.00
Wheel of Fortune
7.30
Jeopardy!
8.00
Big Bang Theory
8.30
How I Met Your Mother
9.00
Two and a Half Men
9.30
Worst Week
10.00
CSI: Miami
11.00
WSBT News
11.35
Late Show with David Letterman

Question of The Day

Do you think Notre Dame should keep Charlie Weis?

E-mail your comments. We'll pick some to read during WSBT News at 5.

  • Yes
  • No