Neighbors and strangers struggling with 4-year-old girl's death

by Sarah Rice (srice@wsbt.com)

Tools

4-year-old dead at Tall Timbers in Michigan City

Neighbors pack up stuffed animals and candles the morning after a vigil was held for a 4-year-old girl who was found dead in an apartment at the Tall Timbers complex in Michigan City. Two people have been arrested in connection with the girl's death. (WSBT photo)

By WSBT News1

MICHIGAN CITY -- A Michigan City couple faces criminal charges after police found their 4-year-old daughter dead. Scott and Melissa Bruce have been charged with neglect of a dependent.

Police were called to the Tall Timbers Townhouses Friday night on Springland Avenue for a child not breathing. Medics pronounced her dead at the scene.

There are still a lot of unanswered questions, including how the child died. And it's something neighbors and strangers are still struggling with.

On a day when most kids are playing outside, Sharon Kelley's kids are paying their respects.

"They picked teddy bears out of their bedroom and we brought them here," Kelley said.

Kelley lives a few miles away from Tall Timbers Townhouses — where police found a 4-year old girl dead Friday night.

"I couldn't believe that a mother could let a life go that's so precious. It's heartbreaking," said Kelley.

It's a feeling neighbors know all too well. Lynnette Mooi helped organize a candlelight vigil for the little girl.

"She played and danced and laughed and what any 4-year-old would do," said Mooi.

Mooi was standing near the girl's mother when she found out her child was dead — a reaction she'll never forget.

"She was just calm and cool, didn't really say too much of anything," she recalled. "It was very shocking to all of us that saw her. She just said that she hoped that she didn't go to jail for child abuse. And when I asked her why she told me that her daughter had thrown herself and got multiple bruises on her face."

Police arrested the girl's mother and stepfather. They've both been charged with neglect of a dependent.

"There's nothing any of us can do or say to bring her back," said Mooi.

Officials still aren't saying how the girl died. But Mooi says the tragedy serves as an important reminder to everyone.

"I hope and pray that if they suspect child abuse or any other kind of foul play in somebody else's home, that they report it. Because then in turn you save a life. And if you don't, then you're just as guilty as everybody else," she said.

An autopsy was performed Saturday, but the results have not been released. The Michigan City Detective's Bureau is investigating this case.

Tuesday, Sep 30 at 12:47 PM ME wrote ...

What a bunch of low lives in michigan city! I'm glad I moved away while I had the chance. I hate bringing my husband when I visit family left behind, it's embarressing!

Monday, Sep 29 at 7:35 AM ???? wrote ...

Where was the 4yr olds father

Wednesday, Sep 24 at 6:57 PM Anonymous wrote ...

This stuff happens in every town everyday, usually by someone the child is related to. As a formal abused child, I was threatened with death if I ever told. A teen who has grown up this kind of abuse is too scared to tell also. My brother died last Nov. from complications of earlier child abuse, he was 37, nobody in the family knew of what happened in our house, not even my father who lived with us.

Wednesday, Sep 24 at 3:39 PM anon wrote ...

From my understanding the little girl was upstairs and the other children were banned from going up. Anyone who is convicted of a crime towards children need to be sterilized if they're going to allow them to live. They need to be treated as sex offenders. Put them on a list available to the public so everyone knows not to let there children near them. They should not be allowed to have any contact whatsoever with any child!

Tuesday, Sep 23 at 10:08 PM Antionette wrote ...

This is so. I hate to see partents kill their own children. If you don't want your own child, give them to a loving couple that can't have kids. There are some people who do not need kids. This is our future when we lose our kids

Tuesday, Sep 23 at 4:09 PM Anonymous wrote ...

No one is turning this around on the other kids. Unless the kids were the ones doing the abusing, they were probably trying to stay safe and alive as well. Any adult who sees this occuring to any child (0-18) in their extended family has a responsibility to that child to do something to help them. You can't tell me that the "aunt of beloved angel" couldn't have done something to help that child. Don't wash your hands of the responsibilty simply because you made a phone call to CPS. Step UP!

Tuesday, Sep 23 at 3:00 PM OMG wrote ...

Where were this poor little girl's extended family members? What about a neighbor? No one noticed anything wrong? HOW? Capital punishment is in order for these two and anyone else involved!!

Tuesday, Sep 23 at 1:12 PM granger mommy ems wrote ...

the sad thing is you dont pronounce them unless their are obivious signs of death like lividy blood pooling in lower parts of body due to gravity or rigor mortis where their limbs atr stiff. this does not occur right away like if they had stopped breathing and while medics are responding leaves me to believe she had been dead for awhile. where was she found were people just walking around her like no big deal those poor other kids maybe this was used as an example to them and they were scared

Tuesday, Sep 23 at 1:03 PM granger mommy ems wrote ...

I heard she was half starved and those pigs ate in front of her I am sure. she was cheated out of so much in life, happiness, love things lil kids should get to do. wonder if she even had a birthday party. I have a three and two year old and cant imagine this happening. its like a bad movie that leaves you depressed and sad when it is done. at least a movie you can say oh well it was not real. this is real and horrific my heart hurts real bad she was a lil princess, I never even knew her

Tuesday, Sep 23 at 7:34 AM DEBBIE wrote ...

THIS IS SO SAD.IF PEOPLE CALL THE CPS AND NOTHING IS DONE CALL THE INDIANA STATE WITH THE DATE AND THE WORKERS NAME YOU REPORTED THE PERSON TO. MY SON IS A SOCIAL WORKER IN ANOTHER STATE AND I HAVE BEEN EMAILING THE STORIES OF ALL THE CHILDREN THAT HAVE BEEN KILLED BY THESE MONSTERS. SO CPS WORKERS YOU BETTER FOLLOW UP ON ALL CASES THAT IS REPORTED THATS THE LAW.IF YOU REPORT SOMEONE AND NOTHING IS DONE. CALL ANOTHER STATE AND THEY WILL PUT YOU IN CONTACT WITH OFFICE OVER INDIANA WORKERS.

Monday, Sep 22 at 11:44 PM Anonymous wrote ...

I believe the other kids were threatened and one of them did finally tell, that is why the police sent to the apartment. Lets not turn this around on the other kids in the house, they didn't do this their father did. They are tore up over all of this. Those poor kids need love and understanding right now not someone attacking them over this. They are kids too. Please pray for all the kids and extended family that have lost a precious baby girl here. The mother and stepfather will burn in hell!!!

Monday, Sep 22 at 7:34 PM Gina wrote ...

11:38 AM Anonymous...the Aunt that you replied about is the Father's side of the family. They may have not been aware of the situation. Don't be so fast to judge someone. They are grieving too. The Mother had married someone she met on the internet. Read up on the article more! I am sorry for the families loss, God bless the family,and friends of this little girl.

Monday, Sep 22 at 3:48 PM Anonymous wrote ...

What am not hearing is there were 4 teenagers in that house and not one of them reported it to anybody ,school,couseler,police maybe if they did she would still be alive maybe or did there dad threaten them to. We will never know.

Monday, Sep 22 at 1:20 PM R. wrote ...

Sounds like the whole family is a little screwey. IF my neice died because of my sister or brother I would not be chatting about it on WSBT.com, I would have already tried to get custody of the child. Get real!

Monday, Sep 22 at 12:34 PM Anonymous wrote ...

Why are they not releasing the cause of death? I agree that CPS have too many cases, people who are vindictive towards their exes and report them for no reason other than bitterness, they need to be fined for false accusations, then maybe CPS would have the time to investigate the real cases, and the children who really need help.

Monday, Sep 22 at 12:00 PM sick to the heart wrote ...

Dont worry thye get away with murder or serve very little time La Porte County so bad in these cases if you really look at all the murders and what the crimes are it sickens you to know end. La Porte county being so small too. Lack of good detectives how sad another child unlove uncare for.....

Monday, Sep 22 at 11:57 AM Carla wrote ...

To 9:33AM R.--I couldn't have said it better myself. Kathy Phillips is no better than these animals--she just got away with it. These people (Kathy included) need to be tortured slowly just like their children were.

Monday, Sep 22 at 11:28 AM Stephanie wrote ...

This poor baby girl lost her life because her parents liked to beat on her? Dear god, what has this world turned into?! Im a young mother, and a proud one at that, I cant even yell at my children without feeling awful. Parents like these two, dont deserve to be called parents in the first place,and give parents like me who are giving it there all a bad name. They killed there own baby, their own flesh n blood and she was only 4. sick people dont deserve to walk this earth,eye for an eye.

Monday, Sep 22 at 10:38 AM Anonymous wrote ...

to aunt of beloved angel, you knew this child was being abused and did nothing about it!? What is wrong with you??? You too should be held accountable then. What the hell is wrong with society that these little kids are being left with "parents" who neglect them or worse. COme on families, step up to the plate and provide the protection these little ones need and either don't know to or can't ask for. Don't rely solely on CPS or the police. Act yourselves and help a defenseless child!!

Monday, Sep 22 at 10:29 AM Mel wrote ...

This is just so sad. I have a granddaughter that is 4 years old. She has her moments, but I could NEVER hurt her. We are teaching her and her brother that we don't hit each other even when we are mad. Maybe we should be teaching that in High School as well, then maybe things like this would never happen.

Monday, Sep 22 at 9:07 AM bee wrote ...

the people in jail arent gonna be able to do anything because theyll put them in protective custody or with other inmates who've killed theyre children since it happens almost everyday now.child killers and abusers should all be strung up andbeaten to death.how could anyone hurt an innocent child?it makes me sick!cps does their job but they have so many cases,alot of which are false made by vindictive exes and the like,that the true cases dont get caught till its too late.

Monday, Sep 22 at 9:03 AM Laporte wrote ...

how did she die anyone know

Monday, Sep 22 at 8:33 AM R. wrote ...

So since we can prove the child took a breath before she died it is murder right?

Monday, Sep 22 at 8:19 AM Linda wrote ...

God speed to you little one. You are in the arms of Jesus and you will never suffer again. To the parents, may God have mercy on your souls because no one here on earth will including your prison pals! They HATE child killers.

Monday, Sep 22 at 7:35 AM Annonymous wrote ...

My heart goes out to all the ones who are suffering during this time. Calling CPS does not help, as I have tried with my granddaughter. They drag their heels on things.

Sunday, Sep 21 at 9:30 PM aunt of beloved angel wrote ...

i would like to send out many hugs to all showing care and concern..and our family greatly appreciates the love shown to my poor niece,prayers are greatly appreciated for all the suffering this poor lil bueatiful angel has indured i believe melissa and scott will indure ten times as much for it is now in gods grace,he shall be their final judge. love to my beloved niece(fathers side of family)may the angels embrace you baby.

Sunday, Sep 21 at 8:20 PM To 6:21PM wrote ...

As the writer below your comment said, people report things they notice but there is a ridiculous amount of proof required that something wrong is going on before they'll knock on a door. It's a sign of the times. Protection agencies have been trained by the prosecutors office on how to reduce the chances of having a case thrown out of court. Unfortunately, as you can see, this does not do the victims much good. I think doctors are required to report suspected case, while we have to prove them.

Sunday, Sep 21 at 7:18 PM DB wrote ...

My thoughts and prayers go out to the children and to the little one your with the angels now

Sunday, Sep 21 at 5:39 PM Anonymous wrote ...

u know anymore if u get a hold of cps they dont do anything....and this is the result of it...so sad....thoughts and prayers are with the family....

Sunday, Sep 21 at 5:21 PM Anonymous wrote ...

She hopes she doesn't go to jail for child abuse. How about jail for murder or at least manslaughter. The justice system needs to start making an example of these so called parents, that you can't treat your child like this. If you can't deal with your child, let a family member take them and provide the love, support and security that they need. This is happening far too often in this area. What is wrong with our communities that this kind of abuse is happening and no one sees it??

Sunday, Sep 21 at 3:40 PM Sad but true wrote ...

There's an unofficial notion floating around but if it turns out to be factual these two will have to undergo psychiatric evaluations to see if they are competent to assist in their own defense. I a have reported several cases of suspected child abuse to my suporvisor, I am a bus operator, and I have been advised NOT to discuss what I see with anyone. Not one time had anything become of the reports so I called Child Services myself and was told a great deal of eveidence is needed to check it out

Sunday, Sep 21 at 12:12 PM disgusted wrote ...

dont worry folks, the bunk mates in prison dont like people who treat little kids like this.

Sunday, Sep 21 at 9:25 AM from mentone wrote ...

My prayer goes out to the family of this 4 year old. The mother and father need to rot in jail for what they did to this poor child.

Sunday, Sep 21 at 1:01 AM Heather Everett wrote ...

rest in peace now no one can hurt you anymore.i hope them two a happy now!

Sunday, Sep 21 at 12:36 AM David wrote ...

this is a shame!!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

Comments are moderated and will not appear on this story until after they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

WSBT and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

WSBT Weather

icon
Current Temp 27
°
More Weather
More On Demand

Stock Quotes

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

Tonight On WSBTFull Schedule

7.00
Wheel of Fortune
7.30
Jeopardy!
8.00
Big Bang Theory
8.30
How I Met Your Mother
9.00
Two and a Half Men
9.30
Worst Week
10.00
CSI: Miami
11.00
WSBT News
11.35
Late Show with David Letterman

Question of The Day

Do you think Notre Dame should keep Charlie Weis?

E-mail your comments. We'll pick some to read during WSBT News at 5.

  • Yes
  • No