Police investigate 'overlaying' in Elkhart baby's death

by Sarah Rice (srice@wsbt.com)

Tools

Overlaying

(WSBT file photo)

By WSBT News1

ELKHART -- Police are trying to figure out how an Elkhart baby died. They say they're looking into the possibility that overlaying could have caused the infant's death.

Overlaying happens when someone is sleeping with a baby, rolls on top of him or her, and accidentally suffocates the child.

It's happened a handful of times in Elkhart County already this year and officials say it can be avoided.

"It's something that doesn't have to happen," said Elkhart Police Department Lt. Ed Windbigler.

Police in Elkhart are looking into the possibility that a 2-month-old baby accidentally suffocated.

"There's a possibility because the child was in bed with his mother and biological father," said Windbigler.

Another child was also in the bed.

"They went to bed around 11:30 at night and the next morning when they got up at 7, or whenever it was, the child was not breathing," said Windbigler.

So far this year, three babies in Elkhart County have died from overlaying. And pediatrician Kehinde Animashaun says it's simple to avoid.

"Do not sleep with your baby," said Animashaun.

Animashaun says babies, especially those younger than 4 months old, do not have the ability get out of potentially harmful situations.

"But the baby doesn't have the reflexes and they don't have strength, or they are so fast asleep themselves. They don't know what is going on to push the mom or dad off or wake them up so they can breathe on their own," said Animashaun.

Parents often think sleeping with their baby is a good way of comforting them. But doctors say parents can do that in other ways, including putting the child in a bassinet near their bed.

Wednesday, Nov 19 at 8:11 PM mellisa wrote ...

why are we critizing this family or judging why dont we who all have kids stop and think what we would fill like they have enough guilt and suffering im sure

Wednesday, Nov 19 at 10:21 AM Taylor wrote ...

Rest in Peace my dear little Zackery. We all are thinking of you and atleast we as your family know it was an accident.

Wednesday, Nov 19 at 8:25 AM Stick wrote ...

Please sleep near your baby, not with your baby. So much of this is just being lazy and not wanting to walk to the childs room. Bring the into your room and listen carefully. I thought co-sleeping went out with single bed log cabins.

Saturday, Nov 15 at 4:31 PM Careful co-sleeper wrote ...

These reporters need to talk with Dr. James McKenna at the Mother-Baby Behavioral Sleep Laboratory at Notre Dame. I think he would shed some much-needed light on the question of co-sleeping. There are a number of other factors that could have been involved here. And think about it: The overwhelming number of SIDS deaths occur when babies are alone in cribs. Do we then conclude that a baby should never sleep alone in a crib? Things are rarely as simple as they seem in a 2-minute video clip.

Saturday, Nov 15 at 11:46 AM It's scary to read these posts wrote ...

To know that there are collectivly so many morons out there is scary. Just wait..they will pass a law that makes it illeagal to sleep with your child next. And then some other "ACCIDENT" will happen and all you do gooders will have another law made up..wake up idiots

Saturday, Nov 15 at 9:57 AM OMG get a life wrote ...

all you people need to get a life and lay off this family

Saturday, Nov 15 at 9:23 AM Trevor wrote ...

I didnt hear you praying for anybody and you are asking everyone to pray for you. Confusious, wake up, are you sleeping thinking about the baby? If this poor little baby is dead then it is with Jesus.. pray for the family who must be missing so much their little angel. I cant hear you praying.. say loud so everyone will really know that you are prayingfor them. Open up your windows and see the confort God will give to those who are brken and left to themselves.

Saturday, Nov 15 at 8:06 AM CH wrote ...

If this is what truly happened then it was their choice and they knew what could happen. I knew that and took the risk. I also had a bed side bassenette but w/ my c sections I could now reach w/o great pain. This worked for me. My kids will come to me if the are sacred now but the have their own room and own beds. It is a parents CHOICE!! Just pray for the family and the little baby. That's what is needed now.

Friday, Nov 14 at 8:40 PM Mentone Resident wrote ...

Peopel back off!!!! This was an accident!!! My prayer goes out to this family and so does my prayers!!!!!

Friday, Nov 14 at 6:54 PM Dicky's friend wrote ...

You think a 10 year old crawling into bed with mom is sick!? I was in the 3rd grade with a kid who had to go home for lunch because his mom couldn't come to school to nurse him!

Friday, Nov 14 at 6:40 PM Kathy wrote ...

Obviously this is a senseless death, IF this is the actual cause of death. This article states it COULD be the cause of death. And for all of the hateful comments directed to the family on here. This sounds as if it was an accident, and accidents do happen unfortunately. I am sure this family did not go to bed thinking I am going to roll over on my newborn and kill the baby! Use a little common sense when posting people! Sheesh!!

Friday, Nov 14 at 6:38 PM Enough Already! wrote ...

PLEASE STOP! The family feels bad enough. They don't need all of you judging them. Try having a heart people. You are just kicking them while they are down, so stop it. Prayer works so much better than criticism.

Friday, Nov 14 at 6:03 PM Maria Stoltfuz wrote ...

Dont ever sleep with a baby you could smash the baby with your body when sleeping we dont know that the baby is on the bed with us. So please young mothers use common sense and dont smash your babies and then cry out loud. Ask the pediatrician to help you and give you some tip on what to do when a baby cries. Poor people dont have enough rooms for babies much less special care mattress to buy they cant afford to do this things because they got no money. By goodness sakes, create an environment w

Friday, Nov 14 at 3:48 PM Mom of 5 wrote ...

Again.....stop judging and lecturing. Think of the family here people!! kind words...prayers....be nice. To the family: My heart goes out to you. May God be with you at this time, and may peace come to you in time.

Friday, Nov 14 at 2:49 PM lucy wrote ...

Hey Geeez-most accidents can be prevented-um like not having your baby in the same bed so you can roll over and smother it. You do NOT KNOW how you sleep, you're sleeping, how can anyone say they wouldn't roll over onto their child or they would know if they did? WRONG. Proven to be NOT SAFE. Isn't that enough? Isn't the safety of your children important to you people? If so, go buy a co-sleeper bassinet and you can have your baby right beside you, but just in their own little bed.

Friday, Nov 14 at 2:12 PM mad mama wrote ...

to any of that sweet baby boy's family who may still be reading through some of this garbage. it only matters what one person thinks, and that one person does not THINK he knows what happens, he does! God is with you and your blessed child. please don't pay attention to the garbage. move on and always remember your sweet baby boy is in heaven watching over u.

Friday, Nov 14 at 2:06 PM better solution wrote ...

I co-sleep with my babies, but they sleep in a bedside co-sleeping playpen. The one side is open and the mattress is level with my mattress. Because it has 3 sides, there is no way I can roll over onto my baby. Then when they reach the age of 8 wks I put the 4th side on it and they sleep in the bassinette till they are old enough for a crib. Very safe, and very affordable, and later doubles as a playpen. I'm sorry the baby passed, but if you co-sleep PLEASE do NOT put your baby in your bed!

Friday, Nov 14 at 2:01 PM mad mama wrote ...

if it's not safe at all to have your child sleep in the same bed as their parent please explain how so many parents out there sleep with their child in the bed and that child is fine no problems because of it. it all depends on the parent it is their choice. i do think that they have to be aware of what kinda sleeper they are before putting a child to bed with them. but putting a child in bed with u does not show intent to harm your child nor does it make you a lazy parent. get real people.

Friday, Nov 14 at 12:36 PM Rachel wrote ...

All of you who left these stupid comments blaming the parents need to get a life.

Friday, Nov 14 at 12:04 PM Geeez already... wrote ...

Some of these comments on here don't even make sense! Give this poor family a break...IF this is what happened, what a terrible ACCIDENT! Get a life folks, please. Prayers to this family, now they have a special angel watching over them.

Friday, Nov 14 at 11:49 AM lucy wrote ...

Sorry to say it-oh wait no I'm not...To the parents or people that think sleeping with babies in the same bed is safe and ok.. Well, that's insane. What are you people on? It's NOT safe at all-You DO NOT know what you are talking about. It's NOT SAFE AT ALL!!!--No matter what. If a 'new parent blog' says it's ok and safe, well, hate to break the news to ya but they're telling you a bunch 'o lies!!

Friday, Nov 14 at 11:33 AM Mom of 5 wrote ...

You people are such busy bodies!!! Judging parents' chioces the way you do is just plain wrong. It is NOT wierd to have your child sleep with you, especially if you are nursing. Who are any of you to decide what parents should or shouldnt do in their homes with their babies?? It's not like this child was killed by the hands of his mom. Imagine her heartbreak right now. Put your opinions aside and have some compassion for this family. Pray, share kind words... just dont be so quick to judge.

Friday, Nov 14 at 11:31 AM lucy wrote ...

If you think co-sleeping is necessary go to the store and buy a co-sleeper bed. They're like a bassinet that usually sits level with your bed. It's a safer way to co-sleep. They're right there with you (just not in the same bed)and plus the child still has the feeling they're in their own bed. P.S. Is 'Pnewmonia' worse than the 'old' pneumonia?

Friday, Nov 14 at 11:29 AM Anonymous wrote ...

I think that spell check and grammar check should be an option before anyone submits their comment!

Friday, Nov 14 at 11:21 AM You do better when you know better......we know now! wrote ...

I am sorry Fulton county that you feel offended, but I rode in a car without a seatbelt or carseat, rode my bike without a helmet, and yes, I am still alive. That does not make it right. It has been proven that MANY deaths could have been prevented IF co-sleeping did not happen. Why argue, if it could save ONE, just ONE baby is it not worth it. It really is only common sense, and all you have to do is read the newspaper to see how ofter it does occur. I love my children as much as you.

Friday, Nov 14 at 11:05 AM I am Zacks Aunt wrote ...

News Law everyone needs to back off. A lot of you know nothing.Zack passed of natural causes. print the facts not what you think.All parents want there babys close. no one knows how you feel losing a parent or loved one hurts But to lose a child is the worst thing ever i lost my baby 27yrs ago i know the pain. let them be and let them grieve.Not one parent can ever say they never layed with there child your a lier.I BEG YOU LET THIS FAMILY BE. DONT JUDGE A BOOK BY ITS COVER,

Friday, Nov 14 at 10:59 AM mad mama wrote ...

i had all three of my children in the bed with me when they were young no problems. some people shouldnt sleep with their child,but,I'm not seeing in this new story that rollover is the KNOWEN case of death. just that it looks like it might be a possibilty. every person i know going back to my great grandma has sleeped with there child in their bed at some time in their life, you just have to be aware to make it safe. let's all just pray for this family!

Friday, Nov 14 at 10:09 AM Anonymous wrote ...

Fulton Resident:just because you did it with 3 children doesn't make it the right thing to do. It's dangerous!! It's possible to comfort the child in other ways. My daughter NEVER slept with us and she grew up just fine. She has never had one nightmare and has had no sleep problems what-so-ever!

Friday, Nov 14 at 9:44 AM Chauncey wrote ...

What's your problem CH? You wake up this morning and finish your bowl of cereal before you realized those weren't two scoops of what you thought they were? No ones attacking anyone, just sharing experiences. So three of your kids slept with you and lived, GREAT! That's a good thing. Do you drive? People do that and sometimes die as well but you haven't, yet. Some of it's luck, some fate. Get over yourself and next time you sit down to breakfast forget the roses, give your cereal a sniff or two.

Friday, Nov 14 at 9:39 AM To 7:54 AM Fulton Resident wrote ...

You let your 10 year old in bed with you?! That's sick.

Friday, Nov 14 at 9:30 AM Mother Maggie Holms wrote ...

Never put a chld on the floor it will catch the flu or worse it may get pnewmonia and the doctor bills will be sky high to pay. The REv and Monika are not here, so the expert minds that are tapping along their little idiotic fingers are at work and ready to say anything. Confusious are you OK? Did you take prosak lately? You seem to be on the moon and coming back to see dear earth it is a shock to you. So.. let us pray for the little angel that has departed and really, have a heart for the famil

Friday, Nov 14 at 8:59 AM A Mom wrote ...

Back when my first son was born, 14 years ago, it was ENCOURAGED to co-sleep with him. I was nursing him, and the nurses at Memorial said that co-sleeping would be less disruptive for us all. It did work with both of my children...but after hearing about all of this, I do not think I would do it again. My prayers to this family.

Friday, Nov 14 at 8:44 AM Anonymous wrote ...

Wakie, wakie is right!! Honest to goodness, what do you think they make baby and children's beds for? I have a friend who lets her 5 yr old sleep with her. Weird!

Friday, Nov 14 at 8:10 AM Linda wrote ...

No one should really sleep with their child for this very reason. What is wrong with a bassenette in your room so the baby can be close. That is the reason they were made. Condolences to the family who lost your little one. Accidents do happen but this could have been prevented by putting the baby in a crib or bassenette in the first place.

Friday, Nov 14 at 7:54 AM Fulton resident wrote ...

My prayers go out to this family. I also have 3 children and slept with every one of them, My 10 year old still climbs in my bad because that is a safe place when scared or sick-and I go with that. Parents need to make their children feel safe from birth and mabey we would have alot less worthless kids. AT LEAST THESE PARENTS WERE WITH THEIR KIDS!

Friday, Nov 14 at 6:42 AM CH wrote ...

Well...I have co slept w/ all 3 of my children. They are still alive. They are healthy 2,4 and 6 year olds.I have NEVER been a heavy sleeper my whole life.This was never an issue of financial situation either. It was out of being a nursing Mom and wanting to be close to my child. I also can name 20 people in this town who have done this and their children are still alive. Accidents happen and so does crimes. So Leave those of us alone and only judge when you know ALL the facts.

Friday, Nov 14 at 1:16 AM Anonymous wrote ...

This is a very sad situation and I pray for the family. I know how easy it is to roll over on top of a baby and not realize it. I had my oldest son bed with me when I brought him home from hospital, he was 6 weeks old, and one night I rolled over on top of him, if it had not been for my mother checking in on us he could very well have died that night becuase I so deep in sleep (and no I was not on any kind drugs or alcohol) that I didn't even realize it.

Thursday, Nov 13 at 11:36 PM Sad For Family wrote ...

The story is so open ended that no conclusion can be drawn as to why the baby died. Were the parents on drugs? Was the other child allowed to sleep by the baby? Was drinking involved? The US is one of the few places in the world that doesn't see co-sleeping as normal. Most of the world does this and is a VERY safe practice if it is done correctly by responsible parents. Would you tell someone who's child died of SIDs that he could very well still be alive today if the family was co-sleeping?

Thursday, Nov 13 at 11:26 PM Anonymous wrote ...

The authorities are assuming that overlaying is what killed this baby, but they can't prove it. Are they positive the child did NOT die from SIDS? I think they shouldn't assume what killed the child and then put it in the news that it was the parents fault unless they can prove it. It isn't right to judge someone without positive proof. I am guessing these parents feel bad enough as it is.

Thursday, Nov 13 at 11:02 PM k wrote ...

You have got to be kidding me Granger. My husband wanted our first born to sleep with us and that same night I caught him rolling on top of her and not even know it. He is such a heavy sleeper he would have never woke up had I been asleep at the time. Stop being so quick to blame drugs! Some people never cease to amaze me:(

Thursday, Nov 13 at 9:42 PM Granger wrote ...

I disagree, the parents need to be drug tested for any kind of prescription meds or anything...I slept with both my children and they have done studies and watched the parents on videos while they sleep, the mother even in her deep sleep will move herself around so as not to roll on the child. It is nonsense to tell others not to sleep with their children. Parents should do what they feel is best. These parents had another child in the bed...or could have been on sleep meds, who knows...

Thursday, Nov 13 at 9:31 PM Senseless Selfish Deaths... wrote ...

All for some stupid 'idea' of 'comforting' the child??? that's NUTS! Wakie-Wakie people! FACT: Every Single One of these children would be alive today had they NOT been sleeping with parents or siblimgs. PERIOD. PERIOD. PERIOD. END. GET IT? unbelievable and tragic.

Thursday, Nov 13 at 8:20 PM bull wrote ...

I'm sorry, but what a senseless death. Babies belong in their own beds. If you don't have a bed, put them on a blanket on the floor. It would be safer than in an adult bed with 3 other people. There are many non-profits out there that help people get baby gear and supplies. Senseless!

Thursday, Nov 13 at 7:38 PM Renee wrote ...

While I appreciate the story and investigating the cause as well as the warning to other parents, I suggest further reading. Every parent website I read while I was pregnant said it is fine to sleep with your child but you must be careful. If you are overweight, drink, smoke, etc., it is not a good idea to sleep with your child. It is terrible this baby died and perhaps the only thing that could have prevented it was not sleeping with the baby.

Thursday, Nov 13 at 6:58 PM Cornfusion wrote ...

This is a practice that many single parent, or any family having serious financial struggles are utilizing. They heat one room at night and pool whatever blankets or covers they can scrounge to huddle under together for body warmth. It's sadder than sad and will be happening a lot more as people have to choose between food or heat, fuel for the car or rent, and so on. It's very real and before Rev This or Monica That gets their little imbecilic fingers tapping, DON'T. You want to pray, pray!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

WSBT and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, or remove user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum. Items that may be considered inappropriate to post are those containing profanity, hatred, or insensitive, vulgar, unlawful or threatening comments.

WSBT Weather

icon
Current Temp 26
°
More Weather
More On Demand

Stock Quotes

YouNews

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.
This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

Tonight On WSBTFull Schedule

7.00
Wheel of Fortune
7.30
Jeopardy!
8.00
Ghost Whisperer
9.00
Flashpoint
10.00
Numb3rs
11.00
WSBT News
11.35
Late Show with David Letterman

Question of The Day

Will 2009 be a better year for the RV industry?

E-mail your comments. We'll pick some to read during WSBT News at 5.

  • Yes
  • No