Keep secret Arizona money out of California politics

A California PAC that opposes Prop. 30 and supports Prop. 32 received $11 million from an Arizona nonprofit. But who really gave the money?

SACRAMENTO — Let's see. Maybe: "Money Launderers for Campaign Finance Reform." No, that probably wouldn't sell.

Could try: "Tax Exempt Fat Cats Against Higher Taxes for School Kids." Nope. That one doesn't have the right ring, either.

There's always: "California Reformers Against Special Interests and Higher Taxes." That's more traditional and has much better voter appeal.

INTERACTIVE: California propositions guide

This is all facetious, of course, sort of.

The real name is the Small Business Action Committee PAC, No on 30/Yes on 32. Citizens for Reforming Sacramento.

I especially chuckle at that last part. Reforming with laundered money.

You may have gotten a campaign flier or two in the mail from this outfit. Like all political junk mail — from the right or the left — it should be immediately tossed. They're pretty much all full of distortions and lies, designed to tell you whatever public-opinion surveys indicate would capture your vote.

The Small Business Action Committee PAC — which gets its money much less from small businesses than gazillionaires — picked up $11 million last week from an obscure Arizona nonprofit, non-taxable group called Americans for Responsible Leadership.

Who finances this organization? Nobody seems to know, at least in California. And, as of this writing, the people advocating responsible leadership were refusing to identify their donors.

"The problem," says Republican analyst Tony Quinn, a former member of the watchdog Fair Political Practices Commission, is that "unless we know where the money came from people are free to allege it came from anywhere, including Al Qaeda or the ayatollahs in Iran."

That's a little far-fetched. But maybe Mexican drug lords, for all we know.

The $11 million apparently is the largest anonymous political donation in the history of California.

Here's what happened: The so-called Americans for Responsible Leadership gave the secret money to the Small Business Action Committee PAC, headed by longtime anti-tax activist Joel Fox.

Fox is spending the money on opposing Proposition 30 and supporting Prop. 32. Some of the funds have been shuffled off to the anti-30 Californians for Reforms and Jobs. Not Taxes.

Love those names.

Prop. 30 is Gov. Jerry Brown's measure to temporarily raise upper-income and sales taxes to help schools and balance the budget. Prop. 32 is billed as an initiative to "stop special interest money" but in reality would cripple just one special interest: labor, both public and private sector.

"It's complete money laundering," said Brown, referring to the $11-million donation.

Responded Fox in his blog "Fox & Hounds:" A "desperate and politically motivated attack."

Well, yes. No argument about that. We are nearing the climax of the political season.

Fox probably wouldn't have accepted the secret money if not for the overwhelming desire — shared by all political strategists — to triumph on election day.

For political pros, it's like the immortal Green Bay Packers coach Vince Lombardi often said: "Winning isn't everything, it's the only thing." (Actually, UCLA coach Red Sanders said it first.)

So why doesn't Fox just disclose the individual donors of the eye-popping $11 million?

It's not his place, says his spokeswoman, Beth Miller. The small business committee "has disclosed all of its donors according to law." The donor of the $11 million was the Arizona group.

And Fox, Miller insists, didn't ask who the individual Arizona donors were. Why not? "He doesn't have to know," she says.

There's a dispute about whether the Arizona group must disclose its money sources. Miller says it doesn't have to.

But Ann Ravel, chairwoman of the Fair Political Practices Commission, says that if the donors knew the money was earmarked for a state election campaign, they were required to identify themselves. If it had been for a federal campaign, they wouldn't have.

The Arizona donors could claim they didn't know their $11 million was going to be spent on politics, but that wouldn't pass the laugh test. The money certainly wasn't meant for the homeless or for Lakers tickets.

"We think it's a circumvention" of the law, Ravel told me. "This is patently outrageous.

"When so much money is being spent to influence an election in California from outside of California — but even if it's not outside the state — the voters have a right to know who is behind the effort.

"Knowing who is supporting messages can tell voters a lot about whether or not they should support the message. They can get a voting cue."

Common Cause of California, a true reform group, formally requested the FPPC to unmask the Arizona donors. And Ravel told me she intends to try.

Fox, defending the secrecy in his blog, tried to equate the hidden Arizona contributors with "the out-of-state Lance Armstrong Foundation which gave $1.5 million in undisclosed donations" to Prop. 29, the June primary measure that would have increased the cigarette tax to pay for cancer research.

But that argument doesn't wash. The name Lance Armstrong told voters plenty about the source of the donation. The tag Americans for Responsible Leadership tells them nothing.

Contributors often try to hide their identity because they could be an embarrassment to the campaign they're trying to help bankroll.

Or they're afraid of retaliation by the opposite side — maybe even a governor. Tough. That's politics. As Harry Truman famously said, "If you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen."

One more old quote: "Sunshine is the best disinfectant" — the late Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis.

The sun should shine on this $11 million or it ought to be buried back in Arizona.

george.skelton@latimes.com

la-me-cap-money-20121025
 

News Poll

Should Attorney General Eric Holder resign?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Undecided

Top Viral Videos

Bear ate my camera » Bear ate my camera Soldier surprises daughter during Tampa Bay Rays first pitch » Soldier surprises daughter during Tampa Bay... Two-year-old girl sings Pearl Jam song » Two-year-old girl sings Pearl Jam song Texas tornado caught on video » Texas tornado caught on video Gas station karaoke on 'Pumpcast News' » Gas station karaoke on 'Pumpcast News' Deer goes for a bus ride » Deer goes for a bus ride Astronaut Chris Hadfield returns to Earth » Astronaut Chris Hadfield returns to Earth Man catches flying bird with his hand » Man catches flying bird with his hand Kitchen meltdown on 'Kitchen Nightmares' » Kitchen meltdown on 'Kitchen Nightmares' Woman kicked off plane for singing Whitney Houston song » Woman kicked off plane for singing Whitney... Nationals' Bryce Harper runs into wall » Nationals' Bryce Harper runs into wall Kanye West walks into a pole » Kanye West walks into a pole Suspect in Mother's Day parade shooting caught on surveillance video » Suspect in Mother's Day parade shooting... Castro's brothers interview with CNN » Castro's brothers interview with CNN Astronaut Chris Hadfield sings David Bowie's 'Space Oddity' from space » Astronaut Chris Hadfield sings David Bowie'... Kid President has a message for moms on Mother's Day » Kid President has a message for moms on... Man born with no arms throws out first pitch » Man born with no arms throws out first pitch Jodi Arias' first post-verdict interview » Jodi Arias' first post-verdict interview Police dispatch call from Cleveland home where girls were held » Police dispatch call from Cleveland home... Kiss cam breakup at Fresno Grizzlies game » Kiss cam breakup at Fresno Grizzlies game J.A. Happ hit in head by line drive » J.A. Happ hit in head by line drive Zachary Quinto vs. Leonard Nimoy: 'The Challenge' » Zachary Quinto vs. Leonard Nimoy: 'The... 'Clouds' celebrity cover » 'Clouds' celebrity cover Justin Bieber attacked on stage during concert in Dubai » Justin Bieber attacked on stage during... Interview with neighbor that helped Cleveland women escape » Interview with neighbor that helped Cleveland... Gov. Rick Perry's NRA intro video » Gov. Rick Perry's NRA intro video Orb wins Kentucky Derby 2013 » Orb wins Kentucky Derby 2013 Video: Reese Witherspoon arrest (dash cam video) » Video: Reese Witherspoon arrest (dash cam... Disabled dog welcomes airman home from deployment » Disabled dog welcomes airman home from... Reporters 'sex' slip during live report » Reporters 'sex' slip during live report Wil Wheaton on being a nerd » Wil Wheaton on being a nerd Tommy Lasorda not impressed by Psy performance » Tommy Lasorda not impressed by Psy... Amanda Knox speaks out for the first time » Amanda Knox speaks out for the first time Graphic video shows plane crashing at Bagram air field » Graphic video shows plane crashing at... Jason Collins talks about being gay in the NBA » Jason Collins talks about being gay in the... Camel tries to eat little girl » Camel tries to eat little girl Willie Nelson's 'Hobbit 2' audition tape » Willie Nelson's 'Hobbit 2' audition tape Steven Spielberg's 'Obama' » Steven Spielberg's 'Obama' Conan O'Brien at White House Correspondent's Dinner » Conan O'Brien at White House Correspondent'... President Obama at White House Correspondents' Dinner » President Obama at White House... Sheep or dog? » Sheep or dog? Michael Buble sings in NYC subway » Michael Buble sings in NYC subway Barbara Bush speaks out on potential Jeb run » Barbara Bush speaks out on potential Jeb run Kate McKinnon as Ellen on 'Ellen' » Kate McKinnon as Ellen on 'Ellen' Meteor lights up Argentina » Meteor lights up Argentina Police officer saves man from being hit by train » Police officer saves man from being hit by... Building pong » Building pong Evian's dancing babies » Evian's dancing babies Chinese journalist leaves own wedding to report on earthquake » Chinese journalist leaves own wedding to... Thermal images from search for Boston marathon bombing suspect » Thermal images from search for Boston... Neil Diamond sings 'Sweet Caroline' at Fenway Park » Neil Diamond sings 'Sweet Caroline' at Fenway... Boston Bruins fans sing National Anthem » Boston Bruins fans sing National Anthem Texas blast caught on cellphone » Texas blast caught on cellphone Cat does not want to wake up » Cat does not want to wake up New 'Man of Steel' movie trailer » New 'Man of Steel' movie trailer Actress Allison Brie recreates famous memes » Actress Allison Brie recreates famous memes Conan O'Brien addresses Boston Marathon bombing in monologue » Conan O'Brien addresses Boston Marathon... Explosions at Boston Marathon » Explosions at Boston Marathon Dog wants a kitty » Dog wants a kitty Psy's 'Gentleman' » Psy's 'Gentleman' Kmart 'Ship My Pants' commercial » Kmart 'Ship My Pants' commercial Woodchuck eats an ice cream cone » Woodchuck eats an ice cream cone Lindsay Lohan talks to Letterman about going to rehab » Lindsay Lohan talks to Letterman about... President Obama hosts Memphis soul concert at White House » President Obama hosts Memphis soul concert at... Weird compliments prank » Weird compliments prank 2013 NCAA 'One Shining Moment' » 2013 NCAA 'One Shining Moment' Andy Dick's Viennese Waltz brings DWTS judge to tears » Andy Dick's Viennese Waltz brings DWTS... What happens when you cry in space? » What happens when you cry in space? Dancing for a prom date » Dancing for a prom date Heartwarming touchdown » Heartwarming touchdown 'Kid President' meets President Obama » 'Kid President' meets President Obama Kevin Ware presents 'Top 10 List' on Letterman » Kevin Ware presents 'Top 10 List' on... Headless at the drive-thru prank » Headless at the drive-thru prank ESPN video shows Rutgers coach berating, hitting players » ESPN video shows Rutgers coach berating,... Conrad Murray speaks, and sings, to Anderson Cooper » Conrad Murray speaks, and sings, to...