Jury deliberates in Ohio microwaved-baby case

By JAMES HANNAH, Associated Press Writer

Tools

By Beth Boehne

DAYTON, Ohio (AP) — A mother intentionally put her month-old daughter in a microwave oven and cooked the child to death after a fight with her boyfriend, a prosecutor told jurors Thursday.

Defendant China Arnold and her boyfriend had argued over whether he was the biological father, Assistant Montgomery County prosecutor Daniel Brandt said during closing arguments in the woman's three-week retrial. The argument got so intense that Arnold bit her boyfriend's lip and he slapped her, Brandt said.

Arnold later told a cellmate she put the infant in the microwave and turned it on because she was worried her boyfriend would leave her if he found out the child wasn't his, Brandt said.

"She could have stopped it with one finger, but she didn't," he said. "We know she used that microwave as the instrument of death."

Arnold, 28, of Dayton, has pleaded not guilty to a charge of aggravated murder in the 2005 death of Paris Talley and could face the death penalty if convicted. A judge declared a mistrial in Arnold's first trail earlier this year.

Jurors in the retrial deliberated for about four hours. They were to be sequestered Thursday night and expected to resume deliberations Friday.

Defense attorney Jon Paul Rion told the jury Thursday there was evidence that someone else was responsible.

He cited Tuesday's testimony from an 8-year-old boy who said he saw another boy walk into the kitchen of a nearby apartment with the baby, heard the microwave go on, and then later saw the burned baby in the microwave.

"He told a very believable story," Rion said. "There wasn't any question in his mind."

With the small black microwave oven sitting just feet from the jury, Assistant Montgomery County prosecutor David Franceschelli said Arnold intentionally put her baby inside.

Prosecutors said the baby was cooked in the microwave for at least two minutes. Franceschelli pretended to turn the microwave oven on and then held up his watch to the jurors, counting down the time in increments of 30 seconds.

"Would you push it (off) now? Now?' he asked the jurors. One began fidgeting. Another dropped his gaze to the floor.

Prosecutors said the baby's DNA was found inside the microwave in Arnold's apartment, and Arnold's cellmate testified during the first trial that Arnold confessed. The cellmate's videotaped testimony was shown at the retrial.

Judge John Kessler declared a mistrial Feb. 11 after he privately heard testimony from the juvenile who testified Tuesday.

In rebuttal, the 8-year-old's mother testified Wednesday that they lived some distance away and they were not at Arnold's apartment complex when the baby died. Her former live-in boyfriend also testified that he was certain the boy was not at the location.

"Sometimes kids make up things," Franceschelli said.

As she entered the courtroom earlier Thursday, Arnold smiled and waved to family members. At times during the prosecution's arguments, she shook her head in disagreement and also glared at a police detective who had questioned her during the investigation.

Rion told the jury that the maternal instinct is the strongest of human instincts and that it defies logic that Arnold would kill her baby. He said police investigators targeted Arnold from the beginning and made it their objective to build a case against her.

Friday, Aug 29 at 10:25 PM CG wrote ...

I cannot believe this woman. I am speechless. My opinion... Put her in an oven and let her know how it feels.

Friday, Aug 29 at 7:56 PM anonymous wrote ...

that so sad to here this. what is wroug with the mom this is her child how could any one do this to there child.

Friday, Aug 29 at 10:42 AM Anonymous wrote ...

South Bend should have an outdoor prison, like the one in Texas, prisoners live in tents , PB&J for lunch, toast for breakfast, dinner soup. Maybe if these people realize life isn't so good on the inside they would think before doing things like this

Friday, Aug 29 at 9:31 AM Maynard Griffith wrote ...

UNBELEIVABLE , that a mother could do this to her own child .Microwave would have cooked this little one from the inside out , no doubt a cruciating terrible death. there is no excuse she should fry...

Friday, Aug 29 at 7:47 AM Bethany wrote ...

I can't figure out what the heck there is to deliberate!! The jury discussed this for 4 hours yesterday and will resume today?! What the heck?! Fry her! This is by far one of the most horrific things I ahve ever heard.

Friday, Aug 29 at 7:45 AM Anonymous wrote ...

i agree cook her but do it slow though

Friday, Aug 29 at 5:51 AM DMC wrote ...

Save our money and let the chair do the work. I agree with Anonymous (on lawyers)...how could someone become a criminal defendant and defend these people that are so sick and heartless?

Thursday, Aug 28 at 10:05 PM MS wrote ...

I am so sick thinking about this. I can't imagine anyone being so heartless and cruel. Animals love their babies more than some human beings love their children. This woman deserves to sit in the electric chair and fry. To support her in a prison with our tax dollars would be way too good for her. God bless this little baby's soul.

Thursday, Aug 28 at 3:31 PM Anonymous wrote ...

people are so unbelievably stupid! maybe they should put the mother in a microwave and cook her to death! an eye for an eye always worked in the past...until lawyers and judges came along!

Thursday, Aug 28 at 2:22 PM Nane wrote ...

Save the taxpayors money for attorneys and court costs she admitted doing this ,, life in prison (an Outside One in the dessert) would work well for her

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

Comments are moderated and will not appear on this story until after they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

WSBT and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

WSBT Weather

icon
Current Temp 22
°
More Weather
More On Demand

Stock Quotes

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

Tonight On WSBTFull Schedule

7.00
Wheel of Fortune
7.30
Jeopardy!
8.00
NCIS
9.00
The Mentalist
10.00
Without A Trace
11.00
WSBT News
11.35
Late Show with David Letterman

Question of The Day

Do you think Notre Dame should keep Charlie Weis?

E-mail your comments. We'll pick some to read during WSBT News at 5.

  • Yes
  • No